Most Disappointing Video Games of All Time


The Top TenXW

1Duke Nukem Forever

The definitive #1 for me. Anyone who grew up playing Duke Nukem 3D, remembers how amazing the gameplay was, Duke's witty lines of humorous gold, and an all around fun shoot'em'up experience. Years of development hell later and we're left with a shattered, watered-down catastrophe of a game that spits on the face of former Duke Nukem fans harder than nearly any other game franchise to date. A good reason why this game went from being a hyped release to littered in the Bargain Bin in a mere matter of MONTHS. - BloodyThunderX

Instead of waiting for it in 2001 skip 10 years later and we get one of them most disappointing games of the modern era. - htoutlaws2012

We waited many years for this garbage, I would blow up some aliens right now but I'm out of gum

This game was fun. People are too sensitive is why they didn't enjoy it. - VicarSlayer23

V10 Comments
2Sonic the Hedgehog (2006)

Those who followed this game before it's release know that there was loads of hype following it, with various publications claiming it was going to be quite the title. However, upon released it was revealed that the final product was left in an unfinished, buggy, and flatout painful state that did serious damage to Sonic's credibility. Apparently, the build used for the final product was NOT the latest build of the game, however was forcedly used due to SEGA's poor reputation for getting games released for certain dates (To keep with it being released for Sonic's 15th Anniversary), and because the latest build was not stable and polished enough to be used.

What a disappointment to say the least. - BloodyThunderX

As one of my all time favorite franchises, I was stoked for this game. This game was so bad that I did not even finish it. I am a completionist and a die hard Sonic fan, so I was expecting to at least play through it, but nope. After a few hours of playing, I had a decision to make: Take it to Game Stop for hardly anything in return or destroy it. It was with great regret that I had to abandon a Sonic game, but I was pushed to do so. I threw the case and then let the disc become crushed underneath my belongings, letting it sit, stored and unplayed ever since. - surgeonsanic

It's Sonic 06. God, it was made in 2006... 666. It had no hope. Sonic is a horrible franchise. It needs to end. Sega is trying WAY too many gimmicks and if it wants good games, make a new mascot. This game, is just AWFUL. Everyone thought we were going to get a great Sonic game, but no. Too many glitches, some scenes look nice and the others look like 1999s. I just don't get how they failed. Great job Sega. Just give up already. They tried Sonic Boom, they failed.

Sonic games are becoming increasingly worse. That's why I hate sonic.

V20 Comments
3Halo 4

I've never been more disappointed in a halo game in my life than this one - htoutlaws2012

343 didn't do the franchise justice

This really shouldn't be number three. This Halo had the best moments between Cortana and the Chief. It also has some great shootouts. The two things this game really lacked was good map design and vehicle moments. The multiplayer is one of the best of the Halo franchise. This game doesn't deserve to be on this list.

I feel most people that comment this just blame the developers. - NekoHybrid

V11 Comments
4Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts

Actually, if you'd play it for what it IS, not what you WANTED it to be, you'd probably enjoy it. - Garythesnail

Despite never having been able to play the first two games, I can say that this one has nothing going for it. Boring, bland, tedious and departed from the original formula don't describe this game enough.

This game is actually a very great game. I loved it so much when I was younger! I played it over the summer this year after about 3 years of not playing it - SirSkeletorThe3rd

This could be good if not to amazing games before

V5 Comments
5Resident Evil 5

It's a very good game. It's just not a horror game. If this were named something else and not Resident Evil, people would like it. - marmalade_skies

Resident Evil 5 is okay, but 6 is really a load!

V1 Comment
6Metroid Other M

"Other M? " Dear Shadow what does that mean!?

Hello, wasted character development.

V3 Comments
7Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5

2 was great, 3 was great, 4 was good, then after all theses years here is pro skater 5 and holy hell this game is horrible it's even a contender for worst game of 2015. - htoutlaws2012

8Mario Party: Island Tour

Ugh I thought this game would be good. Isn't Mario Party games awesome well this game will change your mind. The games have poor gameplay and poor map designs. And it feels like the npcs have more of a chance of defeating you. - spodermanfan1000

Uggg one reason why Nintendo should buy hudsonsoft off konami, to make better Mario party games

9Aliens: Colonial Marines

Very few games were so sorely disappointing as Aliens: Colonial Marines.

It had everything going for it. Finally, a true sequel to the incredible movie Aliens, greenlight by 20th Century Fox themselves to overwrite Alien 3 and be cannon. Previews looked amazing, and it had so much promise. It was a to-die-for recipe for everything fans of the series could ever hope for.

Then... it came out.

It wasn't that it wasn't awe-inspiringly great. It wasn't that it wasn't awesome. It wasn't that it wasn't just good. Or okay. Or even mediocre.

It was bad.

Graphics had been downgraded. It was buggy, boring, repetitive.
As the story unfolded, it had been lazily handed off from company to company with the thought that "they'll finish it and give it back" until no one cared about it anymore. And in the end, it was just rushed together so they could finally deliver and get it out.

What a waste...

Thank god alien isolation came out to save the series

Really buggy A.I that really ruins this game. - htoutlaws2012

V1 Comment
10Bubsy 3D

The original 2D Bubsy titles were mediocre at best, but had a few fans left and right. This pretty much not only killed Bubsy, but was in my opinion one of the strong points of what led to the eventual demise of Accolade only a mere 3 years later after this game.

What could possibly go wrong? Use your imagination. - BloodyThunderX

To be honest, the Bubsy franchise sucked from the start, so this wasn't such a disappointment.

What happened to the 2d bubsy games that I loved... ? He's dead because of this horrible game.

So the 2 2D Bubsy games were average, then we get one of the worst games of all Bubsy 3D. - htoutlaws2012

Bubsy always sucked so he sucks - VideoGamefan5

V4 Comments

The Newcomers

?Ridge Racer 6
?Tony Hawk: Shred

The Contenders

11Super Mario Bros. 2

Hey why is this on the list just because it wasn't a true Mario game doesn't mean it was bad. - ZZDOORAL

The charm of this game is that it was different from the first one. The gameplay was really good and many enemies became regulars in future Mario games.

Just because It's Weird Doesn't Mean It's Bad - BeatlesFan1964

Cause it was a completely different game from the first. - htoutlaws2012

V6 Comments
12Fallout New Vegas

This is a good game not a disappointment

I completely disagree with anyone who puts this on this list.

This shouldn't be here! It's awesome!

I just pretend this game never existed. Such a step down from number 3.

V4 Comments
13Castlevania II: Simon's Quest

After the masterpiece that is the first castlevania game, Simon's quest was such a disappointment. It's the most cryptic game ever, and the stupid text boxes when it changes from day to night ruin it. - PCgamer98

V1 Comment
14SimCity (2013)

I'm gonna explain this game in one word, "Broken".

The only thing that makes up this game is lag, cheap build, and glitches

V2 Comments

I expected this game to by the best ever! And I'm not the only one. Hundreds of thousands... Seriously hundreds of thousands thought it would be the best, if not one of the best. This game was a huge disappointment... Activision destroyed my favorite video game company, Bungie, and ruined what could have been a masterpiece!

Wholeheartedly disagree. Did it have a good story, no. Was it at total blast to play, yes. A bunch of people whine like baby about DLCs you don't even have to buy and people say, oh it sucks because its not as good as halo. It really makes me mad because people talk about what it could of been. It doesn't have a plot to speak of but it is super fun and exciting once you get the hang of it. A Great game, not disappointing. Why don't you haters just go back to playing your precious halo if you love it so much

Disappointing and it had such hype with BUNGIE AND Activision?!?! How did they mess this up?


V22 Comments
16Mighty No. 9V2 Comments
17Star Fox Adventures

That's not how you spell Star Fox Command.

Just because the Star Fox 64 elitists hate it, doesn't mean you should listen to them.

V1 Comment
18New Super Mario Bros. 2

It is personally my least favorite of the new. super Mario bros series

I only have the "New" WII version. Shame this is on the list.

This has NO POST GAME AT ALL but the story mode is really good though

V7 Comments
19Assassin's Creed Unity
20Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric

I was actually expecting this to be great but sega screawed us over and gave us a crappy game - ikerevievs

PSearch List

Related Lists

Most Disappointing Nintendo Video Games of All Time Best Video Games of All Time Most Addictive Video Games of All Time Weirdest Video Games of All Time Top 10 Video Games That People Have Waited an Extremely Long Time For

List StatsUpdated 27 Oct 2016

700 votes
317 listings
2 years, 295 days old

Top Remixes (10)

1. Duke Nukem Forever
2. Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts
3. Resident Evil 5
1. WWE 13
2. Animal Crossing: Amiibo Festival
3. Action 52
1. Halo 4
2. Duke Nukem Forever
3. Sonic the Hedgehog (2006)

View All 10


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.