Most Underrated Gaming Creepypastas

The Top Ten

1 Imscared.Exe

2 Happymouse.Exe

3 Apple.Exe

4 Sally.Exe

5 Sunshine.Exe

6 The Black Room - Roblox

7 The Statue - Roblox

8 Deletion of a World

9 Sonic.exe

Underrated? True,people thinks it's not scary but it's scariest creepypasta I've ever watch

10 Skydoesminecraft.Exe

The Contenders

11 Polybius

Is not a Creepypasta is a urban legend

12 Tails Doll Curse - Sonic R

13 [OLD] Minecraft Creepypasta

14 Come Follow Me - Pokemon

15 Radiation's Halloween Hack

BAdd New Item