Top Ten Hamilton Songs That Make You Cry


The Top TenXW

1It's Quiet Uptown

It took ages for me to warm up to this song 'cause it was so slow and sad and simple, but really, after the Stay Alive reprise, this is just icing on the sad cake... Like in case you weren't already bawling! - keycha1n

Saddest song ever. There's nothing like the loss of a child and the unimaginable pain and grief that lasts forever.

This song immediately follows "Stay Alive (Reprise)" and causes me to sob uncontrollably. - I-WouldLikeIt-Uptown

Of course this is first! - FavoriteFightingFrenchman

V3 Comments
2Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story

You really realize how much Eliza lost. Two sisters, her husband, her son, outliving almost eveyone she loved... And now she's just waiting to rejoin them.
There's also this interpretation going around that at the end, Eliza breaks the fourth wall to realize that everybody in the audience came to hear about Alexander Hamilton's life, making her life work to preserve his legacy worth it. I'm not sure if its true, but I'll totally go with it. - keycha1n

Eliza is so amazing and this song makes you appreciate her even more than you thought you could - FavoriteFightingFrenchman

It makes me relive everything that I just heard and thanking Eliza for telling their stories. - I-WouldLikeIt-Uptown

Eliza lived for fifty years after Alexander Hamilton and everyone else passed

V3 Comments
3Stay Alive (Reprise)

I love this song even though it is so sad. Again, nothing like the loss of your child, especially when he was only 19! I'll never be able to count to 9 in French... ever.

Now I can't count to ten in French without crying

I can't count to 9 in French class now...

I think it is really sad and heart breaking

V5 Comments
4Dear Theodosia

It's so sweet yet so sad. Phillip and Theodosia end up 'blowing away' as in dying. Both of their fathers outlived them - FavoriteFightingFrenchman

This one makes me cry because it's adorable and they don't know the ends their children will meet. - I-WouldLikeIt-Uptown

Probably in my top favorites of Hamilton. So sweet, so caring!

V1 Comment
5Blow Us All Away

I pick blow us all away because it is so happy and cheerful then Phillip gets in an argument and is shot dead at the 7th step even though he wasn't going to kill his opponent

I find this one sad because Philip is so happy and confident and then his opponent turns at seven. - I-WouldLikeIt-Uptown

This one makes me really sad and makes me want to cry in French class. It gives me feels.

It has such a cheerful tune and almost makes you forget Philip will get murdered - FavoriteFightingFrenchman

V1 Comment

When I imagine this song, I first picture Eliza at a desk in the middle of the night in a old nightgown, and the desk would have neat papers stacked and a burning candle. And as the song picks up speed, she would start knocking things off of the desk, and papers would go flying.

Eliza sings this song about burning all the stuff Hamilton wrote for her after discovering that he cheated on her. - I-WouldLikeIt-Uptown

Philippa so's vocals DESTROY me every time I hear this song, especially when she sings, "You, you, you." The song becomes even more heart-wrenching as the vocals build up. "Burn" so beautifully written and performed. I am not ashamed to admit that it has brought me to tears.

This is BY FAR the saddest song in the show

V4 Comments
7The World Was Wide Enough

I start to get sad when Burr says, "This man will not make an orphan of my daughter" When Hamilton starts singing without the melody is when I get really depressed - FavoriteFightingFrenchman

"when Hamilton aimed at the sky, he may have been the first one to die. But I'm the one that paid for it."

Can't deal. Too many emotions. - keycha1n

The lyric "this man will not make an orphan of my daughter" honest to god drained my eyes of any tears they had in them

I may or may not have sobbed my eyes out while listening to this song.

V5 Comments
8Alexander Hamilton

This one only makes me cry because I played Aaron Burr in a miniature production my friends and I put on, and so I had to come to terms with the fact that I was the damn fool that shot Hamilton. - I-WouldLikeIt-Uptown

The first time I was completely in awe of all of his accomplishments. After I finished the play and re-listened to it that was one if the saddest thing ever - FavoriteFightingFrenchman

V1 Comment

The song really builds and it's really cool because you get to hear Angelica's side of the story and you can feel how much she really loves her sister (Eliza).

This song is so sad, she gives up her chance to have an amazing husband for his sister, to have a happy life. She is so selfless, I actually am crying right now

10Guns and ShipsV1 Comment

The Newcomers

?The Story of Tonight
BAdd New Item

The Contenders

11My Shot
12History Has Its Eyes On You
13Wait for It

This makes me sad because I feel bad for Burr. He's living in the shadow of Hamilton even though he was there first.


This song for me is so utterly heartbreaking because it is really the first time Alexander shares with us his past in the Carribean that he has fought so hard to bury so deeply down no one can see it until now in his moment of weakness and dread of what he is sure to come after the release of the Reynolds Pamphlet. The subjects that he touches on this song are so sad and you can just imagine how traumatizing this would be for anyone-much less a child. The little voice crack that you hear when Hamilton is singing about his dead mother and trying not to cry breaks me every. Single. Time.

15Dear Theodosia (Reprise)

This is even sadder than the can find it on YouTube - FavoriteFightingFrenchman

It's a shame they left this song out the final version. It is so sad!

V1 Comment
16Best of Wives and Best of Women

This song is so sad, because this is the last interaction we know of that Alexander and Eliza had before Hamilton dies, and it is so amazing that Eliza was able to forgive after all Alexander had done

This song is an exchange between Alexander and Eliza before Alexander goes to duel Aaron. - I-WouldLikeIt-Uptown

V1 Comment
17That Would Be Enough

Eliza is begging Alexander to come home so he doesn't die before his son is born. - I-WouldLikeIt-Uptown

V1 Comment

It's so lovely and Eliza and Alexander sound so happy, and the entire time you know that Eliza won't ever be this happy again. She won't get a husband that loves her as much as he should and everyone will die before she will.

19Say No to This

I didn't cry, just very annoyed. Screw Maria. - NotYoursTruly

20Aaron Burr, Sir
BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Best Songs That Make You Cry AKB48 Songs That Make You Cry Top Ten My Little Pony Songs That Make You Cry Ten Songs That Always Make You Smile Top Ten Movies that Make You Cry

List StatsUpdated 10 Dec 2016

100 votes
35 listings
327 days old

Top Remixes

1. Blow Us All Away
2. Dear Theodosia
3. Stay Alive (Reprise)
1. Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story
2. Alexander Hamilton
3. Guns and Ships
1. It's Quiet Uptown
2. Stay Alive (Reprise)
3. Blow Us All Away



Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.