Top 10 Greatest Rock Keyboardists and Pianists
Keyboardists were chosen for their skill, creativity, influence, impact, musical depth, expression, and lasting popularity in rock music.With all due respect, this list is a joke. For instance, take Ray Manzarek. As much as I loved him, he was highly simplistic in his playing and stuck there. He was innovative, and there would hardly be any Doors without him. But anyone with any real musical knowledge knows that Ray was no technician or even a highly skilled player. Nor did he pretend to be.
Keith Emerson, on the other hand, blew them all away and more. No one in rock comes close. He's even turned some heads in the jazz scene, which is saying a lot because jazz musicians too often carry airs of superiority and have little or no respect for rock musicians. Keith was also the foremost composer and arranger in classical-rock. Even a number one position for Keith on lists such as this is an understatement.
Of course, there can be no contest here, although I rate Rick (Wakeman) highly. As far as piano goes, you must watch Keith playing 'Piano Improvisations' live! Of course, Tarkus/Aquatarkus on organ are great, but obviously, it's a totally different keyboard technique.
How sad this guy died the way he did, but I guess his music and playing were so important to him that when he could no longer physically continue the way he wanted to, he chose the only way out for him. I have lost probably the greatest inspiration in my life, musically. RIP Keith Emerson.
Dave Greenfield, to me, epitomises and dictates the Stranglers' sound, as much as JJ's grinding bass sound or Hugh's choppy psychedelic sound. In my humble opinion, he is one of the most underrated, forgotten legends of the keyboard, a national treasure, a psychedelic wizard, and a thoroughly decent, approachable musician!
From soaring Doorsesque riffs, Europop, stark industrial sounds, to Sci-Fi dystopian menace, classical, and to a little number with odd time signatures played on a harpsichord! This man can and has done it all, with such surgical precision, with speed, panache, and a pint in hand. Man's a bloody legend!
Dave Greenfield, had he been in any other successful or legendary band, would be celebrated and revered. Because he is in The Stranglers, who have always stuck up their mega-talented middle finger to conformity and the fickle music press, he has been cast aside like a fly around a turd.
The fact is, Dave is one of the most creative, brilliant musicians of our time. For those of you who think The Stranglers ended when club singer Hugh Cornwall left, you should listen to Norfolk Coast and Suite 16 albums. Relentless from Suite 16 is a classic, and Dave's keyboards put Rick Wakeman in the shade, man!
Good luck, Dave! You deserve recognition, and so does the band. That's why I created The Stranglers for Lifetime Achievement Award on Facebook, and 5,000 members agree!
Andy Wade, Fan.
Too often, people overlooked Deep Purple because of the constant turmoil that surrounded the band. Case in point: the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame had to posthumously allow one of the greatest keyboardists into their ridiculous club. Allowing bands like The Beastie Boys, Nirvana, Guns and Roses, and the Sex Pistols in ahead of so many worthy artists is a damned shame.
It was a rare alignment of the solar system. Somehow, Deep Purple had the greatest keyboardist (Jon Lord), the greatest lead guitarist (Ritchie Blackmore), and one of the greatest lead vocalists (Ian Gillan) of all time...
This man said that the most important criterion that makes an individual a great keyboard player is the ability to improvise. He was a great improviser himself, and the music he co-wrote proves him right.
Incredibly technically gifted. Not a fan of his early solo work (it has not aged well), but my God, this man's fingers are so agile!
He is just a magician with his hands. A virtuoso. A great composer too, although here we vote for the better pianist. He, Jon Lord, and Ray Manzarek are the best. Although I think of Lord and Manzarek as better musicians, because their orchestration skills are superior, Rick is the top-notch pianist of them all. Lord is the maestro, Ray is the pioneer and the dreamer, and Rick is the VIRTUOSO.
Fantastic key solos with Yes, and he has fantastic synth tones for the early 70s. Listen to CTTE. The soundscapes he creates with his synths are incredibly moving, especially on And You And I. Along with that, he is also a great piano player. He is undercredited for works such as Life on Mars? and Morning Has Broken. I think what's most important, though, is his ability to create great melodies and his song arrangements.
Less in your face than others on the list - not as obviously into big solos, but his playing was an essential part of Floyd's sound. Wonderfully understated and all the better for it.
Wright made keyboards a vehicle to show his soul, inventiveness, art, and technique all at once. Without him, there's no real Pink Floyd (as The Final Cut, no matter how good, proves). He has always been underrated as a keyboard player, but no one else has propelled the instrument to the stratospheric heights at which he excelled. Rick was more of a virtuoso than he seemed but generally chose to lay the musical carpet for others to stand over and play.
He was also the better composer of melodies in Pink Floyd, as well as a good lead singer. His quiet, peaceful, and very good nature kept him a step below the fight for leadership between Waters and Gilmour. For me, after the Barrett era (when Rick was clearly Syd's right-hand man) and with absolute respect for his fellow bandmates, Wright has been the most important member of Pink Floyd.
Composes classical music, invents and creates both new electronic instruments and software packages, and plays as well as anyone who has ever stroked the electric keys. Listen to your favorite keyboardist and then check out some of the videos online of Jordan playing. And weep.
Rudess is a monster. He's fast, technical, melodic, and will do things with a keyboard that will put a smile on your face. He's crazy, but also a complete genius in this field. Emerson might be your hero, but Rudess will always be the God of Keyboards.
This man is a technical powerhouse, but overrated. He is fast and tight, but the man lacks feeling and is by far the most boring synth soloist that I have ever heard, and is a poor improviser.
The original great rock/prog keyboard player. Made so many Doors tracks memorable. I'm a huge fan of others on the list and listen to some more than RM, but he was the daddy of them all.
Ray should be way higher. The way he combined Renaissance music with rock to create one of the biggest psychedelic experiences is phenomenal. The Doors were about three things: astonishing vocals from Morrison, weird Robby Krieger solos, and, most of all, Manzarek's keyboards. A very intelligent musician. Just listen to Break on Through, Light My Fire, or The End. He also wrote great compositions.
Ray deserves much of the credit for The Doors' success. Ray was classically trained, and he fused the unique style of The Doors. He played bass with the keyboard to help keep time with his left hand while he completed the beat with his right hand. Ray is unique and underappreciated among keyboardists.
Banks is the number one keyboardist in the rock era. Wakeman and Emerson are more technically proficient and achieved many highs, but much of their work is too noodly or discordant in the mix. This results in tedious exercises or whacked-out space sounds. Banks (and Genesis) blend a lot better into an overall composition piece. Nothing from ELP or Yes can approximate the beauty and majesty of Cinema Show - when the song takes flight, Banks's solo lifts you up to behold a chorus of angels. It gives me goosebumps every time after 40 years.
With many more examples of these eargasms, he's the only keyboardist that reaches that emotional and spiritual peak usually reserved for Gospel or spiritual music. Simply listening to Genesis makes a listener more intelligent - for this reason, Banks far surpasses the others.
Like Manzarek, Banks was the heartbeat of the band, and most of their tunes revolved around his 'odd bits and ends' that he brought to the band when they jammed, creating music. Like Emerson and Wakeman, he was a composer, incredibly talented at an early age with classical training and an uncanny ear.
Gabriel had a masterpiece of lyrics in the Lamb, but Banks wrote most of the music with Rutherford and shone most brightly on 'The Wind and the Wuthering'. Give it a listen and know his true brilliance.
What to say - the man is a very gifted player. I personally loved his earlier stuff, where he showed off his playing, such as on Goodbye Yellow Brick Road. But his pop song longevity somewhat blocks out his keyboard brilliance.
Terrible and delusional list by an obviously unqualified group of fans - not musicians or those with any musical knowledge! Elton is the greatest rock pianist, and according to Van Cliburn (you know, the greatest classical pianist of all time - he won the prestigious Tchaikovsky piano tournament in Moscow in 1957 before an all-Soviet judging panel) who stated, and I quote, "That Elton John fellow is the finest improvisational player I've ever heard! His mastery of irregular and difficult chords, and his alacrity of playing these sets while singing, is nothing short of incredible!" Enough said!
This list is comical. Freddie Mercury above a twentieth-ranked Elton, who is unmatched on piano in rock history. Who needs Rodney Dangerfield for laughs when all I need to do is look up one of these ridiculous lists!
I'm happy to see JPJ in the top 10! Not only did he come up with the best bass lines and riffs ever, but his keyboard skills were also amazing! Just listen to the songs Trampled Under Foot, Thank You, and Fool in the Rain.
John Paul Jones was really cool in how he could perform so well, like in Misty Mountain Hop. His playing in that song really gave it something special.
If anyone's heard live versions of Thank You, this guy would be in the top 5, or at least higher than Freddie Mercury. (Nothing against Freddie, but this guy was better.)
Underrated pianist. Everybody calls him the greatest singer, but he was also a very good pianist.
Top 2 in vocals, now top 3 in piano? I can say that Freddie is one of the greatest musicians who ever lived. I'd like to learn to play piano too and try to play Bohemian Rhapsody first...
Underrated pianist. He played by his own rules.
Just listen to Chest Fever. A more epic organ solo has not been done!
As a pianist myself, it's a disgrace that this man is not in the Top 10. Why is Freddie Mercury ahead of him? Freddie was an incredible singer, but his piano playing was pretty basic. Apart from basic chords, there was nothing special he did as a pianist. Meanwhile, Billy Joel is a master of putting emotion into his piano playing, and his finger rolls are stupidly fast.
I voted for Emerson, but it needs to be said that this guy is a monstrous keyboardist. Everybody's aware of his stunning songwriting talents, but one listen to his playing on songs like "Prelude/The Angry Young Man", "Root Beer Rag", "The Entertainer", "Travelin' Prayer", "Scenes from an Italian Restaurant", "Stiletto", "Great Suburban Showdown", "Los Angelenos", "James", "New York State of Mind", and... man, the list is endless!
How is Billy Joel only at 29? I've only heard of three of the people in the top 10, where only one of them is actually a solo artist. Billy Joel has produced more classics than most of the people in the top 10.
Geddy Lee is one of the most disciplined and hardworking rock and rollers of all time.
How can the Keyboard, Bass, Vocalist not be in the top 10? Sad.
A unique style, completely different from Wakeman's, a cleaner player on another note. I love Rick, but guys like Moraz or Emerson are much more technically proficient. Rick will always throw in a bad note during his keyboard licks. Emerson is near perfection, same for Moraz. But my truest idol is Tony Banks.
Exceptional contribution in Yes' album Relayer and great talent live in the Relayer tour. Made us nearly forget about Rick!
He's top in my book. Most famous opening of the most downloaded song.
You and your wife, Tane, were second to none in what you did. Yay, JC! His playing defined arena keyboard rock.
Highly underrated like every other member from Bon Jovi. Watch him play 'Keep the Faith' live, and you will realize his talent. He literally plays five keyboards at a time. He has also played beautiful piano on songs like 'Always' and 'Bed of Roses'.
An extremely versatile keyboardist, his musicianship ranges from being a supporting instrumentalist in songs like 'Livin' on a Prayer' and 'It's My Life', to being a driving force on songs like 'Bad Medicine' and 'Runaway'.
Are you kidding me? He plays five keyboards at a time and improvises each show! Amazing technique and playing. Plus, Memphis is a piece of work. I dare anyone to play that piece as well as him, as well as some other piano versions of the full rock band songs!
You've got to be kidding me. He should be in the top 7. He is the complete package. Bon Jovi is a great band, and he has such chemistry with Richie and Tico. He creates songs and hits the solo instead of Sambora. David is the best in the world.
Revolutionary guitarist, pretty good at piano/keyboards, and he can also sing pretty well. This dude is amazing.
He makes great melodies on the keyboard and plays guitar too. One of the best, I think.
Really? #17? I'm pretty sure if you surveyed the 16 above him, most would put Leon a lot higher. Just ask Elton!
Leon was the best. He is being underestimated at #16. Definitely should be in the top 5, if not #1.
Very disappointed. There will never be another Leon.
Second attempt to type this on the train. Eddie was not just a talented keyboard player of the piano, CS80 Yamaha Synth, Hammond Organ, and Mini Moog - he also played the violin through a Cornish customised pedalboard. As far as I'm concerned, he mastered the CS80 just as good as Vangelis. But playing live showed he was not just a studio keyboardist.
He is totally underrated because he never got the opportunity with UK for the band to be appreciated, despite the other talented artists such as Terry Bozzio, Bill Bruford, John Wetton, and Allan Holdsworth. A real shame.
Nicky Hopkins didn't just play with The Rolling Stones. He also played with The Kinks, The Beatles, Quicksilver Messenger Service, The Who, Jefferson Airplane, The Jerry Garcia Band, and The Jeff Beck Group.
Hopkins doesn't get as much recognition because he wasn't really with one band, but he was possibly, arguably, the greatest session keyboard player.
He played on more really great rock songs than any other musician, keyboard or otherwise. The greatest keyboardist, especially for Sympathy for the Devil and Edward the Mad Shirt Grinder. God bless. (Really... Keith Emerson... how pathetic).
Who else played with the Rolling Stones, the Beatles, the Kinks, and the Who? Also time in Quicksilver Messenger Service and Jerry Garcia Band - Jerry said Nicky was the best keyboard player he ever played with.
A list of rock keyboardists without this man is not complete. He played on many records, toured with many artists as a hired gun. Bobby Kimball from Toto, Andrew Strong, Ian Cussick, etc. He had his own rock band, Lone Age, in the early 90s and was also the founder of the Brotherhood of Rock and Soul, featuring Kingsize Taylor and Chris Thornton Jr. He is also a skilled guitarist.
This cat is absolutely underrated. He played on so many records, toured half the world, and is an excellent guitarist and singer as well.
Absolutely brilliant, not only as a solid rock player but also very versatile in many different music styles.
Listen to his solo stuff to get a true taste of this legend's talent. Enigma Suite is a cool place to start. It blends all sorts of styles, like jazz and neoclassical elements. He also played temporarily with Sonata Arctica and Spastic Ink. An absolute legend in the European melodic metal scene.
This guy is a master and very fast.
That Steve Winwood would be this low on a keyboard list is baffling. He invented rock and roll organ with Spencer Davis, and his organ work remains untouchable to this day. If you listen to his work on "Blind Man" from the "Last Exit", Traffic album, you've got to think, Winwood was doing Prog keyboards before that genre was truly identified. His piano work is untouchable, and he also plays synthesizers. Don't hate him because he is awesome. Just listen.
Steve Winwood owns the Hammond Organ and the piano. You will have a hard time finding someone greater with those instruments. Furthermore, his composition skills are amazing. He has never written a bad melody. He is number one in my book, though Keith Emerson has to be up there as well. Winwood is top three minimum.
Should have been rated much higher. One of the most talented musicians ever. Traffic and Blind Faith were some of the best bands, as well as the Spencer Davis Group.