Top 10 Worst Warrior Cat Leaders

The Top Ten
1 Brokenstar Brokenstar is a villain character from the Warrior Cats series. Brokenstar is a matted, dark brown tabby tom with a broad, flat face, a bent tail, and orange eyes. Brokenstar was a former Shadowclan leader and a member of the Dark Forest. His mother is Yellowfang and his father is Raggedstar.

I prefer him as Brokenkit,he was so innocent adorable and it was very sad how he got Rejected my Lizardstripe and bullied by her kits.I don't really blame him for becoming evil and cruel but he was such a horrible brat when adult.Killed his own father (I don't really like Ragged but at least he was better leader than him),Exiled Poor innocents Elders from their Clans,Blamed his Childhoob best friend (Yellowfang) For the terrible things he did by his own also exiling her,Making kits warriors early leading many of them to deat,I think he deserved to die but I'll always like him as a kit.

Yeah, I agree on Brokenstar, he even did something bad with the elders' den- sorry I don't remember what he did with the Elders' den but, he also blamed Yellowfang, one of my favorite characters, for EVERY SINGLE kit death.

He made kits apprentices when they are about 4 moons and made them warriors when they should just have became an apprentice, and why did you drive Yellowfang out?

2 Onestar Onestar is a fictional character from the book series "Warriors" by Erin Hunter. He is/was a WindClan leader, and is mottled, small, brown tom cat.

He was good before he became a leader. Well as far as we know. Turns out he doesn't care about his mates or kits, a liar, a danger to all the Clan and much more. He too scared that people make him look weak so he can't have any friends. Glad his son killed him. He was leader for way too long. I don't know who Harestar is, but I'm sure he'll be better than him.

I disagree with whoever hates One star. He was brave and honest and heroic. He was a great cat. I don't want to give any spoilers, but unless you read #3 Vision Of Shadows, you don't know his true amazing personality. He is my favourite character. - sunheart360

I respect your opinion but the person who thinks Graystripe will be a bad leader and Onestar is normal... I. DON'T agree. (I respect your opinion) He attacked Thunder Clan for almost no Reason! The ball the was also boring...

3 Leopardstar Leopardstar is a golden tabby she-cat with amber eyes.
Leopardstar was a leader of RiverClan in the forest and in the lake territories. Leopardkit was born to Mudfur and Brightsky alongside three unnamed kits; however, Brightsky and her littermates died during the kitting. Mudfur gave her the name of the mighty spotted cats from LeopardClan to give her the strength to survive. Shimmerpelt took... read more

She followed Tigerstar and let him hurt her clan for god knows why. Garbage leader, leaders are supposed to protect their clan and she failed spectacularly. SHE LET TIGERSTAR PIT HER OWN WARRIORS AGAINST HIS IN FIGHTS TO THE DEATH BECAUSE OF HER OWN PREJUDICE FOR PETES SAKE ARGH

Gotta admit, Leopardstar isn't too bad but, when you know how evil Tigerclawstar is, you gotta fight back, like, why did Leopardstar even let Darkstripe and Blackfoot kill Stonefur, Stonefur was literaly deputy!

She was spoiled as a kit and I know this is a opinion but I found her VERY annoying, bossy, and arrogant as a leader

4 Pinestar

Pinestar deserves to live with twolegs. How'd he ever become leader?

He left his son tigerkit/tigerclaw/tiger star, therefore he becomes evil not to mention he LEFT to become a KITTYPET

5 Tigerstar Tigerstar is a villain in the Warriors series by Erin Hunter. Son of Leopardfoot and Pinestar, former mate of Goldenflower and Sasha, and father of Bramblestar, Tawnypelt, Mothwing, Hawkfrost, and Tadpole. This brown tabby cat almost causes the downfall of the clans. But is killed, firstly by Scourge, who strips all his lives away. And then by Firestar, who moves on to StarClan when they meet again... read more

His ambition overtook him. killed Redtail, Runningwind, Gorsepaw, Brindleface, and his own leader just so he could lead. Thankfully he was exiled, but him leading ShadowClan was still bad. He even brought dogs to camp, which killed Swiftpaw and injured Brightheart. So happy that Scourge killed him. Then he even affects Lionpaw, as he is his dark forest trainee. Won't say anything else because I'm only on Outcast.

He was cruel, rude, and arrogant. I personally think that he should have been fed to the wolves!

This dude should be on top. I mean, how stupid can you be to put Tigerstar not as bad as Bramblestar or Sunstar?!

6 Sunstar

Why is he here?

7 Teller Of Pointed Stones
8 Bramblestar Bramblestar is the leader of ThunderClan. His mate is Squrrielflight and his kits are Dandilionkit, Juniperkit, Sparkpelt and Alderheart. Bramblestar sister is Tawnypelt, his parents are Goldenflower and Tigerstar. Bramblestar is a huge and muscular dark brown tabby tom with amber eyes, he has sleek fur, long claws, and a scar on his shoulder.

Though Graystripe should have been leader, I don't think Bramblestar is bad. I mean, he is awesome

I have just never liked him that much... Don't hate me.

Bossy, brought a bunch of kittypets when not food enough for the clan

9 Clear Sky

He should be number one! I hate him and he's the worst. He's mean, makes a lot of cats kill each other then trys to make people feel bad for him. He's horrible to his son and his brother. He has too many mates and obviously to old for Star Flower because Thunder liked her.

I felt bad for him, when his first mate died and after that just got irritated. I tried so hard to feel sympathy for him, but I just couldn't. He got me more angry than Tigerstar did... He's not the worst leader but he wasn't a good one either.

He's an idiot stupid and has an ugly personality and he has 3 girls I bet if star flower dies he will get another girl he is a saddo I don't like him he should be number 1

10 Scourge Scourge is a villain the Warrior Cats series. He's the leader of BloodClan. He was bullied by his siblings, Socks and Ruby, in the past because he was the smallest out of his kin. One of his most notable features is his collar of dog teeth. Scourge is a small black tom with one white paw, ice-blue eyes, glossy fur, and a torn left ear. He has a purple collar studded with teeth from dogs and cats,... read more

Scourge Actually Feed His Clan and Defended Him but put them in Harms way and Was a bit too cruel but took care of his "clanmates" I'm just surprised you fellow cats voted him to be #11 and not #1 or #3 - EchoStar

Scourge was a pretty bad leader, not feeding his Clanmates, although he did solve a whole lot of problems, I feel like they weren't very good solutions.

Are you MARRIED to Scourge! Have you bees in your brain!?

The Contenders
11 Bluestar Bluestar is a character in the Warrior Cats series. She was one of the leaders of ThunderClan. She broke the code by being mates with Oakheart of RiverClan and having her kits, Stonefur and Mistyfoot, and Mosskit. Stonefur and Mistyfoot live in RiverClan, while Mosskit died of hypothermia. She has a sister named Snowfur, a mother named Moonflower, and a father named Stormtail. Bluestar is a large,... read more

Bluestar was the reason tigerstar lead all the dogs to the forest and the reason why swiftpaw is now dead. If it wasnt for her fox hearted behavior swiftpaw would have been alive and brightpaw wouldn't have to live the rest of her life hiding because she has major anxienty and shes scared people will judge her for her face.

Bluestar did not believe in starclan nor trusted starclan after the fire. She put her clan down and did nothing to even support them. She named brightpaw lostface due to "starclan letting this accident happen" she is a paranoid queen and does not deserve to be in starclan. For starclans sake she even abandoned her own kits just to be the deputy. Shes a stupid fox hearted furball.

Anyone who hates Bluestar can SUCK. IT.
( she went mad from stress, I mean, don't we all...? )

12 Firestar Firestar is a character in the Warrior Cats series. He becomes the leader of ThunderClan after Bluestar. He is mates with Sandstorm and has two kits: Squirrelflight and Leafpool. Formerly a kittypet named Rusty, Firestar is killed by fatal wounds inflicted by the spirit of Tigerstar and a falling tree... read more

You only like firestar because you see from his point of view. He made many mistakes that risked the respect of ThunderClan. Not to mention RUINED the Thunderclan blood with kitty pet blood. He brought in kitty pets who had kits who had more Half-Clan kits. I don't mind clan blood and rogue blood mixing, but kittypet blood? And firestar didn't try to invade territory, resulting in ThunderClan looking weak. I hate him. He deserves to fade from Starclan.
~ Embertail

Summary of Firestar:

Idiot. Kittpet lover. WAY too peaceful. Coward. Disloyal. Hypocrite.

AND BASICALLY, THE WORST LEADER EVER (tied with Bramblestar)!

Firestar is the best! If you don't like him, you don't like Warriors. STOP READING WARRIORS IF YOU DISLIKE HIM MOUSE BRAINS!

13 Oakstar

He’s the reason for everything bad that happened in the entire series. Let me explain...

So he kicked out Mapleshade, a helpless queen, along with LITTLE TINY KITTENS, and they DIED. Like what else could’ve happened? He obviously knew they would die. This causes poor Mapleshade to go a little... insane. She did things to Crookedstar, killed a few Thunderclan cats, and pretty much ran the dark forest while Thistleclaw trained there. Thistleclaw was Tigerstar’s mentor, and we all know where that went. But back to Oakstar. He raised his son, Pinestar, to be the cat he was. Oakstar kind of just dumped all the stress of being leader on his young son. That made Pinestar leave for the easy life of a kittypet. That fueled Tigerstar’s rage and started a huge chain of terrible events that can all be traced back to Oakstar. In my opinion, he needs more votes on here.

I read some of the comments on Oakstar, Oakstar exiled Mapleshade?! Welp, now I know who exiled Mapleshade, just, why Oakstar? Why exile a half-drowned she-cat with three drowned kits?

14 Ripplestar (Shadowclan)

attacked the clans under the full moon

He's the one who got killed by StarClan. Ohhh! I wonder if he's in Dark Forest.

15 Raggedstar

He was mean to Yellowfang. After Brokenkit was born, he acted like she was a good-for-nothing useless piece of fur.

Well, Raggedstar wasn't too bad of a leader, but he was really mean to Yellowfang, who is one of my favorite characters, and I was suprised when he was killed by HIS OWN KIT, like, bruh.

He was so mean to Yellowfang

16 Heatherstar

Heatherstar was wonderful. What are you talking about?

Heatherstar was a great leader

17 Leafstar

Though she isn't the best name giver, she is still great

18 Nightstar

NightStar sucks. Just, I hate him. He was leader FOR TWO BOOKs! Never again

I mean really not letting cats go to gatherings? He was to old.

19 Shadowstar

Wait... Shadowstar? You mean like the first shadowclan leader? I'm sure he couldn't be really bad.

I love Shadowstar. Why is she on here?

20 Featherstar

She made a cat deputy who was young,had no experience what's so ever and never had an apprentice.if you ask me she was to easy going and hardly ever stood up for her clan

21 Hailstar

He was a bit of an ass. " I want Reedfeather's kits back even though I gave them to WindClam. Oh, I know! We will attack them for no damn reason at all because I need to keep my rep of being an Ass as high as possible." GRRR

stole kits after giving them away

22 Darktail
23 Badgerstar
24 Darkstar (RiverClan)
25 One Eye
8Load More
PSearch List