Scariest Animatronics In Five Night's at Freddy's


The Contenders: Page 2XW

21Withered Freddy

He bites at your face... I guess if you were actually there as the night guard and not just playing a game where you are a night guard, he'd be scary... I'm not sure

Is it just me or does withered Freddy look exactly the same as the original with a few scars?

V2 Comments

He's a version of chucky, I mean, hand him a knife and it would be complete

Plushtrap scares me. I'm like! Even though plush trap may be cute but he is so scary

V3 Comments
23Nightmare ChicaV3 Comments
24Withered Golden Freddy

Maybe it's the Golden Freddy in the second game.

V2 Comments
25Eyeless Bonnie

If you see this rare start up or game over screen happen. Your heart will go so fast

This one actually scares me. Luckily, it's rare, and it's just an Easter Egg. Eyeless Bonnie is the normal Bonnie(you know, the less weird looking ones, purple fur), but has black eyes, that cover some parts other then his face.

Yep I always listen to slipknot eyes while playing this and I see eyeless bonnie well guess what you can't see California without marlon brandos eyes

V1 Comment

Nightmare looks like a mix of shadow Freddy and shadow Bonnie with the body of golden Freddy

He is the " not so nice versing of Fred bear

Yeah, this guy is pretty dang freaky. His jumpscare is kind of nightmare-inducing (no pun intended).

Why did scott make this...

V10 Comments
27Golden Bonnie

I actually think this dude is cute. Why? Search up "Golden Bonnie," and look at the first photo. He's adorable! I mean, his Heidi's barely off his's just ' adorable. Love you, Springy!

Oh jeez the twitching! His smile freaks the life outta me!

He is so creepy with that face mangle dose not scare me mangle is my homey

Golden bonnie is spring trap

V7 Comments

Ennard is quite a scary character, especially based on the fact that he uses manipulation and impersonation so frequently to lure you into a false sense of security while he manipulates other animatronics. He is an amalgamation of everything bad and scary, and wants revenge and to escape. - SwiftFox777

Mad scary and it's ending gave me nightmares.

"There's a Little of Me In Everybody"

Scared the crap out of me

V4 Comments
29Nightmare Foxy

All those sharp, and pointy teeth. RETURN TO A PLUSHY!

He's so terrifying. The original foxy may be my favorite but the nightmare version is SCARY!

V1 Comment

Nightmarionne has that grin that says: GOODBYE SUCKER.

NightMarionne. First time I saw him I was like HA HA NOPE! Had nighmares for a while.

Nightmarionne can jumpscare you she will get out of the screen in 15 seconds

V1 Comment
31Shadow Bonnie

Shadow Bonnie is the scariest for me because of the lack of defining facial and bodily features. I mean, she only has eyes and a mouth, which are colored bright white (lots of contrast). When you're looking around in a dark place, she can appear ANYWHERE.

In five nights at Freddy's 3 if you are playing on a iPhone once you finish the fourth night you play as shadow Bonnie and when you move you twitch which freaked me out so bad

The only one who has ever given me nightmares!

V5 Comments
32Nightmare Freddy

Like golden freddy, but with teeth everywhere. Nightmare fuel!

I used to think all the characters were cute. But the rows of teeth kind of got to me. I really like all of the animatronics. Until I saw him on the internet... But I just love fnafs games. Great job Scott!

He's not as scary, since he only attacks you if either too many mini Freds are on your bed or if you just stand at a part of a room for too long.

The Games Out Dude

V3 Comments

It's so scary when you crawl through the ballora gallery and when you see the light of the door you see ballora's legs go past. Oh, and her jumpscare is pretty terrifying as well.

V2 Comments
34Phone Guy

Phone Guy is NOT Purple Guy for heavens sake. The theory is not true, the thing Purple Guy has in his hand is NOT a phone. It doesn't even have a cord attached to dial buttons.

The thing in Purple Guy's hand could be a taser, because in the mini game when you make contact with him, the screen turns blue, and you shut down. Probably because the shock from the taser does it.

And Purple Guy is a police man, so he can carry the taser around with him. Phone Guy probably would not have a one. If you don't believe me, you should search YouTube for the theory.

The man we all trust could be leading us to our doom and we don't even know it. Never trust someone you can't see.

He murdered the Marionette when it was a kid. The phone guy is the purple guy

He gets annoying when he's like wow you made it this far!

V4 Comments
35Nightmare Golden Freddy

Seriously why is he not in the list
He a fast basterd and he will get you no matter what
Have you seen him

He scare the living hell out of me.
his death screen, and jumscare freaks me out.
. He comes out of nowhere
.you need to close the door as soon as you see him
.I am so scared of him, I do go in my basement AT ALL...!

V3 Comments
36Nightmare Balloon Boy

Oh my god he is terrifying I mean None of these characters are too scary (for me) and this did not give me nightmares but he is still the creepiest

I hate when you see him on the camera than boom so scary espacialy without eyes god! I'm wetting myself

V3 Comments
37Balloon Girl

What the Dark Forest? Of course, she DOES kick butt on the Hunger Games simulator for some odd reason.

V2 Comments

Who in the hell of it is the muffin?!? Do you mean the cupcake because there is no muffin.

V4 Comments
39Mike Schmidt

Who the heck added him to the list?! You can't even see him!

V8 Comments

The fan is pure evil! It is the one that uses up your power!

I hate the fan he talks to me between nights he is just so scary

He Is So Scary I Screamed When I Saw Him In All 4 Games!

This is the most stupidest thing on the list

V7 Comments
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top 10 Scariest Animatronics In Five Nights at Freddy's 2 Scariest Moments In Five Night's at Freddy's Top Ten Scariest Five Nights at Freddy's 3 Animatronics Top Ten Scariest Things About Five Night's at Freddy's 3 Top Ten Scariest Five Nights at Freddy's 4 Characters

List StatsUpdated 4 Dec 2016

700 votes
59 listings
2 years, 58 days old

Top Remixes (15)

1. Foxy the Fox
2. Golden Freddy
3. Puppet
1. Nightmare
1. Bonnie The Bunny
2. Freddy the Fazbear
3. Foxy the Fox

View All 15


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.