Top 10 Scariest Creepypastas

These are creepypastas that scared me the most. Its almost Halloween so lets bring some nightmares out. Don't agree with the list? Vote for an existing item you think should be ranked higher or if you are a logged in, add a new item for others to vote on or create your own version of this list.

The Top Ten

1
Jeff the Killer
Time to sleep. I get into my bed and lie down. I close my eyes thinking about random things. Sadly, one of those random things is Jeff the Killer. Step one: Open eyes as wide as possible
Step 2: Go completely still
Step 3: Breath rapidly
Step 4: Reluctantly think of all the ways Jeff could attack you
Step 5: get something close to your bed that you use as a weapon, but won't hurt him anyways

For maximum results, sleep alone!

username34

The thing which scares me the most about him is, HIS FACE! That face always haunts me... I don't even think he has a nose... I just hope I never, ever see his face ever again...
This dude has the scariest face EVER. Ever since I couldn't sleep well and when I closed my eyes his face comes up! And also, read his story it end so scary!
[newest]
Jeff the Killer looks like a cross between The Joker & Marilyn Manson.

egnomac

More comments about Jeff the Killer

2Slenderman
Honestly Slendy is the strongest creepypasta besides The Doctor. The Doctor is the one who creates them and Slendy hates him. Slendy is the best cause he can control your body, teleport, has tenticals that comes out of his back, makes you lose your memory, can drive you too insanity, can make little kids comes in the woods, can form a mouth that goes from one side of his blank head to the other and take a giant bite out of you, he can rip your heart out by sticking his long fingers down your throat and he has the power to make the Slender Portal to take his victims to the CreepyPasta world, and he can make you paranoid and attach him even though it is easier to kill you that way. All of this is true about Slenderman. So he should number one or The Doctor should be cause he knows how to kill every CreepyPasta and can create them. The Doctor can even kill them by just a drop of his blood landing on their skin and them will disintegrate painfully.
That is the truth and Slenderman does not eat kids souls.
A faceless guy who has tenticales and kills you buy staring at him and eats kids souls. FREAKY!
Team Slender. Hands down. He's dah best :3
[newest]
Who would win in a fight Slender Man vs The Rake or Slender Man vs Jake the Killer.

egnomac

More comments about Slenderman

3BEN Drowned
Ben is a creepy creepypasta and when playing the game are on cleverbot.com
This is my favorite creepypasta just not the scariest one but I do like the fact that it is video game related... I LOVE VIDEO GAMES!
Only number 3? You shouldn't have done that. You're going to meet with a terrible fate, aren't you?
More comments about BEN Drowned

4Sonic.exe
Who wants to play sonic after playing that game?
I AM GOD! That's all I have to say. 😣
Sonic is wah scary tails doll just as scary but sonic has a better story to it
[newest]
I may never be able to play another Sonic game after this.

egnomac

More comments about Sonic.exe

5Smile Dog
Thanks to Smile. Dog, I now cautiously scroll down every creepypasta page and shut the browser if I see the tip of any picture...
Smile dog by a lot. The image is really horrifying to look at. Unlike Jeff the killer, smile dog had a better well written story.
Smile Dog...he haves a way scary face than Jeff does. I seen images of him, But I just need to know what breed of dogs he is!
[newest]
Probably the first pasta to disturb the living crap out of me, and I don't easily get disturbed. Very well done, picture included.
More comments about Smile Dog

6The Russian Sleep Experiment
Picture is the scary part.
I keep on learning more and more things that the possessed test subjects represent.

username34

To be honest, it's the most disturbing experiment I ever read!
[newest]
Most realistic creepy pasta EVER
More comments about The Russian Sleep Experiment

7Squidward's Suicide
Go to red mist. -Alexis Thompson-Tomlinson
This just breaks my heart. That there is a lost episode of my favorite T.V. show SpongeBob. That face of Squidwards will haunt my nighmares.

8Suicide Mouse
Not only is this scary but it is extremely disturbing. It is Mickey Mouse walking down an endless street for 3 minutes before cutting to black for a couple of minutes then it returns to Mickey doing the same thing but this time it is a woman screaming for about 4 minutes with a grin on his face. At one time of the episode it shows Mickey Mouse's face indicating that it is the end of the episode. The first person to watch this episode committed suicide. The end!
This is nightmare indusing, this is childhood ruining, this makes you want to watch Micky Mouse club house. GOD DANG REALISTIC SCREAMS!

9Abandoned by Disney
This was TERRIFYING. Oh my gosh... The nightmares of that costume. And that Mickey Mouse voice, "Hey, wanna see my head come off? " OH my gosh.
Oh my gosh. This gave me SO. MANY. NIGHTMARES. The costumes were horrifying.
It is very scary I can't believe that Mickey appears and scares the heck out of me
[newest]
Ahh I know now tails doll and that mickey mouse now I have 2 things to be scared of

mikaylaroes

More comments about Abandoned by Disney

10Cupcakes
It picks the character, Pinkie pie. Who makes cupcakes. Sadly, she forgot about the ingredient. So, she takes Rainbow Dash into this so much disgusting treatment.

Pony_forever

This creepy my little pony fan written story featuring Pinkie Pie brutally murdering Rainbow dash will send chills down your spine as you read of the gory disection
I just love her look and every thing!

DubstepLover


The Contenders

11Red Mist
The story was pretty freaky, the picture was hellish, but the video? That was disappointing! The part where he was standing there with those bleeding eyes was creepy, but when he actually killed himself, it looked like someone drew a picture of him on a computer, and the animation when he put the gun to his head was so lame. In the story, he used a shot gun and blew his head apart. There was blood, brain matter, his eye was hanging out... But in the video, he puts a little revolver to his head, shoots himself, and then blood spatters on the screen. Then it shows a picture of squidward lying down with some really fake looking blood. Also, when the voice said "Do it! " It sounded like a ' 15 year old who has no experience with voice acting. LAAME!
Squidward creeps me out on this one. The only thing that creeps me out on this creepypasta is the BIG BLOOD SHOT RED EYES! And the ending were HE POINTS A GUN INTO A MOUTH AND SHOOT! That's just creepy.
The story was scary, but the episode was disappointing. In the story, he blew his head up with a shotgun. In the episode, he put a little revolver to his head, and shot himself, and there was some blood on his head... Weak! Also the animation was poor, and when the guy says "do it," it sounds like a 15 year old guy who has no experience with voice acting. LAME!
More comments about Red Mist

12The Rake
Makes me close my windows and blinds and sleep with the covers over my head with only a small hole in which to stick my face out. I have actually done that since I was like 6 or 7 (because I was afraid of lots of stuff then) and I still do it. It's just unconscious routine that went from feeling scared without the covers over my head to feeling awkwardly exposed and weird.

username34

The rake is really scary I think people always say that and I think that to the rake is a tall long thing that comes into your house and kills you will his bloody big hands and he crawls on the floor so no one can see him
I read this story really late at night I was awake for at least another 2 hours before I went to bed that night I really hope this creepypasta is fake
[newest]
The Rake freaks me and millions of people the heck out!
More comments about The Rake

13Lavender Town Syndrome
Pokemon can be scary and suicide making. Well that's it. If I'm missing something please add it on here. Well bye and good luck sleeping tonight after reading these Creepypastas. And happy halloween.
Haha, this is my favorite, no offense but Sonic.exe sucks laugh out loud

MoldySock

There are SO many Pokemon creepypastas out there, it's not even funny. This one is just one of them.

username34

[newest]
This wasn't very creepy when I heard that people never killed themselfs because of the music
More comments about Lavender Town Syndrome

14Ronald McDonald House
Holy hell. This was definitely the scariest one yet. Really well written too. I was seriously hoping he got out of there alive.
I have never been shaking from a creepypasta since I first read the Red Mist. This was seriously the most messed up and sickening story ever and is making me seriously want to stop reading creepypasta as a whole
I never actually started fearing of what of the character or ever had been scared of clowns until this creepy pasta.
[newest]
I've written many creepy pasta and by now I think I now whats scary or not but this one still scares me
More comments about Ronald McDonald House

15Tails Doll
Normally, creepypastas just make me scared at night. Not once have they given me nightmares. Except for the tails doll. That one gave me a nightmare. I don't remember the whole thing, but I do remember a few 2 second parts of it, all of which had the Tails Doll floating around on a colored background with red, glowing eyes. About the waking up in the middle of the night thing, that just happened because I had 1) gotten scared of a new creepypasta, the teddy bear 2) My friend told me that there is a 90% chance that if you wake up in the middle of the night for no reason, it's because you're being watched. Combine the 2, and you wake up in the middle of the night 4 times!

username34

This doll makes me wanna run away.
When I read this I was checking out of my window and waking up in the middle of the night for 4-5 weeks hoping that I will live.
[newest]
I want to date him. -Alexis Thompson-Tomlinson
More comments about Tails Doll

16The Doctor
Okay, let me get this simple. This is nightmares in a story.
I hate doctors because they all turn out to kill you in MOVIES LIKE THIS PEOPLE HE IS A KILLER!

17Jane the Killer
JANE THE KILLER IS CREEPY and that's a have to say...

18Annora Petrova

19Mereana Mordegard Glesgorv
That creepypasta creeped me more than other creepypastas, because it's about a man who has red background and looks like demon starring at you! When you try to search for him you would find nothing at first searching! But then if you try to search for him second time, you will find his shortest video about 22 seconds, at first 20 seconds it happens nothing and only he looks at you and then the last two seconds he grinding! It creeps people out and too much people had suicide, because their eyes went to insane! But there's the original video which in less than two minutes your eyes will become red! Don't try this, please your eyes will become red and you will die!

AlexandraMoonDust


20Weeping Angel

21Eyeless Jack
I used to be afraid of seeing him over my face.

username34


221999
This one is a little long but it's worth reading
I've read this one 3 times, and it never gets old. Kinda sloppy at the end, but very original!
I don't even think this story's ended yet.

higgsboson2142


23Super Mario 64: Damned
I read about it incredibly creepy and disturbing I may never be able look at Super Mario 64 the same way after reading this creepypasta.

egnomac


24Funnymouth
I find this story creepy! It's definitely in my top tens.
It's is just so well writen

25The Expressionless
Definitely beats out any other creepypasta!

26The Portraits

27The Keyhole

28Dr. Smiley

29The Cell Phone Game
This is a well written Creepypasta and the ending is pretty shocking. It's just amazing.
That ending and the sequel...
I have to stand by it.

30Bloody Painter

31Laughing Jack
Easily my absolute favorite creepypasta. I told his story to all of my friends, and they were mortified. This one could easily be around the top three, but this isn't my list...
I read this one and was pretty scared. Not as scary as Jeff the Killer though.

username34


32Zalgo

33The Dating Game
It was scary because the girl wasn't possessed as far as I know.

34Psychosis
This, unlike the horribly overrated Jeff the Killer and Slenderman, is extremely thought provoking. Such a disturbing concept, and the ending is so well crafted the writer ought to get a medal. This and Candle Cove are easily my favorite Creepypastas.
This is the best written creepypasta by far. It easily squashes things like red mist and lavender town syndrome, and makes slenderman seem like a children's novel.
How isn't this on here?

35The Strangest Security Tape I've Ever Seen
You can't have a list without a disturbing security tape being in it, I like the concept of the time loops and also Jeremy is a freak

36Persuaded

37Bloody Mary

38Username 666
My friend tried to kill my computer by looking this up and trying to make it happen. I didn't let him though. All it really is, is a virus hooked up to YouTube. Nothing paranormal.

username34

This is what happens when a devil makes a YouTube account

tranhotwheel04

Pretty creepy This creepypasta will keep me from ever going on You Tube again.

egnomac

More comments about Username 666

39My Teddy Bear
It's just scary, and the picture scares the crap out of me. Mr. Creepypasta read this on YouTube, and I listened to it. I am never sleeping without a light in my room ever again.

username34


40Fuzzy (as performed by CreepsMcPasta)

41Mr. Widemouth
It's decently scary (freaked my 11-year-old brother out).
But more than scary it's the best-written creepypasta ever.
This made meh cry so bad cus this is a sad story

42Mother's Call
I'm SCARED TO GO DOWNSTAIRS TO HELP WITH DINNER NOW!

43Gateway of the Mind
One of my first pastas, but the creepiness factor remains strong as ever.

44Dead Bart
I wonder what Matt was going through when he made this.

45Spongecry.avi
An episode when Gary died, SpongeBob kept crying till he got so decayed a lot! The pic gave me nightmares...

46Annabelle the Doll

47The Godzilla Nes Game Hack

48Mr. Fuzzy
This story is long, but well-worth the read! Very creepy and disturbing.

49Luna Game 0
I played it on roblox. -Alexis Thompson-Tomlinson
How is this NOT on here? Pinkamena is CREEPY!
Ughh... creepy. Never playing that game.

username34


50Robert the Doll

51Polybius

52The Autopsy of Cole Ryder

53Deprivation

54The Terrible Secret of Animal Crossing
I'm Not sure if this is A creepypasta to you, but it Scared
Me a lot, The Most Gross Part Was When the Character (Billy) Has his eye pulled out, This is a very long creepypasta. It is based off of the game series Animal Crossing.

55Emma by Chris Craft
Not a creepy pasta but a good story

JaysTop10List

Creepy story. The end said something like "But nothing could explain the face that appears on my ceiling some nights." I try not to look at my ceiling anymore, and I hope beyond content that my window blinds don't randomly start banging against the window. 0_0

username34


56Rock Motto
This Ceepypasta Is about a Guy who YouTube pooped SpongeBob and this YouTube poop is very disturbing! Do not watch!

57The Dawn is Your Enemy
I've seen this creepypasta in real life. No joke. I saw this on Adult Swim the other day and it was from a Twitter bump. I also saw this at the end of Inuyasha a few years ago.

58Radiation's Halloween Hack
Damn, this hack was disturbing... I mean, seriously, how much creepier and more depressing can you get? It's like the Majora's Mask of Earthbound, only MUCH scarier.

59Max and Ruby 0004
Where can I get a copy of the dvd? -Alexis Thompson-Tomlinson
I love max and ruby how could you people it made meh cry

60The Sand Man
How did you forget the sand man

61Happy Appy

62Thomas and the Children
By the way there is no narrator, there are murderous messages at the end, and the children are made of wood.
You will have to look this up before laughing out loud and thinking it was a regular episode. It is a creepypasta. 1 spoiler warning: he [Thomas] did kill Bertie the bus.

63B.O.B.

64Hetalia Episode 23.5

65Grinny

66Ed Edd Eddy "Lost Episode"

67He's Still Out There

68Herobrine
I heard a child just killed Herobrine in Minecraft PE and guess what he got... loads of diamonds! You can watch it in YouTube.
Just creepy even though I kill him all the time on Minecraft
I didn't know herobrine was a creepypasta, in fact he isn't a scary creepypasta
More comments about Herobrine

69Happy from McDonald's
Happy from mcdonalds is NOT scary he is funny
Has a pasta ben made about this yet?

michaelthecritic


70Rap Rat

Comments About This List

Featured Lists
Popular Lists
New Lists

Top Remixes of This List

AlexandraMoonDust

tranhotwheel04

Pony_forever

SOUTHPARKFANHH

PopTartCookie

see more...

Posts About This List

List Info

This list was created 328 days ago and has been voted on over 300 times. This top ten list has been remixed 14 times.

Updated Sunday, September 21, 2014


List Error Reporting

See an item on this list that's misspelled, duplicated, or doesn't belong? Let us know. Click here to report the error.