Top 10 Creepypastas That Should Be Made Into Movies


The Top TenXW

1Jeff the KillerJeff the killer is a creepypasta usually accompanied by a picture of a white face looking in to the camera smiling in an unsettling manner . The creepypasta is also usually accompanied by the term "Go to sleep" .

They could pull this off, guys! If they can do it right, they can even add subplots about Jeff being picked on I school, not just by Randy, his parents arguing, him browsing through childhood photos after he kills his family and then breaks into tears with a permanent smile on his face, etc. They could make the "scary" idea of a boy going insane all the more tragic, sad, and overall heartbreaking to the point you just want to hug him.

Yes they NEED to make this.

Also, they could make Peter (the dad) abusive and it would make just another problem in Jeff's life.

Jeff should have his own movie, however it's only going to be good if it's done right. The story has to be from Jeff's point of view and start with how he came to be a killer in the first place. Then you have to focus on what sort of people he kills and what's going through his head/how he acts/why he kills them, then make something up based off that maybe sight other Jeff The Killer Fanfics or short films for other cases. That's how you make a good Jeff The Killer film, and DO NOT bring in Jane as a lover, that'll ruin it. Because no good killer actually has a love interest, they don't have time for that (See: other slasher films such as Halloween or Friday the 13th.)

Jeff should have his own movie! He's one of my favorite creepypastas and I think with his brother covering for him and going to jail, would definitely make a good "Guilt" scene and with him cutting his permanent smile onto his face. They could totally make this a movie.

I've had this idea for a long time now and a jeff the killer movie would just be perfect

V45 Comments
2The Smile Dog

If they made a movie of this I would imagine it as a mystery thriller vibe. It would have an investigator who visits the mom of a teenager who kills herself a week after seeing the picture. The investigator doubts that the picture had anything to do with the suicide and doubts that the picture is possessed but after seeing it himself he starts to be haunted by the dog in nightmares and is taunted to "spread the word"

I have read this story something like...12 times or more

Still scares me

Just the image is creepy in and of itself

This deserves a VERY good movie with a GOOD director and not some cheap ass director either

Its story is GOLD and deserves nothing but the best as a director

Smile, so cute... Anyway I would love to see it. It would be like a psychological suspenseful scary movie. If they make it they should have the main think he sees Smile everywhere. And he buys a Husky to help him feel safe but said Husky is Smile!

Smile dog should have his own movie, I imagine it as a thriller or drama sort of thing

V9 Comments
3Slender Man

This would be amazing! It would be so refreshing and different from your average cheap slash-horror movies, just like this CP is so different from all horror stories and urban legends that I've usually heard growing up.. Someone PLEASE make this into a movie!

I wish though they should try and make a slenderman origin story, also the movie would be hectic because maybe we can find where slenderman hides the bodies

This should be a movie. With all the creepy music and have a realistic looking slenderman not a mannequin. - HappyFlower

There is a Slender Man movie

V22 Comments

This could be played out like True Detective and Silence of the Lambs, with a much more dark and menacing theme that would feel like you are alone. - Drewstar

"1999" is my favorite creepypasta and I love movies 'til death, and seeing these two merge together would be, like, the most awesome movie ever made. - GaretTheCarrot

I really enjoyed reading this pasta. It was probably one of the best ones I have read so far, it would be cool to get a good director and actors to create it into a film.

Totally "1999" is an amazing story and it could definitely be a movie, it would probably make a lot of money too

V8 Comments
5Eyeless Jack

If there's a movie about him, I'm going to watch it (I know I'm going to have nightmares after that) - BlueFrostOfThunderClan

He is my favorite he needs to be in at least 1 or just a big one about them all!

Eyeless Jack is my favorite, it should definitely be made into a movie

They should totally make a movie about him

V13 Comments
6The Russian Sleep Experiment

I Might be making this into a short film at my school. We will need a lot of fake gory props.

If this was made into a film it would be one of the best and scariest movies of all time

Enough goes on in the story that a convincing movie could me made, and there is wiggle room already to add in extra details or scenes.

YES. Make this true creepypasta into a movie.

V16 Comments
7BEN Drowned

BENs' story as a movie would be interesting because we don't know how he drowned. His story could go two ways, a young boy with abusive parents who gets a 64 and Majoras' Mask as a gift from his grandfather to help get his mind off things but is later drowned in the tub by a drunken mom/dad. Or normal family situation normal life and BEN accidentally drowns either in the tub from slipping or drowns at the beach/pool and is just trying to explain to whomever picks up his game how he died.

This would make a great movie. It was so scary and one of the most believable stories ever on Creepypasta. Also... I think that they should make a movie with the RAKE, too

I would totally see "BEN Drowned" if it came out in theatres. It's such a fantastic creepypasta, it would be cool to see what they would do with it.

Someone is planning a BEN movie.

V15 Comments
8The Rake

Okay, I'll admit it, I'm a HUGE Ben Drowned fan. But I don't think think things like BEN or Smile dog would make good movies. Smile dog doesn't have enough to work off of for a movie, BEN already has creepy game plays, and you would need Nintendo's permission, and Jeff is super overrated. The Rake would scare me to death in a film.

... Who needs sleep anyway? I would love to see his (? ) story as a movie. So far thy have many documentaries on this guy (? ). My teacher showed us one for Halloween... I didn't know what we were watching until someone said the Rake.

The rake is not one of my favorite pastas but a horror movie about the rake would be awesome

The rake is gonna go well

V6 Comments
9The Strangest Security Tape I've Ever Seen

Would be a great short films or Sundance movie but not sure if it could be too long before people realize whats happening or get bored. but definitely this.

I can see it being made by a fan like a fan film not a really big production like warner bros or something like that lol

I just read the story, it was weird and scary, so it should be made into a movie

Why is this above penpal what

V6 Comments
10Ticci Toby

Here's the basic origin:

Toby grew up with several mental disorders during his childhood, making it difficult for him to fit in with "normal people". He was constantly bullied by his classmates for his tics and was ultimately deemed unsuited for a public school surrounding, so he switched to homeschooling. While he received plenty of support from his mother and older sister Lyra, his father was nothing but a negative influence on his son. Having lost himself to alcohol, drugs and gambling, Toby's father became increasingly abusive towards his family, especially Toby.

When Toby was seventeen, he and his sister were involved in a tragic car accident that resulted in Lyra's death. Toby's symptoms worsened greatly because of this; he lost his appetite for food, became even less social than before, and slowly began to lose his memories. On the night he returned from the hospital, Toby saw the Slender Man watching him from the street. Slender Man repeatedly stalked ...more

Toby is my favorite. This would make a great movie. I feel really bad about how toby's life went. With his sister dying and what his dad did to him.

Ticci Toby is the one creepypasta I can't find the origin of

Yes Toby is my favorite pasta and his story is one of my to favorites

V16 Comments

The Contenders

11Laughing Jack

I've seen a pretend trailer by the creator of Laughing Jack, and I have to say that it would be neat to have a movie. I would so watch it. I love Laughing Jack!

I think that Tim Burton could totally pull it off.

Laughing jack is the perfect creepy pasta to be turned into a short film

Yes! Tim Burton could do this really well.

V12 Comments
12Candle Cove

Well, they could easily pull this off. If they got some good actors, and good props, and made it well, the movie would definitely be watched.

Just a random thought but perhaps Tim Burton could do something like this.

Get Tim Burton On It and you got yourself a hit

Yes I think tim burton could do this too.

V1 Comment

I swear this would be the first horror movie that would scare me since this was one of the first creepypasta that made me both scared and curious it would be awesome if directed by someone talented like Wes craven or something - samanime

I would do 1,000 jumping jacks on hot coals with 300-pound weights hanging from my testicles to maybe, just MAYBE, get to see a film adaptation of Penpal.

This would be an amazing film! It's already like a novel and the messed up chronology would be amazing in a film! Just reading it gave me chills!

I would do anything to see a movie that can even compare to how amazing the creepypasta was

V3 Comments
14NoEnd House

I pictured this as a movie the entire time I read it anyway, and it would be so cool. Just the feeling of dread and no hope the entire time you watch it, hopefully would be just as strong as when I was reading this CP. Yes the ending is slightly predictable, hence the name, but this was an amazing creepypasta nonetheless. If this was made into a movie, I would most definitely watch it.

When I read it I imagined it as a movie. It perfectly bleands a good story that is not too heavy on cliches and gore which could be favorable with the critics. Is premise is simple, yet unique and I would love to see this as a movie.

Yes they could make it like "Horrid Henry" imagining your in the house, creepy!

This one is awesome

V5 Comments
15The Seed Eater

I can't think about a scarier movie than a thing eating children yes

I love this one! It may seem really, you do not this made into a movie. Really, trust me it made me wet myself from scaredness and I never got sleep for nearly 3 months now

Get it? Children, seeds, both youngsters?

Peter Peter seed eater, he eats children!

V4 Comments

It would be great to have a movie

V1 Comment
17The Killswitch Experiment

Also known as "kagome kagome" this Nazi based experiment/ghost story is truly terrifying look into the world of immortality.

So this is kagome kagome. Well, there's already a vocaloid song about it - BlueFrostOfThunderClan

I am filming an ameature lost footage style film based on this story.

18The Ronald McDonald House

The story is a 10 year old boy that go's crazy

I love this story so much... Same with Russian Sleep experement and Candle Cove though... AND the Rake! - MoldySock

The Ronald McDonald house is a terefying idea. The process of filming it would be amzing and epic. I couldn't think of a better creepy pasta to be made into a film.

V1 Comment
19Abandoned by Disney

This movie would most likely be a documentary.

This would put Disney out of business! Do it! Haha just kidding it would be a good movie

It can be like a False Documentary!

This would be like five nights at freddy's

V2 Comments
20Where Bad Kids Go

Yush! this one needs to be one! It also needs to have a scene of 'the room'!

V4 Comments
PSearch List

Related Lists

Video Games That Should Be Made Into Movies Books That Should Be Made Into Movies Top 10 Best Disney Animated Movies Not Made by Pixar Lamest Movies Made in the Past 15 Years Call of Duty Games That Should Be Made Into Movies

List StatsUpdated 27 Oct 2016

400 votes
60 listings
3 years, 43 days old

Top Remixes (6)

1. The Smile Dog
2. Jeff the Killer
3. Eyeless Jack
1. The Smile Dog
2. Slender Man
3. The Rake
1. BEN Drowned
2. Candle Cove
3. Jeff the Killer

View All 6


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.