Top Ten America's Got Talent Judges


The Top Ten

1 Howie Mandel Howie Mandel

Howie... the best you could get.

Who doesn't like Howie? - xXbfdi_bhabieXx

Howie is so kind

I love Bowie he rocks

V 1 Comment
2 Simon Cowell Simon Cowell Simon Phillip Cowell is an English reality television judge, entrepreneur, philanthropist, film, record, and television producer.

For all the people saying Simon is a mean narcissist, he has actually changed quite a bit, and is very kind nowadays, and for the few saying he is annoying because of this, he does still share his opinion which he believes in.
Howie Mandel appreciates too many silly acts, and doesn't like any of the actually good acts, so I don't understand how he is number 1, but he still is a good judge in general (Howie.) - MaxAurelius

That face is gonna be in my nightmares now - KingSlayer93316

I usually have the same opinion as him on acts. Just watched the Season 13 premiere last night. - PackFan2005

Simon is a very honest judge, he isn't afraid to tell the truth and to be honest Simon can be a real dicl sometimes but I know that it's part of his job to judge a contestant truthfully.

V 6 Comments
3 Piers Morgan Piers Morgan Piers Stefan Pughe-Morgan, known professionally as Piers Morgan, is a British journalist and television personality currently working as the US editor-at-large for Mail Online.

He's the best this was his show before they took it from him.

The best

Piers Morgan is currently the only good judge on the show. He's the only judge that actually criticizes and buzzes the bad acts. The best judge ever.

In my opinion, he's the only ACTUAL judge ever on the show. The other judges should be called worshipers instead of judges.

V 2 Comments
4 Mel B Mel B

Mel is the most authentic and honest of the judges. She comes across as the warmest (SImons the coldest). Shame Simon uses her as the scapegoat.

Mel is the BEST - Luckys

Her laughing make more happy

I love Mel B! She needs to be number one and she always gives an honest opinion

V 5 Comments
5 Howard Stern Howard Stern Howard Allan Stern is an American radio and television personality, producer, author, actor, and photographer.

Yes - Spiritualsavedboy

the best

He was the only judge to tell the honest truth to the contestants. He only gave out standing ovations when they were deserved (unlike the other judges, who gave them out constantly). He was very funny. And let's not forget that he was the one who brought America's Got Talent to Radio City Music Hall.

Pretty much the new Piers Morgan. Howie's the one who sees the talent in people, and Sharon... Well she breaks the ties (usually in favor of the contestant). Howard tells the honest truth about the acts, and that's great.

6 David Hasselhoff David Hasselhoff David Michael Hasselhoff, nicknamed "The Hoff", is an American actor, singer, producer, and businessman, who set a Guinness World Record as the most watched man on TV.
7 Sharon Osbourne Sharon Osbourne

Guys mel B sucks and The other new one. Sharon was nice, honest, and friendly. Love her British accent. That's horrible that they replaced her with those two retarded freaks.

8 Heidi Klum Heidi Klum Heidi Klum is a German model, television host, businesswoman, fashion designer, television producer, and occasional actress.

This picture is... revealing? - MaxAurelius


Should Be Number 3 - Hafizhiskandar

That picture is scaring me... - Popsicles

V 1 Comment
9 Brandy Norwood
10 Neil Patrick Harris Neil Patrick Harris Neil Patrick Harris is an American actor, writer, producer, comedian, magician, and singer. He is known primarily for his comedy roles on television and his dramatic and musical stage roles.

He gave Piff the Golden Buzzer. I agree with him.

The Contenders

11 Nick Cannon Nick Cannon Nicholas Scott "Nick" Cannon is an American rapper, actor, comedian, entrepreneur, record producer, radio and television personality.

He always supports people if they didn't make it through. - funnyuser

12 Regis Philbin
13 Tyra Banks Tyra Banks Tyra Lynne Banks is an American model, television personality, talk show host, producer, author, actress, singer and business woman.

She's not actually a judge, but whatever. - MaxAurelius

She is such a great host

14 Chris Hardwick
BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Favourite Britain's Got Talent Judges Best America's Got Talent Contestants Best America's Got Talent Seasons Best America's Got Talent Season 8 Acts Top 10 America's Got Talent Season 11 Acts

List Stats

300 votes
14 listings
7 years, 293 days old

Top Remixes (4)

1. Howie Mandel
2. Mel B
3. Heidi Klum
1. David Hasselhoff
2. Howie Mandel
3. Sharon Osbourne
1. Howie Mandel
2. David Hasselhoff
3. Piers Morgan

View All 4

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.