Best Car Insurance Companies

The Contenders: Page 2

21 Acceptance

Very friendly, personal, and informative staff. I enjoyed the choices that were given to me and how my coverages suited my needs and budget. I am a non-standard customer and my rate compared to the other non-standard insurance companies was lower & I received better customer service.

Extraordinary customer service through and through! This is one of the few places that I've shopped where I really felt like the agents listened to me and understood my needs. My only regret is not checking them out sooner.

Visit Website
22 Arbella Insurance Visit Website
23 Farm Bureau Insurance

Farm Bureau has paid every claim we have had fairly and quickly. I hydroplaned after a tire blew out and my Honda flew over an deep embankment and landed upright but the damage was significant. Again, I was easing out of a parking place at a restaurant when a large pickup blew through the lot and couldn't stop. My car was a total loss and Farm Bureau gave me what seemed to be more than they needed to based on my research of my car's worth. A third time, I bumped someone at a right turn stop sign and they took care of the dent on the other car, no questions asked. If I were them, I would refer me to another company, but they continue to offer great service at an very fair price and have just insured our new condo at an excellent rate..

Paid every claim we had with no problems. We were involved in agriculture and had several accidents. One involved one of our trucks hitting a gasoline carrier. Brakes on our truck went out on a crossroad and tore open the gas truck. Closed main highway for about 3 hours. Farm Bureau took care or it all.

We were rear ended by a driver with Farm Bureau insurance. My wife and I both had injuries, and Farm Bureau were compassionate and efficient in quickly making sure that we had sufficient money to pay our medical expenses.

Have had them for 16 years, they have the best rates. great customer service and they truly care

V 2 CommentsVisit Website
24 Infinity Insurance

Sucks to be the guy you hit but it's cheap.

Visit Website
25 Erie Insurance

Working with insurance adjusters on a daily basis, I couldn't image carrying insurance through any other company. I find Erie to be the most likely to settle claims, which makes me feel extremely well-covered when I'm on the road. I know that if something happens, and the other person doesn't have insurance, my company will take care of me without pushing back or thinking of dropping me. I love ERIE!.

I have had ERIE for auto and home owners for 35+ years. Having done comparisons from time to time, I have not been able to get better rates and coverage for my dollar spent. Their claims service, to me, is outstanding. They are truly "Above All in Service" The only draw back is that they are somewhat regional.

We have been with Erie for 20+ years now. It's nice to see that they don't have the huge marketing budget that some other companies have. Because of that my rates are low and have had a few comp claims with no issues at all. Just remember those funny commercials are paid for by you!

Been with erie for years and let me tell you they are definitely the cheapest insurance around.

V 11 CommentsVisit Website
26 Elephant Insurance

We used to have Geico. We have a clean driving record no accidents and our insurance goes up. So we changed to Elephant and love it! And it is a whole lot less with the same coverages.

Visit Website
27 Auto-Owners Insurance

I've dealt with them on two homeowner claims (for my grandmother) and three auto claims (a $68k uninsured motorist claim and a broken windshield claim on my cars and my mom's car after she hit a deer). These claims have spanned the last nine years and each one was handled with a high level of professionalism, but also with decency, kindness and compassion. They are truly an honest company that pays the claims they owe quickly and fairly. When I was injured by the uninsured motorist in 2010, the first thing my attorney said when he saw that I had A-O was "you have nothing to worry about, they will take care of you."

Actually pay claims. Even when on an older vehicle with little damage.

The rates are much better on a Homeowners policy than I have ever had with State Farm or Grange. Great agents also.

I've had nothing but great experience with Auto-Owners. They are not as widely known, or they would be much higher on the list.

V 3 CommentsVisit Website
28 Shelter Insurance Visit Website
29 Mercury

ALTHO they did not give me discounts, at least they did not charge an arm and a LEG after my one accident. Mercury has been faithful and very helpful when I am a couple days late on payment. DARN ALLSTATE! They paid the other party over and over and over, even though the damage to my fender was worse, they only had a slight tap on rear end, but got FULL VALUE for their 'destroyed' car, and all 5 occupants got PT and chiropractic visits 3x each. I WAS ANGRY! They were not injured, and the car was repairable. But Mercury came through and gave me a good deal for the upcoming years!

Mercury gave me a lower auto insurance quote than any of the others that I have checked that are ranked higher on this list.

Visit Website
30 Pekin Visit Website
31 California Casualty

They have the lowest complaint ratio in California. They mainly market to teachers, police officers, fire fighters, and nurses. They're also endorsed by the NEA and California Teacher's Association. They're a great family owned company!

California Casualty is a great company! Association based, they work with teachers, fire fighters, policemen and nurses. They have to adhere to a higher standard when responding to claims so they don't lose their endorsements. They are endorsed by over 1k associations nationwide. They also have the NEA endorsement. 97% claims satisfaction.

We have worked with Calcas for over 20 years and have been completely satisfied with our rates and coverage.

Visit Website
32 Wawanesa

Been with them for over 10 years. The customer service is great, response time is excellent, and the cost of coverage is outstanding.

Cheapest insurance and good service, too. They were there when I needed them, professional, and very efficient.

I've been with Wawanesa for years and you can't beat their prices or customer service in handling claims.

Best price out there

V 2 CommentsVisit Website
33 Safe Auto

Man my insurance (Safe Auto) needs to get ranked up! - wefixbadcredit1

Yes, I completely agree

Nice service at a great price.

Visit Website
34 Lincoln Insurance Visit Website
35 EMC Visit Website
36 Encompass

I have been with State Farm for 35 yrs. And it's time for a change. I rec'd my new premium and it increased $341... Encompass was less than half.
Since they are a subsidiary of Allstate and their reviews are good, I will be going with them. State Farm has been good for me, but now in 2013, I can't afford to be paying out all these increases for exactly the same coverage... Bye, bye SF xoxoxo

Visit Website
37 Pemco

Awesome insurance and great coverage. You will know their goodness if you ever need your car repaired. Even in a not my fault accident, PEMCO provided all the assistant needed in dealing with other person's insurance.

Cheap insurance. Paid above market value for my car when I totalled it. Good costumer service. Generally a great company, Though I am forced to get new insurance after getting a dui. Overall great care.

Visit Website
38 Access General Insurance

Worst insurance company. Never get insurance with them.

First time getting this insurance so far it's been good!

Visit Website
39 COUNTRY Financial Visit Website
40 Hanover

Hanover auto insurance policy for an entire year covering two cars and and two drivers was less than 50% of what Progressive wanted for a year for both of us.

Visit Website
PSearch List

Related Lists

Best UK Car Insurance Companies Best Car Insurance Companies In India Top Ten Best Car Companies Best Life Insurance Companies Best Health Insurance Companies

List StatsUpdated 19 Jan 2017

8,000 votes
59 listings
8 years, 71 days old

Top Remixes (21)

1. Allstate
2. Nationwide
3. AAA
pachechak
1. State Farm
2. GEICO
3. AAA
meenarai
1. Progressive
2. State Farm
3. Nationwide
FerrariDude64

WRemix
View All 21

Posts

Tips to Save Money on Insurance
credit-repair
Allstate Has Been Fantastic for Us
visitor
Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.
P