Best Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream Flavors

Don't agree with the list? Vote for an existing item you think should be ranked higher or if you are a logged in, add a new item for others to vote on or create your own version of this list.

The Top Ten

1
Phish Food
The best flavor of all time. The marshmallow is so gooey and delicious, the fudge fish are amazing, and the caramel is perfect. All in the greatest flavor of any ice cream: chocolate.
Me and my best friend, Grace wanted to know what was the best Ben and Jerry's ice cream so we went on to the internet and we both wanted it to be 'Phish Food' because we both love it. Yum!
So GOOD everyone should try it its the best ice cream next to cold stone =) The marshmallows chocolate and caramel melt right in your mouth!
More comments about Phish Food

2Cookie Dough
I'm eating it right now. If cookie dough was an actual person I would marry it. It is heaven in a tub. Cookie dough is the best ice cream ever to be created. Praise the lord for the person who created this flavor.
Cookie dough sounds kind of good but believe me, If you tried cookies and liked them this flavour is for you. With the finest chunks of cookies and delicious Vanilla Ice cream, you'll L-O-V-E this yummy flavour.
the best
you haven't lived without it!
More comments about Cookie Dough

3Chunky Monkey
M... The creamy banana ice cream, great high quality chocolate pieces and crunchy walnuts together can't be beat!
As a kid, I loved the flavors of banana & chocolate together & this ice cream brings back memories! With the addition of huge raw walnuts to cut the sweetness from the banana ice cream & big chocolate chunks, this ice cream is simply amazing to me.
There was a buy two chunky monkeys for the price of one at target and... A person cannot fathom my happiness at that moment. I am eating those chunky monkeys for lunch right now! :) so much joy!
More comments about Chunky Monkey

4Chocolate Fudge Brownie
So so delish. So chocolatey I can't live without it. It tastes like heaven. My house loves it.
if there was one thing I could live on it would be this fliping awesome fav toltaly 10 out of 10 ice cream heven

bloodskull

its totally awesome dude
so good I left wife for it
More comments about Chocolate Fudge Brownie

5Half Baked
Me and my girlfriend just had a pint of this right after having sex. We're deciding which was better
The most awesome flavor ever invented! Its just so good with all the flavor combinations and every time I eat it, I want more. This should be the top flavor.
are you kidding :O? not top five? The three best things in the world: cookies brownies and ice cream
More comments about Half Baked

6Cherry Garcia
So Smooth With Bits Of Cherries And Just The Right Amount Of Chocolate Pieces And Not To Sweet But Just Perfect... Love It. I Buy In Single Serve 1/2 Cup Because If I didn't I Would Eat What Ever I buy All At One time
The BEST!
Of best B^^J's ice cream so delicious half cherry half chocolate and with caramel it's better.
It is the perfect mix of textures from the crunchy chocolate to the soft cherry bites, and the perfect balance of sweetness and creaminess. I could easily eat a whole tub of this!
More comments about Cherry Garcia

7Baked Alaska
I love baked alaska its packed with yummy mini white choc polar bears I think there cute this flavour is best for the people that have a sweet tooth
This is amazing! I love the white chocolate and marshmallow swirls. The best ice cream by far! Congratulations Ben and Jerry on such a fabulous flavour. It is utterly delicious.
I was wondering where this awesome flavour was as I read down the list... Finally to find it at number six, NUMBER SIX? Shocking! Number one any day in my opinion!
More comments about Baked Alaska

8Coconutterly Fair
Absolutely delicious! Chocolatey but not heavy with a sweet, light crunch. And what's better it's (cocon) utterly fair

9Fossil Fuel
Just so the best the sweet cream ice cream the treacle peace signs the delicious chunks of cookies and a fudge swirl. Just heaven.

cameronbrown


10New York Super Fudge Chunk
The Extraordinarily rich Chocolate flavor of the ice cream and the ice creams smoothness are the start. I read recently where New York Super Fudge Chunk was the number two flavor behind Phish Phood. Who knows? I bought Phish Phood tonight just to get the taste of number one. I will try it later. Then comes the slabs of white and dark chocolate and the nuts.
I love to let the white chocolate melt in my mouth, its extra sweet contrasting with the dark chocolate ice cream taste and the dark chocolate chunks melting too. And then the crunch and taste of the nuts. N Y S F C has been my favorite flavor for many years.
Absolutely delicious dark chocolate ice cream with the kick of chocolate covered almonds is amazing. Also, don't forget the dark and white chocolate chunks! They melt in your mouth and tastes like heaven! All of them mixed together is just the best flavor you could ever taste and dream of. The first scoop of that ice cream just gives you the chills and you just want to eat the whole pint. Well, that is New York Super Fudge Chunk to you!
No doubt. The very best flavor of all. No other flavor comes close.
More comments about New York Super Fudge Chunk

The Contenders

11Strawberry Cheesecake
I had doubts about what it would taste like but my friends said it was good. When I tried it was really
Surprised that it actually tasted like cheesecake! Its been far my favourite yet! My first impression was that ITS AMAZING! Whenever I get an ice cream in good strait to the strawberry cheesecake. Best invention ever!
HOW IS THIS NOT #1? Best flavor of all time. Fantastic cheesecake ice cream, sweet strawberries, buttery graham cracker crust, and smooth cheesecake pieces. A mouth-gasm every bite.
Exquisitely delicious, I finally tried it last night and it was better than I expected. Deserves top 3
More comments about Strawberry Cheesecake

12Mint Chocolate Chunk
I LOVE Mint chocolate chip ice cream! I am a total sucker for it!
MY FAVORITE FLAVOR! It just screams VOTE FOR ME! VOTE FOR ME!
I LOVE THIS FLAVOR! VOTE VOTE VOTE!
More comments about Mint Chocolate Chunk

13Cheesecake Brownie
Tastes exactly like a cheesecake with brownies most realistic flavor by far

14Mint Chocolate Cookie

15Milk & Cookies
Mm I love milk and cookies ice cream even more the chocolate which for me is saying a lot

hollyleafforever

Like an orgasm in a pint!
Best ice cream flavor I have ever had.

16Coffee Coffee Buzz Buzz Buzz
Absolutely the best! I am addicted. I drive around store to store when sold out in my local market! Just the right amount of coffee flavor with espresso bean flavor with huge chocolate chunks. Please don't resign this flavor!
Coffee AND Chocolate!? Definitely my favorite flavor!
I don't buy any other flavors besides this one.
More comments about Coffee Coffee Buzz Buzz Buzz

17S'mores
In general, I could easily eat a pint of ice cream, but s'mores REALLY REALLY REALLY makes me want to eat the whole thing. The rich chocolate ice cream, delicious fudge chunks, marshmallows and gooey graham cracker concoction - you really can't ask for anything more...other than another pint.
Probably too sweet for some, but it is my favorite. The graham cracker swirl is the best part. If there are six of these in the grocer's freezer case, six will come home with me.
The best EVER. Try TODAY.

18Banana Split
It is easier than making a banana split at home. The only thing you need is a spoon. I love banana splits. YUM
The banana really split in My mouth
Its like a party in my mouth

19Everything But The...
I love Ben and Jerry's ice cream and I've had lots of different kinds but this one is my favorite. Full peanut butter cups, white chocolate, vanilla and chocolate ice creams, fudge covered almonds... What's not to love!
Best flavor of ALL time. I'm devastated when my market is sold out!
Hands down my favorite!
More comments about Everything But The...

20Turtle Soup

Delicous the chocolate turtles are cool and the caramel chunks and the mint leaves are quality

cameronbrown


21AmeriCone Dream
AmeriCone Dream is the BEST flavor. If you haven't tried it you have to! It has caramel and fudge covered bits of ice cream cone. In addition to being AMAZING, all the proceeds from this flavor go to charity. The only reason this flavor isn't #1 is not enough people have tried it!
Hands down the best B&J flavor, and I've tried them all! Their vanilla ice cream is amazing, almost like soft serve, and the mix of ingredients is perfect! Like eating a "Drumstick" in a pint container!
This flavor is AMAZING! What is not to love about caramel vanilla icecream full of chocolate covered waffle pieces in almost every bite. Plus who to have represent it none other than Stephen Colbert himself. You just can't say no to the Colbert!
More comments about AmeriCone Dream

22Caramel Chew Chew
The best, sweetest, most refreshing and satisfying flavour in all of human history, without a question.
Feels like heaven :P

23Coffee Heath Bar Crunch
Can't believe this isn't #1
It just really hits the spot after indulging with some of my favorite herb.
A sweet and salty flavor that simply can not be beat!
More comments about Coffee Heath Bar Crunch

24Chubby Hubby
SERIOUSLY! THIS ICE CREAM IS AMAZING!
It should be in the top ten!
It's like a normal ice cream but it has a sort of snack in it!
And really, who can resist chocolate, peanut butter, caramel and pretzels?
Chubby Hubby is like sex without all the sticky sweaty stuff : )
I will not live in a world where Cherry Garcia is in the top 10!
More comments about Chubby Hubby

25Cinnamon Buns
This tastes like heaven! It tastes more like a Snickerdoodle dough in caramel ice-cream than Cinnamon buns - there is absolutely nothing yeasty about it(that's a good thing).
Best flavour by far, they took it out of stores though! Little doughy pieces of cinnamony goodness are inside, Mmm m
It's amazing- cinnamon bun dough in caramel icecream? Sold!
More comments about Cinnamon Buns

26Late Night Snack
Simply the best. Fell in love with it while on holiday in the states and an just gutted that I never will get the chance to eat it again. Hate Fallon himself-much prefer Stephen Colbert-but adore Fallon's ice cream-and hate Colbert's ice cream, it tastes like cat droppings, but at least the proceeds go to charity, unlike Fallon's. Long story short, this ice cream is amazing!
Why was it discontinued?

27Chocolate Macadamia
The best, only thing to fight with my girl

28Red Velvet Cake
I love this flavor because, well, who doesn't just love red velvet cake? It's a southern favorite- now in the form of a delicious ice-cream flavor!

29Karamel Sutra
The most underrated of flavours; I cannot turn down that delicious caramel core, or the caramel ice cream on one side with chocolate chip on the other! Wow!
No way this should be ranked 25th.. Top 5 for sure. Wake up people!
Best ever ice cream!
More comments about Karamel Sutra

30Neapolitan Dynamite

31Cotton Candy
The Best & My Kids Love It... But we can Never Find It! Please Help
Love this ice cream should be year round flavor
Amazing! Please make it a year round flavor!

32Pistachio Pistachio
The best Pistachio ice cream ever. Sweet balanced with salty.
You Don't Even Know! Heaven!

33Chocolate

34Fairly Nuts

35Oatmeal Cookie Chunk
I can't find this flavor anywhere. I miss it so much. Can't go wrong with a vanilla ice cream cinnamon cookie raisin swirl. Ugh!

36Mission to Marzipan
Most almond-y flavored thing ever!

37Schweddy Balls

38Magic Brownies
TO THE PERSON WHO BOUGHT OUT ALL REMAINING STORES OF THIS FLAVOR: FFU! Also, do you have any left? And, can I come over, please? :(:(:( This was BY FAR the best flavor they've ever made. EVER! And apparently, it isn't coming back :(. I could cry. http://www.asha.org/Publications/leader/2013/130701/Convention-A-La-Mode.htm
The best ever. Last year, we bought out the remnants from last batch ever from the Vermont store in Waterbury. Fingers crossed that they bring it back some day.

39Imagine Whirled Peace
I like the ice cream flavor but hate how Yoko Ono is exploiting John Lennon's memory for money. I feel guilty liking this flavor.

40Willie Nelson's Peach Cobbler

Mr. Nelson would be pround of this flavor with his namesake. He could 'Go on the Road' with gallons of it.


41Vanilla Heath Bar Crunch
Why muddy up perfection... It's a perfect combo... And timeless

42Pumpkin Cheesecake
Better than any other pumpkin flavored dessert out there, let alone ice cream. When fall comes around, the shelf is always barren of this flavor. Grab it if you ever see it.

The pumpkin cheesecake ice cream is phenomenal. Not too much cheesecake or cinnamon flavor. Then add in the swirl of graham cracker crumbs.. It's amazing. You can try every other crazy flavor out there. Nothing beats this simple masterpiece.

This should be a permanent, year round flavor.
Best pumpkin ice cream. Ever. Wish it was more readily available--only found it at Walmart. The graham cracker swirls are heavenly mixed in with the perfect blend of pumpkin and cheesecake.

43Clusterfluff
How can this not be in the Top Ten!

Marshmallows and peanut butter chunks! Yum!

44What a Cluster
The dogs bollocks - but tastes better as the original, 'Clusterfluff'... Not sure why
Why do mom's across america have to rain on my clusterfluff

45Dublin Mudslide

46Mud Pie

47Triple Caramel Chunk

48Vanilla Caramel Fudge
Such simple goodness! What more can I say?..
Number one on my list. We buy them up when we see them at the store.
Slice up a banana put some VCF and top it off with whip cream with a cherry on top, ""

49Butter Pecan

50The Gobfather
Mm bring it back!

51Blondie Brownie
The core... Oh my god the core 😋

52Boston Cream Pie

53Vanilla

54Peanut Brittle

55Berried Treasure

56Berry White
Wow, my favourite by far

57Oh My Apple Pie!

58Clever Cookies

59Dough-ble Whammy

60Chocolate Peppermint Crunch

61Scotchy Scotch Scotch
I know this is a limited batch but it should up there with the regular flavors. I buy a pint every time I'm at the store. I have seven pints now. Please don't stop making this.
The little pieces in butterscotch candy remind me of being a kid. SO good. Love. Love. Love. Would pay top dollar to have it shipped to New Braunfels TX.

62Brownie Batter

63Jamaican Me Crazy

64Chocolate Therapy
This Ice Cream taste like a smooth chocolate moose.

65Coconut Seven Layer Bar

66Cannoli
People in S. Jersey and Philly area are buying up the limited batches... Best ice cream I've ever tasted and I don't eat ice cream, till Ben & Jerry's cannoli I f I find it I Bering it to friends and families home as the dessert and it goes over big TIME! My family and friends are always asking where they can get it and we look for places for one another.. Please keep it permanently!

67Volun-Tiramisu
Taste just like the cake has the cocoa and marscarpone cheese with chunks of lady fingers.. Another once you try you will be addicted! My all time favorite and I don't really eat ice cream is Cannoli 2 and tiramisu

68Peanut Butter Me Up
Eating this now! It is nice but a bit sickly.. Only eat a small bit! -taliajoy

69Liz Lemon
Perfect combo of some favorite light flavors!
So light and refreshing!

70Mississippi Mud Pie
Why is this not on? Its by far the best best best best ice cream in the world

71Dulce Delish

72Bonnaroo Buzz

73Hannah Teter's Maple Blondie

74Fair Goodness Cake

75Berry Nice

76Lemonade Sorbet

77Core Dough-Ble Whammy

78Winter Berry Brownie

79Cow Power

80Peanut Butter World

81Coffee Caramel Buzz

82White Russian
It's so simple but it's still the best coffee ice cream ever.

83Coffee Fudge Swirl

84Peanut Butter Cup
BEST FLAVOR EVER! I've tried so many flavors and nothing beats this one! The best part is the peanut butter ice cream! I always hate when the ice cream is just chocolate or vanilla in a peanut butter cup mix. The ice cream is so good it could stand alone and still be my favorite! But the rich peanuts butter cups are out of this world! And there's usually a generous amount which doesn't hurt one bit!
When our time is up on this earth, and the robotic archaeologists of tomorrow research into our lives, this ice cream flavour will be known as the greatest thing we have ever produced.
Easily the best flavor out there! The Ice Cream is absolutely delicious and the cups only add to the great taste! A must for all peanut butter lovers, I would really recommend this one
More comments about Peanut Butter Cup

85Key Lime Pie
Delicious

86Cake Batter

Comments About This List

Featured Lists
Popular Lists
New Lists

Top Remixes of This List

blaine4

cameronbrown

maggpie3476

matty16

Posts About This List

List Info

This list was created 4 years, 73 days ago and has been voted on over 2,000 times. This top ten list has been remixed 4 times.

Updated Saturday, April 19, 2014


List Error Reporting

See an item on this list that's misspelled, duplicated, or doesn't belong? Let us know. Click here to report the error.