Top Ten Alternative Song Titles with a Word Replaced with the Word "Creepypasta"

The Top Ten

1 War of Creepypasta (War of Change)

2 Master of Creepypasta (Master of Puppets)

And the master of the creepypasta is...

3 Cheap Creepypasta (Cheap Thrills)

Creepypasta Fan: Ugh, this is so cheap!

4 I Want A Creepypasta for Christmas (I Want A Hippopotamus for Christmas)

Mom: Oh so you want Slenderman for Christmas?

I want Laughing Jack for Christmas

I want Smile Dog for Christmas

5 Creepypasta Hoe (Stupid Hoe)

A pervert and a big fan of Creepypasta will describe it.

6 Elastic Creepypasta (Elastic Heart)

7 Creepypasta Space (Blank Space)

8 I Will Always Love Creepypasta (I will always Love You)

9 Creepypasta Romance (Bad Romance)

Dating Jeff the Killer sucks!
But Italian pizza is awesome!

You and Jeff the Killer dating!? (Birdechosplash reference by the way)

10 My Creepypasta Will Go On (My Heart Will Go On)

The Contenders

11 Baby One More Creepypasta (Baby One More Time)

What I say when somebody is getting bored with Creepypasta and I want more.

12 Fear of the Creepypasta (Fear of the Dark)

13 Should Creepypasta Stay or Should Creepypasta Go (Should I Stay or Should I Go)

Creepypasta should stay.

BAdd New Item