Most Overrated Video Games


The Contenders: Page 7XW

121Slender Man and the 8 Pages
123Super Paper Mario

So what if it's childish, so what if it's not the same as the other paper mario games? This game is very unique and very fun. If anyone disagrees they will be thrown into the chokey!

It's not overrated. I never ever saw it on a top 10 Mario games, despite it's a good game. Not overrated.

its OK. not the greatest tho, but super mario is still awesome - Marcopwnzatdrums

More like underrated. - GentleTrouter

V8 Comments
124Devil May Cry 3: Dante's Awakening

Overrated game with a lousy character.

Don't listen to them this game is awesome especially in the hd collection

This game is like the new Angry Birds. It's everywhere, there's a million and one copies of it, and isn't even that fun much like angry birds.

Whenever I get a sudden urge to play it, I play it, and then I get super bored - lolingdog9000

The worst thing ever just a bunch of balls eating each other

I got bored so fast by playing this game

V3 Comments
126Super Smash Bros Melee

I Like Smash Bros Melee And I Say That Smash Bros Brawl Is A Good Game - CuteGirlJigglypuff

Really good game but a bad fanbase of nostalgiafreaks ruins it.

Super smash bros Melee isint a bad game but I don't understand want makes people's all time favorite smash bros game that is held in such high regard I think it is one word nostalgia

V3 Comments
127Halo 4

Really? Another Halo game, really getting uncreative. Certain games needs to just die. It should of just ended with Halo 3, though given Money$oft likes to milk franchises, I don't see this game coming to a end till they close down their gaming department, or just go bankrupt. Either Way Halo 4 was beyond overhyped and is much worse than ODST.

I'd switch this and where 3 is this one is the most overrated in my opinion - htoutlaws2012

This game was a huge letdown, it sucks so bad that it makes Halo Reach look underrated.

128Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4

I love the Megami Tensei franchise, and Persona 4 is no exception. But when Persona 4 is the only game that people talk about out of the whole franchise, then wouldn't you say it's overrated? Persona 4 has great gameplay, but the problem is that there isn't enough. Half of the game is dialogue, which is incredibly tedious unless you like visual novels. When the characters are not advancing the plot (which doesn't seem to go anywhere in the first place) they're doing things that are completely unrelated and unnecessary. There are plenty of other MegaTen games out there that I believe are much better than Persona 4.

129Powerpuff Girls: Defenders of Townsville
130Pokemon Emerald

Why do people like this game so much
It's the same as every other Pokemon
Game it's my friends favorite game ever
It drives me nuts why do people like this much

V2 Comments
131Sonic the Hedgehog (2006)

You know a game is overrated when it has nothing to do with the last 3 sonic the hedgehog games.

Like bubsy 3d, everyone gives it the appropriate reaction. It's overrated since it exists.

Why is this game here?! This game gets too much hate! Saying this is overrated is like saying this is the worst game of all time!

This list is called overrated games! Not worst games of all time! Morons

V5 Comments
132Mass Effect 2

ME series deserve all the praise they get. A fantastic story in a fantastic universe.

133Street Fighter

If you mean the original Turbografix version. Yes, it was terrible.

134Portal 2

This is not an overrated game. I gets all the praise it deserves. The people who put this on here probably just saw a walkthrough on YouTube. Playing Portal 2 is a totally different experience than watching it. When you play the ending it will drive you to tears. Play this game then come back here say say to my face that this masterpiece is overrated.

I love how both Portal games are nowhere near the top of the list.

I don't understand why this is on here. - PinataonSugar

V1 Comment
135The Legend of Zelda

The game was revlionary for its time it was the first open world game and the first game with a save awesome boss fights secrets to find and sidequests this game it the numder 2 game for the nes next super Mario bro 3

V1 Comment
137Ratchet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction
138Mario Kart DS

This game is so overrated & Pauline could've replaced Peach. Also, what's with the terrible graphics?! Everything (except Mission Mode & Retro Cup) sucks about this game!

Pauline could replace Peach? You did not seriously say that. You. Did. Not. The graphics are called 2005 Handheld. What makes Retro Cup better than anything else? Also, Mario Kart DS is not nearly as talked about as Wii, Double Dash, 7 or 8, so how is it overrated?

The normal tracks are great but most of the retrio tracks are bad

V1 Comment
139Sonic Generations

I LOVE SONIC GENERATIONS! But why is it on here you may ask? Well because it's too short, too easy, and the final boss is awful. But it's still good just not as good as Sonic Unleashed. - Chaotixhero

This game is not even well liked. How could it be overrated

140Sonic CD

Good sonic game but is it really the best sonic game? I think not.

Top 10 best Sonic the Hedgehog games

Top 1. Sonic the Hedgehog 2 (especially with Knuckles in Sonic 2).

Top 2. Sonic 3 & Knuckles.

Top 3. Sonic the Hedgehog 4 (the pirated SNES version)

Top 4. Sonic & Knuckles.

Top 5. Sonic the Hedgehog: Triple Trouble.

Top 6. Super Smash Bros. Brawl.

Top 7. Sonic the Hedgehog 3.

Top 8. SEGA Superstars.

Top 9. Sonic the Hedgehog 1.

Top 10. Sonic the Hedgehog CD.

Sonic: wait people hate this game?! Tails: People these days hate everything. Next they'll be saying Call of Duty sucks. (Which I hope they do)

I don't understand why critics day this is the best game of all time when it isn't true, it's bland as hell.

The best Sonic game is the original 16-bit game.

PSearch List

Related Lists

Most Overrated Video Games of 2013 Top 10 Video Games, Movies and Shows That Are Greatly Overrated Due to Their Nostalgia Factors Top 10 Video Games With the Most Overrated Storyline Top 10 Underrated Video Games from Overrated Series Top 10 Video Games That Were System-Definingly Overrated

List StatsUpdated 28 Oct 2016

5,000 votes
394 listings
9 years, 56 days old

Top Remixes (68)

1. Half-Life 2
2. Call of Duty
3. Team Fortress 2
1. Five Nights at Freddy's
2. Minecraft
3. Call of Duty
1. Five Nights at Freddy's 2
2. Five Nights at Freddy's
3. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas

View All 68


Call of Duty isn't bad, just overrated.
Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.