Top 10 Best 3D Sonic Games

SuperSonic17
People say Sonic sucks in 3D, but in retrospect he's actually had more good 3D games than a lot of franchises that fell hard when making the jump from 2D to 3D. Here are the 10 best 3D Sonic games in the main series (some are only here by default as there are bad ones).

The Top Ten

1 Sonic Colours

I don't know, this game is really overrated and has a lot of problems for it to be even considered the best 3D Sonic game along with Generations.

The both aren't bad, they're pretty good, but I wouldn't call them the best due to a terrible story with terrible writing and mediocre voice acting, very short games overall, too much 2D, and (Colors) abusing wisps too much at the pint where it's not even a Sonic game anymore. - MasterCreepy

This game is awesome! I loved the songs too! - TwilightKitsune

It's great in the gameplay department, though the music doesn't compare to "Live and Learn..."

It's good, but the writing and voice acting sucks. I think we need a replacement. - MasterCreepy

V 8 Comments
2 Sonic Adventure 2

This game has the best 3D gameplay for Sonic in my opinion! Colors and Generations are awesome but they're too linear for me. I just want to see a new Sonic game that doesn't ride on nostalgia (like this one)!

God I wish I had this game. Also, I was wondering, are the Knuckles and Rouge levels really that bad? Because they looked good to me. - EspioTheChameleon

Loved the story. And I enjoyed this gameplay more than Sonic Adventure's.

This game is awesome

V 3 Comments
3 Sonic Generations

Meh, I wouldn't say so. This game is much more overrated than Colors. The only good reason why people call this the "best 3D Sonic game" is because of the PC Mods.

The story sucks even more than it did in Colors, everyone else just stands there like useless crap, the voice acting is much worse, the writing is bland, the game is unoriginal, the game itself and levels are too short, the bosses are too easy, and just not much in the game to give a great impression like what Unleashed did. Sure Sonic controls better than what he did in Unleashed, but it doesn't add up much. The soundtrack is good though.

Seriously? Sonic Unleashed deserved the PC port, not Generations. - MasterCreepy

The best gameplay-wise, in my opinion. I had so much fun playing it. Too short though.

Described by IGN as "A love letter to the Blue Blur", which combines the best of the old and the new, with both classic and modern Sonic. This game features some of the best designed and fleshed out levels ever seen in a Sonic game.
If only the game wasn't so short. Oh well, maybe the upcoming Project Sonic 2017 will deliver on this game's shortcomings. - SuperSonic17

It's great

V 2 Comments
4 Sonic Unleashed

This needs to replace Colors. Colors does not deserve that #1 spot, it had terrible writing and voice acting, too much 2D and too short.

It's like the fanbase and EVEN SEGA forgot Sonic Unleashed existed. - MasterCreepy

The best sonic final boss battle. EVER. - HeavyDonkeyKong

Best Sonic Game PERIOD

Really good game, such a shame its underrated

V 8 Comments
5 Sonic Adventure

Pac-Man fell a lot less harder than Mega Man when they jumped form 2D to 3D. I was fine with Mega Man in 2D gameplay, but Capcom ran out of ideas. Namco didn't! Sonic's transition from 2D to 3D was smooth. Direction-wise, the Sonic franchise got partially ruined in Sonic Adventure by how the Modern/Dreamcast Era aspects are rather inferior to how they used to be in the Classic Era of Sonic, but Sonic Adventure proves that Sonic can sustain its might in 3D. Mario had a very smooth jump from 2D to 3D, but Classic Mario is mainly better than Modern Mario. Bubsy's jump from 2D to 3D was PATHETIC! Don't you love to make fun of this wannabe? Metal Gear's jump from 2D to 3D was also very smooth.

A lot of people say that it does not age well. perhaps it is nostalgia, but I believe that t has aged just fine. - HeavyDonkeyKong

How is this lower than Sonic Colors? I swear this list is so messed up. - MasterCreepy

SONIC COLORS IS FOR LITTLE KIDS WHO don't KNOW NOTHING ABOUT SONIC SUCKS, SONIC ADVENTURE IS 1000000 TIMES BETTER

V 1 Comment
6 Sonic Heroes

Every other team in Sonic Heroes is much better than Team Rose for reasons. That does not make the game, and give SuperSonic17 a round of applause. He judged this game in an incredibly fair way, which I don't always do. - The Ultimate Daredevil

I replayed this game at least 5 times. It may be because it was on of my first Sonic games, but also because I like variety of characters and fact that contents of stages are changed for every team!

Ah, Sonic Heroes what can I say about you. I really love the choices of four teams (my personal favorite is Team Chaotix) and the boss fights. But sometimes the controls get very slippery and the special stages can be hard, but I don't necessarily think they're bad. You just have to get used to them. Overall, I think this is a good game, nowhere near SA2 and Generations, but I would say it was as good as Colors. I don't care what you think, it's MY opinion. Thank you. - EspioTheChameleon

Even after a decade I still get a kick out of playing this; it was my childhood, I loved it then, I love it now. --p.s. the special stages physics went down the crapper before the game launched--

V 2 Comments
7 Sonic Lost World

An underrated game. I love it. The reason why is because it felt like a 3D version of a 2D Sonic Game. Screw IGN and Screw GameSpot. This game is awesome. Oh as @SuperSonic17 no it did not rip of Galaxy. Sonic Adventure 2 already had the "walking around platforms" gimmick. - DCfnaf

Extremely underrated. Do not listen to the critics. YOU are the critic of this game, whether you liked it or not.
The only things I would say about this game that bring it down are the terrible writing, the story, the villains, and useless characters (Knuckles and Amy do nothing in this game, hell why tf were they even there in the first place).
Also this game is NOT a ripoff of the Mario Galaxy games! Sheesh, why are people so dumb sometimes...
Also also great soundtrack. - MasterCreepy

Should be higher than Secret Rings because this game is better than that trash in my opinion. - DCfnaf

Very fun game. NOT a ripoff of galaxy. The insults sonic makes towards each of the deadly six are just hilarious. Oh, and the return of Baldy McNoiseHair! (Sonic's nickname for Eggman)

V 3 Comments
8 Shadow the Hedgehog

I know this game gets a lot of hate, but to me it's a great game. It's so much fun blasting stuff with guns and the varied story routes make it so playing through the game multiple times is never too repetitive. The controls hardly take any time to get used to and the game just gives you that feel of power and superiority that's just to satisfying.
If the aesthetics were better and some of the vehicles were more useful it could've easily been my favourite game. But I attest to the fact that more people need to give this game a fair chance and not just follow what everyone else says. - SuperSonic17

This game is, like most of the modern sonic titles, extremely criminally underrated. - HeavyDonkeyKong

I love the gameplay mechanics, the music, and then also and the story. What I hated:

Tons upon tons of levels revolve around you constantly taking laps around stages killing people or looking for things. It gets old and teious to have to do that to complete a level.

The whole entire "Choose Your Very Own path" Story driven mechanic was not utilized to its full potential.

Some of the endings did not provide closure. For example, we see Shadow killing eggman in one of the endings, but as a whole, it doesn't really seem like a true ending of the game. the black arms and the humans are both still fighting. - HeavyDonkeyKong

9 Sonic and the Black Knight

The last Sonic game with a good story and good writing.
After that we got games with trash stories, trash writing, and trash voice acting starting with Colors. - MasterCreepy

Playing this game is like cutting down the mightiest tree in the forest with... A HERRING!

A decent experience. Better than Secret Rings. - DCfnaf

My guilty pleasure - hugh201

V 2 Comments
10 Sonic 3D Blast

Why is this game so low? I liked my experience with this game, my only complaints are the slightly slippery controls and the game is too short, thank you GameHut for making a version that really fixes the controls!

The Contenders

11 Sonic Riders

My 2nd favorite Sonic game <3
Such a great, underrated game. - MasterCreepy

12 Sonic Forces

Yet another guilty pleasure for me and I actually replay it a lot - hugh201

My favorite game of Sonic

Ah, Sonic Forces. Even though we all think it is a disappointing game, I really want to play it since I’m so into it. The music, the custom hero, and the wispons that the avatar uses.

Its pretty cool but why does in the avatar stage it’s 2d and classic Sonic stages but modern sonic stages were 3D it makes no sense why it’s on this list - TopTenX

13 Sonic the Hedgehog (2006)

I'm very glad that you added Sonic 2006 to the list. The game is not as bad most people say it is. Popular opinions aren't always honest, you know.

It's not popular opinion, it's experts that play video games for a living going through them and getting killed or unable to complete a level because the game is actual trash. Sonic 06 is, overall, one of the worst game of all time. - ckets4769

I know what it is. Sonic Next-Gen is overly praised because of Princess Elise the Third!

At least the glitches were hilarious. - mattstat716

Great game anyone say otherwise is dumb

V 4 Comments
14 Sonic Riders: Zero Gravity

Yeah, I didn't put the Riders games on my original list as I was going for main series games and I consider these games spinoffs, otherwise I would've put this game in the top 10.
But hey, I ain't gonna be some cannon Nazi, if you guys want to include these games on your lists go right ahead, especially if you don't want to put Sonic 06 in the list. - SuperSonic17

15 Sonic Adventure DX

I think this version is better than the DreamCast version, except for the camera.

16 Sonic & the Secret Rings

It's debatable which is better/worse out of the two storybook games, as they both suck. In the end though I feel Secret Rings kept more true to Sonic's roots. There is speed, but it's hampered by awkward motion controls which feel twitchy and at times unresponsive. Also the level designs are the equivalent of train tracks, and as the game always forces you to go forwards it can feel like the game is playing itself.
Unlike Sonic & the Black Knight however this game at least didn't give me as bad wrist ache. This is the only one on the list which I simply don't recommend. - SuperSonic17

This was worse than Lost World. I thought Black Knight was better than this too, but your opinion is still respected. - DCfnaf

Stupidest Game I've Ever Played - VideoGamefan5

Here's how I consider these games from best to worst: (This includes the fun glitches you could do)

Sonic 06 (whilst bad , it felt more sonic-y and and had fun glitches.)
Secret Rings and Black Knight (Hard and Easy respectively, kinda dumb music, and bad
c ontrols.)
Lost World (My finger hurts from holding R. If a game physically hurts me, it is automatically
b ad.)
Sonic Boom Rise Of Lyric.
You know what, no paranthesis this time. This game was the absolute WORST of the series. Some might say 06 was sonic's beginning downfall -NO! Boom is the rock bottom. It is the ABSOLUTE WORST. At least 06 was made with at least SOME normal sonic intentions. You do ocassionally go fast. But in Boom? Nah. Good luck with that. You'll be slowly moving forever. Bland repeating levels... boring. Even the Knuckles Glitch Jump was patched, so automatic negative there for removing fun glitches. 06 had the guts to keep their glitches because they *knew* it was the one of the major ...more - mattstat716

V 1 Comment
17 SegaSonic the Hedgehog

This is extremely criminally underrated indeed. Well, so-rry I defend (Classic) Sonic/Mighty/Ray (in this game) for their spherical middles and unique capabilities! >8(

It's good. - SonictheHedgeho

18 Sonic Free Riders

This game would have been awesome. If the controls worked. - HeavyDonkeyKong

19 Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric

Should not be on this list. End of discussion. I'm voting for 06 to get it above this sorry excuse for a game. At least 06 had potential and was slightly fun to play.

People look at Sonic games as Sonic games. I look at them as any game in the world. Slow, why should I care? I never cared about the speed. I love how this game encourages exploration. It's only my 2nd favorite in the franchise, but If no one in here will defend it, then I will.

It's sad when 3D Blast (an isometric game) was higher than this "game". Can you really call it a sonic game when the characters feel like nothing sonic related? - mattstat716

This is on the list. The game that killed Sonic like 06..-.

Hey, exploration is back though! Not perfect but still something! Also Werehog ripoff combat. - MasterCreepy

V 5 Comments
20 Sonic Adventure 2 Battle

I've only played the gamecube port. Its multiplayer is amazing.

21 Sonic 3D Blast DX

Good - SonictheHedgeho

BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Top 10 Greatest Sonic The Hedgehog Games Most Underrated Sonic Games Top Ten Best Main Series Sonic the Hedgehog Games Top Ten Sonic the Hedgehog Video Games With the Best Graphics Top Ten Mario Games vs Sonic Games

List Stats

200 votes
21 listings
1 year, 290 days old

Top Remixes (9)

1. Sonic Adventure 2
2. Sonic Adventure
3. Sonic Colours
HeavyDonkeyKong
1. Sonic Adventure
2. Sonic Colours
3. Sonic Adventure 2
htoutlaws2012
1. Sonic Generations
2. Sonic Colours
3. Sonic 3D Blast
SuperheroSith

WRemix
View All 9

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.
P