Most Overrated Bookssaaarsdej
The Contenders: Page 2
I'm writing it from a Polish point of view. It's one of the books we have to read at school and every literature teacher seems to love it and the minority who doesn't see it as a masterpiece is getting bashed. It's a bit ironic though, because the book that was basically saying 'f you' to people who criticized Gombrowicz's earlier work and yet it's the one most praised by critics and teachers. - saaarsdej
The plot doesn't make sense sometimes, the tension is too low for a good thriller, the only truly interesting character dies too early, it would take days to list all the parts where Dan Brown did not put enough effort in research. Yet it's a bestseller in many countries of the World, there are almost scientific debates about it, there's a movie adaptation and a PC game... I don't get it. - saaarsdej
I have no idea how popular it is in the rest of the World, but if there's a movie, it has to be, at least at some point. It's really not good though. As much as I usually love Scandinavian crime books in general, I really dislike this one. The plot makes no sense at times and the action is rather boring apart from few plot twists. The main protagonist and the main anthagonist are in fact both bastards, so readers can't really take sides. Actually the only person I symphatized with in a whole book was the one that made a cameo in the first and the last chapter of the book. - saaarsdej
Many people claimed this story changed their approach to life, made them care more about the others or started living their life different way, but I didn't feel anything like that. It is somewhat touching, but using a little cancer patient has to work that way. Reading this was a disappointing to me. Or maybe I'm just heartless. - saaarsdej
This book is so godammed overrated. There is enough plot to fill a book of mabye 1/4 that size, with the rest being pointless filler. It is a mediocre at best book that has a following approaching that of the bible, and is the "gold" standard for all modern fantasy books, leading to an endless parade of the same tired elves, dwarves, and orcs routine. The lore makes zero sense and all of the supposedly "powerful" characters spend the whole book doing jack while the author tells you how awesome they could be if they actually used their powers.
This is awful and unreadable. The interesting parts are glossed over in the same monotonous narrative and it just is so boring.
One-time-read book; 3rd part - return of king is complete disaster, description of battle is unreadable - dubbelvla
I tried to read the first one really boring and a long 50 pages.
Seeing it as one of the most romantic stories ever is just plain wrong. The main characters basically ruined eachothers' and everyone else's lives because they both were too proud to make a confession or to try to get the situation fixed. Where's anything romantic in that? It has really good dark atmosphere though which makes it readable. - saaarsdej
I used to love this book in my teens. Was more sceptical about it while reading it (obligatory) during my English studies. Now, few more years later, I find this book rather boring and very naive.
Poorly written -- too bad English teachers think it is wonderful.
Very dull and boring text.
Really? A holy book?
Should be banned.
The best book ever!V 1 Comment
Some stories are great, funny and imaginative, Pilipiuk has many great ideas and isn't scared to try any of them even the silly ones. But after some time reading about an old drunkard hunting all kinds of supernatural stuff gets boring. - saaarsdej
I love and hate these books, the first series was decent and I liked the idea, but it just goes on and on and most of the characters are bad, Firestar, the main character is flawless, most of the main characters are, plus the fans are annoying and have to make everything warrior related
Thank you, it's so annoying when people go on and on about this book series, they're constantly rubbing it in people's faces.
More overrated then Harry potter
This is my favorite book series, but I have to admit it is overrated and goes downhill after Midnight. After Midnight everyone is a Mary Sue and many characters are overrated (coughcoughJayfeathercoughcough). The only overrated books are those after The Prophecies Begin and Midnight. I think the original series should be celebrated. Although I am a fan of Harry Potter and think that they deserve to be higher, to whoever said this is more overrated than Harry Potter.
Lucy Maud Montgomery created many stories about many different young girls Why is she most famous because of the most irritating and the least interesting of them all? That's something I will never understand. - saaarsdej
I actually criefd over this book when matthew dies. READ IT IF YOU LIKE READING!
This book was absolutely pointless. - francesco
This is the book that comes to mind whenever I think of 'overrated novels'. It's frequently taught to students as an introduction to the idea of allegory, likely because the allegory is extremely blatant in this novel. Combined with very flat ideas of 'good' and 'evil', this book blows ass.
I've heard tons of praise from tons of friends about this book. After I've read it, I was extremely, downright, utterly disappointed. Hannah Baker committed suicide and leaves tapes to blame other people and say that it's their fault that she killed herself. Well, point blank is that it was her choice if she would let other people crush her and she vindicated their success on doing so by killing herself.
Her 13 reasons why seemed too petty to be intertwined with the decision of a person to kill herself. Asher made Hannah seem like a shallow, vengeful character thus making it difficult to relate to her or at least feel sorry for her. I felt like she was the bad guy the whole time I was reading the book.
I don't understand how people consider this "insipirational." I don't think a girl who committed suicide for insubstantial causes then leaves tapes to haunt people's conscience (even if, in my opinion, they didn't deserve so) could in any way serve as an ...more
I hate this book. I'll admit it, I absolutely hate this book, and I usually like realistic teenage drama, heck, Catcher in the Rye is probably my favorite book. This was being called The Catcher in the Rye of its time. Lets compare the two. Moral: CitR- growing up is an essential yet unpleasant part of life and it is okay to keep some of your childhood innocence. PoBaW- Hey kids, drugs are good for you, (Yay), abusive relationships are fun (which weirdly contradicts itself), sex is all that matters, and many more messed up morals like that. Characters- CitR-The main character is obnoxious but he is relateable due to his refusal to want to grow up. PoBaW- The characters are complete morons (which is weird because the author intended them to be smart). It also contains the worst character I have ever come across, Charlie's Sister, but I'll leave her alone for now. I almost expected to see all of these characters kill themselves out of sheer stupidity. Setting- CitR- Kind of dirty but ...more
I do enjoy this book, but it's not as relatable as people claim.
It was good, but not as good as people claim it to be. - pjo
Coincidentally, I did not like this book. It wan't the worst book I've ever read, but it was not worth the hype around it. - Rottenboy22
I found this book really boring and I was barely able to finish it. - pjo
This is an excellent book. I'm guessing whoever put this on the list is a shallow person who prefers action and explosions in comics.V 1 Comment
Related ListsTop Ten Most Overrated Movies Based On Books Most Overrated Diary of a Wimpy Kid Books Most Overrated Actors/Actresses Most Overrated Rappers of All Time Top Ten Best Books of All Time
List StatsUpdated 23 Aug 2017
5 years, 82 days old
Top Remixes (6)
2. Ferdydurke - Witold Gombrowicz
3. The Da Vinci Code - Dan Brown
2. The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
3. Mockingjay - Suzanne Collins
2. Divergent - Veronica Roth
3. Percy Jackson Series
View All 6