Top Ten Worst Metallica Songs

The Contenders: Page 2XW


Awesome riff and solo! Song is too long though

I don't hate many Metallica songs, but this one isn't good at all.

It is not as good as the others. Still a great song, but...
It kinda bores me after a while listening to it. And how are some really great songs are on this list?! Come on! Please vote.

22Hero of the Day

Why in the hell are some actually good songs in the Top 10 worst, when this isn't!?!?! This song isn't even bad, but it's the worst one on here, I thought. And why is no leaf clover third!?!? I LOVE THAT SONG.

One of The best songs by Metallica.

V1 Comment
23Sweet Amber

Hurts my Ears, Sickens my stomach

Without the awful drums would fit in in any other newer album. The only good song on st anger.

V1 Comment
24Pumping Blood
25Poor Twisted Me

I actually like this song. It's one of my favorite songs off of Load. Hugely underrated.

The only Metallica song which I don't like

V4 Comments
26Some Kind of Monster

I like this song's short version but this is so long and annoying!

Bad song. This song kinda annoyed me. There's nothing so special about this song. Please vote!

This song did not even want me to listen to the other songs on the album. Uck

27I Disappear

Hey... Hey, Hey! This song's great, and it Shouldn't be on here. - AggressiveBlaze

V2 Comments
282 X 4

Sorry for the 2 X 4 lovers, but this song just sucks. And what is To Live is to Die doing here!?!? And mama said or even Phantom Lord, what is this. And Get The day that never comes off this list, it's great. What

V2 Comments
29No Leaf Clover

This is a good song. Are you crazy? The symphony goes really well with it. I don't understand why people don't like it. Sure The Ectasy of Gold was the best part of S and M, but still this is a great song in my opinion

Metallica with symphony is the worst. First thought. Second one, why the f is master of puppets on here at all? Anyone who knows anything about Metallica knows that that is one of their best songs EVER. The comment on their ways that he hates Master of Puppets but loves no leaf clover. WTF?!?!? He isn't a Metallica fan. Just gtfo. - Dragonbacon522

This is a fairly awesome song and its bs that its on the list.

V2 Comments
30The Struggle Within

The Black Album, Kill Em All, Load, Reload, for God's sake Master of Puppets and Ride the Lightning.. Why are songs off of these albums there. You want a top 10 list of the worst Metallica songs just pick 10 off of Lulu and there you have it. Maybe throw in a couple St. Anger in there, even though that album was decent.. Lulu was... God almighty it was HORRIBLE.

This song kind of irritates me. But it's decent. - IronSabbathPriest

It is not as good as the others. It is so freakin predictable. BUT I STILL LOVE IT!

V2 Comments
31Fight Fire with Fire

I'd put this in their top 10 best songs - BronzeWolf96

Are you kidding me? Other than Battery, this might be the best opening song on a Metallica album. Good grief.

This one is one of the best Metallica songs!

How did this get on here?

V15 Comments
32King Nothing

Changing your musical style to stay relevant does NOT make you a 'sell-out'. Their music was just as meaningful. And 'Death Magnetic' came outta nowhere and made a last stand for the genre of thrash metal.

You guys obviously have no clue about music this is a great song and if you disagree well your a loser

this is a sell out song and a disgrace and how the heck is phamtom lord, to live is to die, and I of the beholder who ever put these clasic songs on this list is a poser little kid

Shouldn't be on here.

V2 Comments
33Free Speech for the Dumb

This cover is an absolute joke... Easily the worst on this list, along with the entire Lulu album.


Worst song that is not on St. Anger

Here are my top 10 worst Metallica Songs
1. Temptation
2. The View
3. Fixxxer
4. Purify
5. Frustration
6. Lords of Summer
7. All Within my hands
8. My Apocalypse
9. Suicide & Redemption
10. The Judas Kiss

V3 Comments
35Prince CharmingV1 Comment
36So What
37The Unnamed Feeling

Still a bad song, even though it was one of the better tracks on St. Anger.

My least favourite Metallica song of all time.


Why the hell is there even a list for this

This is a great song why is it here

Oh come on, ya just gotta love Motorbreath! You gotta! YOU REALLY HAVE TA!

Another awesome song that shouldn't be on the list. - IronSabbathPriest

V5 Comments
39My Friend of Misery

This is an awesome song! Whoever made tis list has to rethink and make it again. Phantom lord, my world, master of puppets, my friend of misery, struggle within... What?

This is just a shame from Metallica and I hope they make new GOOD songs at least.

V1 Comment
40The Day that Never Comes

One of my favorite Metallica songs. in my humble opinion, those last three minutes was epic. How could it even be on here? I don't understand, but looking at some of the other songs in here, I guess the trend just happened to include this song.

James new voice scared me when I first listened to it

V1 Comment
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Best Metallica Songs Best Songs On Metallica's Black Album Best Songs On Metallica's Death Magnetic Top Ten Classic Metallica Songs Best Songs From Metallica's Ride the Lightning

List StatsUpdated 7 Dec 2016

1,000 votes
90 listings
6 years, 342 days old

Top Remixes (14)

1. Junior Dad
2. We Did It Again
3. All Within My Hands
1. Fight Fire with Fire
2. Motorbreath
3. Phantom Lord
1. The View
2. Temptation
3. Brandenburg Gate

View All 14


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.