Top 10 Animal Jam Items

These are the best and rarest ANIMAL JAM items! They are hard or impossible to get!

The Top Ten

1 Rare Headdress

I have a full set, not willing to trade them though haha...


I have a light pink headdress that is worth around 15 black longs

They're worth 2 Black Long Collars + 1 Good Long Collar

2 Rare Spiked Collar

I was just scrolling looking for animal lists and this is what I get lol

I have a black spike but I don't trade it, but I really want to get a rare headdress though. - ArcticWolf

So hard to get! I finally just got one! took sooo much trading!


3 Founder Hat

That's beppers dream item! He got it from mailtime!

I don't think there is only twenty because I have seen more then 20 people in my den at the same time that were wearing them. Also they lost value recently they are not worth two black longs and two indigo longs, now its just two black longs, or an orange beard


I love founder hats! People will kill for those things! Literally a little kid was pointing a fake gun at me saying " give me your founder hat and nobody gets hurt! ", I didn't even have one. and I knew it was fake gun by the way.

4 Party Hat

I had one and didn't think it was rare and traded it away :c

My dream item (that I will never get)

I had a Party Hat but I traded it for the Neon Blue Spike I had wanted since I started playing. Overall, it's a pretty cool item! - GameTheorist

I have the rare Monday party hat and recently I'm try I trade it away... I'm also trading a yellow short collar. The worth? I don't know help anyone?

5 Orange Beard

Ok. Don't laugh. I know it sounds silly. But the orange beard has only 1 of its kind. YOU HEARD ME RIGHT, 1! - garfieldgirl307

I have an orange beard I am jammer2981718, please trade me for it :) I'm not lying. there are plenty of orange beards, but it's so uncommon to find one, its less common than beta tiaras and founders hats! So how could it not be rare? I think that an item is rare if you like it, not its value. that's what trading SHOULD be about


I HAVE SEEN A PERSON WITH AN ORANGE BEARD. I don't really think that there is only 1 orange beard. They are super uncommon! I have only seen about 1 or 2 people with an orange beard. I seen 1 on trade. I tried to trade rares for it, and the person wouldn't accept. Is it really worth several betas and spikes?

6 Worn Blanket

I don't get how worns are hard to get their clothing betas their everywhere the black one is like four den betas I believe so

'Cause it's good for non-members to finally have rares. And it's one of the most rarest non-member rares.

I have like a million and there super easy to get ya know ill tell you if you buddy me I am code5895

Black worns are definitely the rarest, they say they are worth 10 den betas! I have one, put it on trade and requests came flowing in... even though I didn't advertise!

Worn blankets are super duper rare! They are also a beta item! I tried so hard to trade them a rare fox hat for a worn and I got one! I was so happy because I got my first beta item from somebody!

7 Rare Spike

People who have rare longs or shorts are really picky about them. There are multiple colors such as pink, yellow, orange, black, blue, green, red, and purple. The most rare is black, and the least rare is orange. People usually trade betas and rare wrists for rare spikes. The order of how rare they are is actually based on their color and if they're short or long. Most people get spikes by trading ultra good things, or playing the adventure: The Forgotten Desert. I used to have a red short, but it got scammed. People would do anything to get rare spikes, even threaten people that they would scam and hack their account. If they do, just report and leave. Most people don't even put their spikes on trade because it is too valuable.

People I know are SUPER PICKY about their spikes like I gifted one of my friends my extra pink short spike and she said " I wish it were a black one like the one your wearing. HEY CAN I HAVE YOUR SPIKE? " and I'm here like " if you know how I feel why would you say that like you out me in such an uncomfortable situation like you know I'm not happy you know that I'm trying "

Rare spikes have different colors such as, pink, yellow orange, green, blue, black and purple, many jammers want rare spikes, there is also long and short, longs are WAY rarer than shorts. They look good on arctic wolves ( My opinion ) and I have been trying to get a Black long collar and black long wristband for months! They are the rarest of spikes.

But, I think rare spike is not really that rare anymore because now members can obtain it from The Forgotten Desert adventure.

8 Neon Blue Bow


I didn't even know this item existed, but I want one. I will offer. My user is bunniesareawesome136.

I am trying to find one, it's so imposable! by the way I'm a 8 year old kid, I found out this website


I traded around so much and I finally got one; it's my literal dream item!

Although if you have a nm head feather jag me, I'm sarahjmaas

9 Scullies

I have never seen a, "scully" as they are very rare item. I had first found it on YouTube, and the video was called, "Animal Jam Beta Footage", or something like that. I would love to have them, but, unfortunately, AJHQ had hacked into the beta accounts, and they removed them. They took this action because on a panda, it looked, "inappropriate." The reason why I say, "beta accounts," is because at the time, they were only in the beta Animal Jam website, in witch have been completely
Updated. Some people, however, are still lucky enough to have them. I think all AJ accounts that had a panda, and a scully, are unfortunate. Maybe some people who still have one, got a panda and got it removed by AJHQ because of their action taken by getting a panda. Please, if you enjoyed, gift me, I just got ban, and my spike collar, a rare blue long, got scammed. My username is sandstorm339, and please, gift me unwanted. Thank you for your time reading this, hop you enjoyed :3

I have never seen anyone with a "scully," as it is called. Could someone please tell me what it looks like? And I'm sure that when they introduced this item, pandas were not available as an animal in-game, so they could not account for this "weirdness." Perhaps they are so difficult to find because AJHQ hacked everyone's inventory and removed the scully from it, so they wouldn't have to worry about people's cute pandas looking inappropriate. But that is just my theory, don't take my word for it. P:

I think sculies are the rarest item on this list, but you should add betas, for example... MAGENTA SHEEP CLOAK IS WORTH LIKE 65 BLAK LONGS!... so I think that's the rarest item on AJ

I feel they should be worth more due to ever seeing them around jamma

10 Headdress

This is one of the rarest items even more than the rare headdress this should be higher than 10.

Headdress is deffanitly most valuable

They r so cool and rare at the same time amaze

I would do anything for a headdress

The Contenders

11 Pirate Sword

I will do ANYTHING for a pirate sword! Though they look very much alike, normal swords have the members only lock on it, while the pirate sword is non member. It is a very valuable beta, should be right up there or even above rare spikes!

I personally think green is the rarest since I traded a rare fox hat and another rare (can't remember which one) for a green pirate sword and they accepted, and then I traded it for a pink one and they accepted, and I got another green one soon after (a gift from my super-rare buddy) and traded it successfully for a blue pirate sword. The pirate swords are incredibly rare and they are also from the beta days. You don't find many of them around anymore (especially the blue,red,and black ones) and only super rare jammers have one.

For all of you that want a pirate sword jam gram me your offers and I might trade you one JUST JOKING I will give anybody one I know a way to get them of forgotten desert and return of the phantoms hard mode even that one cosmo adventure

I have this is it blue and rare?

12 Fox Hat


Hey everybody! This is iloveicecreamfrozen (my account username) I have a fox hat and everyone kept saying gimme the fox hat! I kept saying it wasn't for trade! Gosh now people think fox hats are adorable. I would trade anything for all the fox hats on animal jam! Now I see a lot a people surrounding me like I'm famous! Gosh I think that some people want to become rare. In my opinion everybody is special. Non rare people rare people. Still be kind and trade fair one person kept trying because mine was once on trade they were like trading me rare bows I kept declining sorry but I like the following: red light orange and white fox hats. If you would like to trade please trade me either white or red. At the moment I have light orange if anybody is happy enough to donate a fox hat for my good and nice friend Fredric101 she's really nice and really upset she really wants one. By the way I'll trade it for a rare headress ok? Ok now I wanted to say everybody is rare! I do not care about ...more

I remember when fox hats were just an item that said "rare" and everybody went on and on with how they aren't rare. Now people are always trying to get my pink fox hat. I guess people recycled them for money since they didn't think they were rare anymore and now very few people have them. I am: miahappyheart

I fox hats are so popular! They should be higher on the list because, EVERYBODY (or close to) wants them. I have 4 right now (possibly more later) and people keep asking for mine. They are so cool, they cost 1,250 gems. And people have to trade 3 to 4 RARES to get a fox hat.

13 Rare Spike Wrist Band

I have a black long wristband. I would trade it for a short collor not orange

I honestly think that a rare spike wrist band and a rare spiked collar should be both equally rare. Am I the only one that believes this?

I totally agree with everyone who says that these should be up a bit higher

The only reason it isn't rare than a spike collar is because it is smaller and barely anyone cares about it. It's all about opinion these days.

14 Horse Coin

I mean, these were removed from the game, and are very rare, so I think they should be higher.

Never heard of it sonds cool user: 15Cakep0ps

I don't know aj crap thanks for my friend lol.#Lol

I think this is even rarer than an orange beard, or at least close to it. It should at least be higher up than this though. It's not #21!

15 Rare Worn

The purple rare worn is extremely uncommon I think it should be worth more "my opinion" but most people probably recycled them because they where in the 1st leap year party in Animal nam

The purple worn is really rare. It is worth a Bad-Decent Long collar and is the rarest worn! The blue one is not so rare, only worth 2-4 rims, but it's still pretty!

I have the rare purple worn and people keep asking me to put it on trade. But wasn't it sold last leap year? I don't know because I started half a year ago

Ooh I have one too but I traded it away for something I don't really remember

16 Eyeball Hat

If the beta one is magenta with peach eyelash and veins then I'm dead because I had one and someone traded me 3 black longs and then declined I almost flipped them off.3.

These things are actually pretty rare! Especially the beta eyeball. Trust me, they're worth more than headdresses. I know you don't believe me but they are.

Eyeball hats are really beta. When you know you hit jackpot is when you get the one with peach eyelashes. those are worth founders! I think in 2014 for Halloween they put it for sale. can't remember though

I see people with them sometimes I think a lot of things on this list are old animal jam things! And old animal jam things are so rare and awesome

17 River Race

I have only seen 5 around and there this glitch where it makes you go to the finish line fast! Someone said they give me black long if I can beat them but they keep cheating and this glitch works for all games with multiplier except best dress falling phantoms gem breaker and yea

This was deleted except for the den item version. I've only seen a couple of them ever.

I have only seen one ever.

I have only seen 2 so they should be on the list maybe not 1 but at least 5.

18 Epic Plushies

I see a lot of people with a ton of epic plushies. People might demand a rare spike, wrist, or headdress (might be an over pay) if people want it. I try to ask what for the epic plushies and people say: rare spikes! Rare wrists! Black longs! I'm never getting one.

I have two epic plushies (a giraffe and penguin) and I got them from someone who had a lot of money and bought a bunch of them. The only thing I will ever trade them for are other epic plushies.

You buy them from aj outfitters because if you get an epic plushie I will never trade it because were dealing with actual money just think of what your parents are paying for you they pay $15.95 dollars for something and you just trade it?!?! Just think of the money they're spending.

I really don't get why lots of people don't have one I have looked and looked but I can't find anybody who wants to trade them or anybody who has one

19 Cami Frog

I have one its from long ago

It's a toy and it's the shape of a frog... let me see, how is it called? Ah yes cami frog!

I have been playing from when the game came out and everyone that joined got a cami frog for free

Umm, this is on the list. 0-0

20 Light Purple Gazelle Horns

These aren't that rare, but at least they're rarer than some non member rare item other than a worn blanket.

Extremely rare ; only known pair belongs to snowy claw. They are worth about a few spikes or some founders.

A lot of people confuse these horns with the light and dark purple gazelle horns. The real purple gazelle horns released during Beta Testing is purple and brown. Rarely have I seen this item, so it must be much rarer than 19th on this list. -beachfun

This is rare at all they currently are in stores

21 Mira Statue

Sigh... people are really bad these days. I won't beg for one but some random person came to my den and said, "GIMME YOUR MIRA STATUE OR I WILL GET IT MYSELF" I didn't believe that they could actually do anything, but I went on a few days later and it wasn't there. People these days... - GameTheorist

You can win it in The Phantom Badlands.

I agree mira statues are extremely beta. I'd say they're worth... a beta phantom statue. I don't go after the golden bronze ones but I like the clear ice ones, cause they look better in my opinion

I always have wanted 1 I did not know they were worth 19#! I almost got 1 by a person giving it away. they said they would send it to me but somebody butted in and shouted NO ME SEND IT TO ME! I was so disappointed

22 Tiki Mask

I don't know honestly

Tikis, ahh, quite old items, were sold in the beta as a matter of fact! They are quite rare, and hard to achieve, they come in a wide variety of colors, from blue to tan, these old items are darn right rare! They are also hard to find and jammers won't accept as often as they would of you were trading for a fox hat, if any of you jammers have them congrats, if you don't I hope you get one soon.

Well I didn't know they were that rare before now..( but I think mine was from the friendship event ), I traded mine for a painting ( And many other things, DANG It cost me an arm and a leg! ) But I wish I had kept it now..

Tiki Masks are kinda creepy, but I still collect them cause they're beta

23 Spaceship Grey

I have a Spaceship Grey.

Nothing is really rare anymore even a long black spike if your a member and has an eagle you can become really rare in weeks I got my space ship gray from the eagle adventure :T and a green spike neon bow and more

This is actually pretty beta still, but a lot of other things are better than it.

I seen 1 of those in my life O. O

24 Brown Beard

Look there are to many beards but I heard all this from other people - garfieldgirl307

Its more more beta then the rare 1 its true

I only have a cream but yea there is

Wait there is a brown beard?

25 Bow and Arrow

I also have a rare raspberry bow and arrow. Accepting the WORST rare long spiked collar for it!

Wut? arn't they in stores? - nowwearepandafromaj

Which bows? I have quite a few rare ones. I used to have neon, but I traded it!

I have a rare raspberry bow and arrow which are the rarest of the bow and arrows, believe me. It took me a month to get one. I also have two non rare bows.

26 Rare Giant Lion Plushie

I have one!

It's the rare one that isn't in the diamond shop, because it doesn't have the diamond sign, but it DOES have the rare sign!

They are in the diamond shop... I think

My friend has one and I have one

27 Black Long

This is a good item but it should be rarer than bow and arrows

Worth 3-4 den betas!

Wow these are super rare nobody will accept anything these days in 2015

I'm never getting one. They say "headdress! 20 den betas! " as their offer!

28 Dragon Glove

These aren't that rare... I just have to say.

No need to be in the top 100 anymore! In the diamond shop and there are MILLIONS of people with them these days... did you write this in 1012? Because now in 2015 there and billions to people with dragon gloves. they have no need to be in top 100 rare items anymore there in diamond shop. sorry! :( I'm bffsrule0

Yeah, most of my buddies have rare dragon gloves and I have like five

Rarity has gone DOWN now that it is in diamond shops

29 White Tail Armor

White tails, nice, they are a pleasant item to own, go great with almost every look you can think of, I enjoy these items, they were a monthly member gift back in the beta, very very rare, congrats to anyone who owns one of these magnificent items and if you don't I how you get one soon. Take care, and jam on jammers!

These were given as member gifts (can't remember when though) and came in different colors then the diamond shop came out and now you can ask for rares. no more rare :(

It's actually the rarest tail armour. And its also Beta. So it's no reason to be upset about it.

It's not just white it's all purple, all pink, tan, silver and gold, or the red and white one. But the white is the rarest it's worth a purple, red, or blue long

Its worth more

30 Black Beard (Silver Tip)

A regular beard may seem lame but the truth is beards that aren't labeled "rare" are actually rarer than the ones labeled "rares" haha beards are actually worth say a rare claw

You may notice beards are very rare. This is 1 of the rarest. - garfieldgirl307

I have one, and I personally think it looks very cool on a eagle.

All beards are rare I personally think this one looks the best my use: radioable please buddy me and maybe trade me a rare? That would be awesome.

31 All Spirit Armor

Not rare at all anymore. In stores now.

Spirit armor is out in the diamond shop today, yet a very cool item. Jam on jammers and take care!

Not rare they came out in the diamond shop or day!

I have all spirit armor now it's in diamond shop :'(

32 Cream Beard (Grey Tip)

Ok there's way to many beards but a friend of mine said this is super hard to get - garfieldgirl307

I have 1 they say that there's 4 in animal jam but I don't know

I don't have this but I'm willing to...

Ok same for all the other beards NOT SO RARE I'm mimii8 :3

33 Shark Fin

I had a black one but I traded it for a spike collar rare one got accepted then spike got scammed

Oh yeah I have 2 black shark fins and a lot of non members trade for them.

I had one and I got I in a gift and I recycled it

I have the rare one.

34 Princess Bed

The Princess Bed is an bed and only 1 Jammer owns this item her user shall not be shared. This item has not been released ever and is pink with brown wooden borders. The Princess Bed is also very rare and people will ask about 15 Black long spikes or 20 Non rare Headdress.

Good post? - Maelinthewolf

No one owns this it is unreleased and taken out of the coding system for nasty reasons

This should be like number one, whats it doing at number 74?

I think his name is X.

35 Pink Gazelles

Just came out in stores now you can bye so they are not rare!

I had one before they were in stores. NOW I'm SO MAD :(

I have them I'm so happy

One: able to buy. Two: very nonrare

36 Rare Claw

I've actually got one from a...I think a Claw machine. I can't remember. Both me and my sibling have one, and I'm positive that we've obtained it though Claw machines, since if you be persistent enough when using the Claw (not the stuffed animal claws), you might get lucky.

It is priceless. Claws that are rare are as rare as a really beta item. Every time I tried to trade 4 max rares that were ultra rare and a person said no. I finally got a rare claw and I'm so happy.

This is a VERY rare item. It should be at the top of the list. At least by number 3. It was a Monthly Member Gift, and it is obtainable on The Forgotten Desert

I have a rare claw and I love it! I would love to trade it! My user: noodle2014

37 Magenta Furry

I just love Bepper so much!

The 'real' furry is worth 250 to 300 black long guys! Why is this the 47th while the about 8 black long worth rare hd is first? The 'fake' one, which are given out by ajhq are probs worth about 7 black longs... but STILL - Phantomcat

I have seen so many people with these... I'm not sure if their being duplicated. One time in coral canyons I saw 6 people wearing them

I had one then traded it for 9 headresses. Was that fair?

38 Black Beard (Red Tip)


They r super beta I have never seen 1 I only saw 1 on Julian2s animal

I have one of these :D I would like to trade it to somebody. So jam a gram me your deal

I have one of these :D I would like to trade it to somebody. So jag me your deal

39 Beard

Beard are not really rare

I like red beards

I have one and I am told it is the most rare thing in aj

I have a light brown and orange ~code5895

40 Glitched Ring

I have one and they're really rare but they've gone down recently

It's not glitches because if it is glitches it would be silver and it would have had whatever color decorations and I have 3 megenta furrys but I sold one for 5 blackout long spikes and a rare headdress so that's pretty cool I think

Ugh people should know how rare it is... no one ever does giveaways on them.

Theese are supper rare

41 Top Hat

Is that the same as a rare friend ship hat? - nowwearepandafromaj

I'm pretty sure there beta but I may be wrong. I just got one from the Eagle adventure, making it less rare because more people are getting them each day. But still I think there beta.

They are beats I guess I have a pink one and people trade me the brown and pink one for my pink all I know that these would be like another top hat or two

I couldn't believe how happy I was. Now I have 2 top hats... My first would be the pink one. My second was the multi-colored blue top hat!

I have a black and white top hat plus there like worth a rare short collar combiNed with a rhino helmet

42 Gecko Plushie

I have rarely seen anyone with it. I traded my best for it.

I had it. I traded it for black top hat

These are just small betas they are not worth anything big

I have this and it should be higher then 43 more think 5 or 6

43 Mech Angel Wings

I have that too

I used to have all the mech angle wings but soon, a member came along and said she would trade me all the coloured rare spike for it. I said no because imma non member and can't wear spikes and she got really angry and hacked me so all my wings were gone! I cried for at least a hour! but my very nice member bff in reallife gave me her rare mech angle wings and I'm really happy. I traded it for a rare bunny hat in 2014. check me out guys! my user is fuzem and I don't look rare but I am

I have all the collections but then traded them out for other rares because I stopped liking them

I have 2 rare ones and 4 non rare ones but nobody would want to trade their's.

I got all the colors the last one I got was black and I was so happy when got it

44 NM Glove

I got a Rare Glove in the first adventure. wolf302 I will go with anyone just jam-a-gram me.

Lol. this nm really wanted my glove and she traded me a rare nerd for it I'm like

I have the magenta and green glove there beta by the way I'm rebecca1240

You can buy non member gloves in the diamond shop...

45 Red Long Spike

I had that but I traded down to get blue!

Its rare!

46 Rare Raspberry Bow

Those are rare? What? I have 2!

The most rare bow out of of the bows not many people have them

Easily the rarest of the rare bow and arrows. You can't get them in adventures so they are worth awesome beta and rare spike wrists.

The rarest color rare bow and arrow. They are VERY uncommon and difficult to find.

47 Beta Arctic Hood

I think since famous jammers say so, and my self, that this is 1 of the rarest

My friend says this is worth a light pink headdress! How is this 55?

I got traded 5 black longs, and a founders for my beta Arctic hood!

I got a trade of a beta hood for my founder rebecca1240

48 Non Rare Headdress

I think Non Rare Headdress is the rarest because there is like maybe I do not know like 50 of each or so.
I am wolf302 anyone know what looks good with a red worn please tell me, I got one and I would like to know I got it in the first adventure on hard mode I would like to get a black one and if someone would like to trade me send me a jam-a-gram please

In my opinion the regular orange one looks better than the purple rare one. These things were selling like hotcakes in 2013 they were in Jam Mart Clothing.

They are extremely rare the rare one was once sold on a Rare Monday back probably in 2012 I was there

It's way rarer then 25

49 Light Pink Headdress

Um I'm srry but animal jam worth wiki a light headdress is worth 14 black longs and the most expensive item in animal jam is the magenta long spike collar which according to the wiki it "priceless" hope this helps

Yes I longed for this item the day I saw it! But believe me 10 years from now Ill be like, Hey, I finaly got a light pink headdress now that I'm 19! If u wanna buddy me My user is ullifire.

This is SO rare! It should really be in the top ten!

Light pink headdresses are really rare. They are worth 4 black longs and add!
Light pink headdresses are many jammers dream items including mine.
Good luck getting one but it will be really hard...

50 Creature Mask

I think I have one of these! - nowwearepandafromaj

I had a pink one and I traded it for a beta clover fountain. Is that worth it? Reply

These probably went down because they were in stores for Halloween.

You totally over traded for the clover fountain beta creature masks are worth a lot!

8Load More
PSearch List