D'ERLANGER vs. X-JAPAN

ronluna which of them is more metal?

LA VIE EN ROSE 2008


la vie en rose, xxx for you, dummy blue, gekkou, so..., zakuro vs. jade, art of life, orgasm, kurenai

isono kyo hiroshi vs. toshimitsu deyama
ichirou cipher takigawa vs. hideto hide matsumoto, pata
nakao seela tomohiro vs. taiji sawada, heath
tetsu kikuchi vs. yoshiki hayashi

17 years break vs. 10 years break
no additional members vs. sugizo (luna sea)

dont use popularity in this one

EDIT: and my vote is mainly affected by vocals

Comments

Why do you go on about derlanger cant you respect someone elses opinion and you're blind by derlanger. X japan's art of life beats all of those songs single handly. Also sugizo is sixth member because hide died you idiot research it before you write about it. And when you say dont use poularity on this one on every list i've done you've put tonnes of d'erlanger! you like there groupie and biggest fan lol. X japan rock and considering d'erlanger may have been an inspiration to luna sea and glay and dir en grey but not as much as x japan visual kei pioneers and discovered each of these bands and produced them and made them highly successful. Each x japan member is better than any of those bands mentioned and d'erlanger. No offence but yoshiki is the best composer and drummer in jrock and maybe top 10 in the world. Toshi great vocalist and frontman as he interacts with the audience more than any band in jrock. More than malice mizer, dir en grey and luna sea put together. taiji great bassist probably top 5 alongside heath, toshiya, yuki, j and barry sparks and billy sheehan from B'z. hide greatest ever enough said. And pata in top 5 alongside hide, sugizo, hizaki and teru. I know i go on about x japan but B'z, Dir en grey, alice nine, luna sea, malice mizer an phantamoriga are better than D'erlanger, and dir en grey, mucc and especially x japan are heavier. X japan are hugely popular in japan and are repsected by everyone even in other countries. X japan are very underrated as in the uk people thought it was dir en grey and girugamesh who were the first visual kei bands. I know i've went on loads but your annoying as you cant say that x japan even if you dont like them are visual kei pioneers, genre smashers, and a very heavy band. D'erlanger are great probably one of my favorite bands joint with X japan, luna sea, sambomaster, dir en grey, malice mizer, moi dix mois, mucc, versailles, phantasmoriga and B'z.I respect these bands and think they're brillantly and i just dont go on about one band like you so can you at least stop goin on about d'erlanger and do any other band i know it may be difficult but could you try at least? - TD17

why are you telling me that we HAVE different views
youre the idiot here im not only a fan of d'erlanger
x-japan is way overrated, you could say that because of fans, wtf
look at fansites at least
x-japan has more fans than dead end and d'erlanger
they mentioned x-japan, luna sea, but they forgot dead end d'erlanger
id researched all the visual kei foundations and there are many bands that contributed to visual kei
like BOOWY, DEAD END, D'ERLANGER, LUNA SEA, BUCK TICK. try to respond to this but im tired if listening to those very common bands, all people who knows x-japan, malice mizer, gackt but what about others? loudness is not common also - ronluna

ARGUABLE WITH WHICH IS YOUR TASTE
if im annoyed theres nothing u can do
if i like it same reason either
we just have different tastes - ronluna

this is the same with which of the artists are very annoying or does like you the most
for which i find it cooler
isono hiroshi has grown a lot, hyde, (i just dont like gackt and toshi's voice, alice nine as a whole and other visual kei artists)

common sound is very disposable while unique sound does
try to ask more people - ronluna

art of life is not a reason why x-japan is the greatest, people are very annoyed with their sound not as pioneers of visual rock
x-japan and d'erlanger are the best if you could argue with me
ive stated that x-japan is so popular and i want dead end and d'erlanger to be popular too
what about if only x-japan is the only band in the world that is very annoying also, even if it is your or my favorite - ronluna

LOUDNESS is also great you should mention them as well
and also the most annoying thing is why are we still arguing which is the best?
i argue which has the best sound
if i like luna sea, d'erlanger, dead end, l'arc and sometimes annoyed with dir en grey, etc.
i dont want to be influenced by i dont like at all
B'z, is great add bass and drums to it it will be better
my music is not yours, and yours is not mine either
EQUALITY FOR ALL
no offense, etc comments are very annoying and an insult, you should state "IN MY OWN OPINION" - ronluna

i just stated that i try to dominate the top tens to become popular so many artists becomes more popular - ronluna

THEY ARE THE BEST IS FALSE i dont ever believe in such a thing
if i like it, and i hate it
i like that sound more than that
i find it more annoying because its very repetitive
the most influential bands should receive more credit
thats my own criteria - ronluna

all people are the same there is one big in me, im a serious type of person and arguing with all nonsense things is useless no matter what you say - ronluna

so stop insulting me and stop the nonsense talks - ronluna

stop calling me a person with only one favorite band
dead end, l'arc, d'erlanger, luna sea, bug, craze, die in cries, b'z are my favorites NO LESS NO MORE ARGUMENTS
and dont ever influence me to listen to x-japan, malice mizer, aline nine(the most annoying), even asian kung fu generation is very annoying
punk, alternative, blues, hard rock, industrial, i listen to them all but i hate the band who has very annoying voice and music - ronluna

im not the only fan of d'erlanger and im not their biggest fan "the annoying fangirls term"
- ronluna

d'erlanger win. - visitor

I agree,X JAPAN is really overrated,yet so many idiots can't see the truth.I am laughing so hard looking to X JAPAN now! - visitor

to:anoymous --->pls specify your name to be known - ronluna