Top Ten Awards That Should Be Given If There Were Thrash Metal Awards

gemcloben

The Top Ten

1 Best Solo - Tornado of Souls (Megadeth)

I'd give that one to fade to black. Although that one's heavy metal, not thrash metal, so never mind, I agree with this. - Songsta41

Nominees:
Tornado of souls (Megadeth)
Elimination (overkill)
One (Metallica) - gemcloben

2 Best Musician - Dave Mustaine (Megadeth)

Maybe Megadeth isn't as great as Metallica, but Dave is definitely the best overall musician. He was one of the founding members of thrash metal and he's very musically innovative. He writes a majority of Megadeth's songs as well, and in those songs he sings great, while at the same time playing sick guitar riffs and sometimes solos. There's no denying that Dave is the best thrash musician. - Songsta41

I would nominate the same 3 people but I would give it to Hetfield - he was more influential towards thrash popularization in the 80s, he was the epitome of thrash. He's also a better leader of his band than Mustaine. And a better singer.
Mustaine is a better guitarist but the award "Best Musician" is more than that. - Metal_Treasure

Good leadership doesn't mean control. How many band members left Metallica and how many band members left Megadeth? - Metal_Treasure

Nominees:
Mustaine (Megadeth)
Hetfield (Metallica)
Waters (Annihilator) - gemcloben

I love the idea of this list - thrash Grammys? Sure, it's cool. Great job, gemcloben! - Metal_Treasure

3 Best Song - Head Crusher (Megadeth)

Well, that's not the one I expected to be here. I didn't expect it to be anywhere, to be honest. I find this one a bit too heavy. Here are my nominees:
Welcome Home (Sanitarium) - Metallica
Tornado of Souls - Megadeth
Badlands - Metal Church
And so many more... - Songsta41

I love so many thrash songs that I would probably nominate more than 30.
1. The Four Horsemen - Metallica (or some other Metallica song).
2. Black Prophecies - Dark Angel
3. Raining Blood - Slayer - Metal_Treasure

Nominees:
Head crusher (Megadeth)
Motorbreath (Metallica)
Elimination (overkill) - gemcloben

4 Best Bassist - Cliff Burton (Metallica)

Nominees:
Burton (Metallica)
Araya (slayer)
Trujillo (Metallica) (I think he is overshadowed by Burton too much, but a really unique player) - gemcloben

5 Best Drummer - Dave Lombardo (Slayer)

My nominees:
1. Dave Lombardo (Slayer)
2. Gene Hoglan (Dark Angel, Testament - 2 albums)
3. Mike Mangini (Annihilator) - I'd say he's the best drummer but nobody thinks of him as thrash, especially now when he is associated with Dream Theater and prog drumming.
That's why I give it to Lombardo but Gene Hoglan is a pretty strong contender for the #1 spot, too. - Metal_Treasure

Nominees:
Lombardo (slayer)
Menza (Megadeth)
Adler (he can be classed as thrash for his work with Megadeth, but he really make it here with lamb of god) - gemcloben

6 Best Riff - Elimination (Overkill)

I think that the Elimination riff (1989) sounds pretty much like Master of Puppets (1986). - Metal_Treasure

I just didn't like the vocals overall a good song

Tornado of Souls! Wow, I'm giving a lot of these awards to that song - Songsta41

Nominees:
Elimination (overkill)
Master of puppets (Metallica)
Holy wars (Megadeth) - gemcloben

7 Best Riff - Holy Wars (Megadeth)

Megadeth isn't my first thrash choice but this is the riff that impressed me at most. - Metal_Treasure

8 Best Musician - James Hetfield (Metallica)
9 Best Singer - Chuck Billy (Testament)

Nominees:
Billy (testament)
Calevera (sepultura)
Hetfield (Metallica) - gemcloben

10 Best Album - Kill 'em All (Metallica)

Ride the Lightning! Kill em All is amazing, but not as special, fantastic, and well done as Ride the Lightning. James improved his growl and they found the perfect thrash metal sound, while at the same time, writing 8 songs which I would all call "insanely good". - Songsta41

Alice In Hell - Annihilator. It brought more technical and sophisticated elements to the table, and also influenced Rust In Peace. - Metal_Treasure

Rust in Peace man! I don't think Countdown to Extinction is purely thrash. It's kind of their black album. - IronSabbathPriest

Nominees:
Kill 'em all (Metallica)
Countdown to extinction (Megadeth)
Souls of black (testament) - gemcloben

The Contenders

11 Best Ballad - Nothing Else Matters (Metallica)

Fade to Black by far. I'd still take the unforgiven first, but then I'll take Nothing Else matters as third (just talking about Metallica), but A Tout Le Monde is also one of the greatest. - Songsta41

12 Best Thrash Instrumental - Arc Lite (Coroner)

The Call of Ktulu - Metallica - Songsta41

Nominees:
Arc Lite (Coroner)
Orion (Metallica)
Musical Death (Testament) - Metal_Treasure

13 Best Ballad - Return to Serenity (Testament)

Nominees:
Return to serenity (testament)
A tout le monde (Megadeth)
Nothing else matters (Metallica) - gemcloben

14 Best Vocal Performance - Absence of Light (Testament)

Nominees:
Absence of light (testament)
Elimination (overkill)
Madhouse (anthrax) - gemcloben

15 Best Thrash Cover Of Non-metal Song - Saturday Night's Alright For Fighting (Flotsam and Jetsam)

Nominees:
1. Saturday Night's Allright For Fighting - Flotsam and Jetsam (Elton John cover)
2. Whiskey In The Jar - Metallica (Thin Lizzy cover)
3. I Want You (She's So Heavy) - Coroner (The Beatles cover).
This is the best Beatles cover - confirmed by the Beatles fans I know (I sent them the link because nobody knew this cover existed). - Metal_Treasure

Am I Evil? - Diamond Head (this one's New Wave of British Heavy Metal) - Songsta41

16 Best Album - Pleasure to Kill (Kreator)
17 Most Overrated Band - Megadeth

Fanboys just ventured beyond Metallica, they think Dave Mustaine is some kind of God.
He's the Donald Trump of Metal.

BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Top Ten Users Who Should Be Given a Lifetime TheTopTens Award for Their Amazing Work and Personality Reasons Why Awards Should be Given to Those who Contribute the Most to this Site Top Ten Reasons Why There Shouldn't Be a "Big 4" In Thrash Metal Top Ten Awards There Should Be If There Was A The Top Tens Award Ceremony Should There Be a TheTopTens Award Ceremony?

List Stats

17 listings
3 years, 10 days old

Top Remixes

1. Best Riff - Holy Wars (Megadeth)
2. Best Musician - James Hetfield (Metallica)
3. Best Ballad - Nothing Else Matters (Metallica)
Metal_Treasure
1. Best Musician - Dave Mustaine (Megadeth)
2. Best Song - Head Crusher (Megadeth)
3. Best Solo - Tornado of Souls (Megadeth)
gemcloben

WRemix

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.
P