Top Ten Bands to Make Up the Big Four of Progressive MetalI did this for NWOBHM (New Wave Of British Heavy Metal) on my last account, which was one of the few good things to come out of my last account. Now it’s time to pay tribute to my favorite metal subgenre, not counting heavy metal because that’s the root of all metal.
I put some of the others above QR (Queensrÿche) because they’re more proggy, QR is basically a heavy metal band with a lot of prog characteristics.
The Top Ten
The current top 4 is great, each of the bands bring something different to the table, yet they all fall under the term progressive metal. DT is the closest to pure prog metal out of the 4 in my opinion, SX successfully mixes power and neoclassical, Opeth focus much more on tone rather than technicality (though they still have that too) and are death metal, and Queensryche sounds extremely close to classic metal with progressive elements mixed in. - kempokid
Currently tied with four other bands for my favorite artist of all time. They’ve had an immense impact on the prog metal genre, but weren’t the first, because Queensrÿche formed in 82’ while DT came in 85’. Still superior in my opinion, since QR really just doesn’t have the consistency of Dream Theater. Everything after they fired Geoff has been good, but he was the heart and soul of the band. Everything after Portnoy has been good as well, even The Astonishing, which was just a bit overblown. I don’t think it’s too long, but there’s too many interludes and songs in general. If they’d removed all of the interludes and crunched the songs down into smaller but longer songs, it would’ve been a better album. As for QR, La Torre is good, but Geoff is better for sure.
Progressive death metal. Most people would place Blackwater Park as their favorite Opeth album, but my favorite is Pale Communion because it’s lost the growls (not that I have a problem with Mikael’s growls, I just prefer his clean voice) it’s more of a pure prog album then a prog death album. I really have been enjoying the direction they’ve been going in the past decade, where they’re becoming more of a prog rock band rather than a brutal death prog band.
Basically Dream Theater’s little brother, I don’t love SX as much as I love DT, but it’s pretty close. I think their peak masterpieces are The Divine Wings Of Tragedy, which is basically their A Change Of Seasons (not quite as masterful, but still phenomenal) and The Odyssey (their Octavarium, but I honestly prefer The Odyssey). Iconoclast, their second latest studio effort, is also pretty great, even though my favorite album of theirs is Paradise Lost.
The earliest prog metal band I know of, they formed in 82’. To be honest, they’re one of my all time favorites, even if they’re not the most consistently good band on the planet. I’m a little biased here because they were the first band on the list I really got into, but they’re not my favorite.
They’re a near perfect balance between progressive metal and alternative metal. Not too proggy that it overshadows their alternative side, but their alternative side does tend to overshadow their progressive side a little. Still an amazing band overall, and they deserve a spot here for sure.
I almost forgot about the fathers of djent. They’re a brutal prog metal band who don’t need downtuned riffs to be heavy, but it helps. They’re one of my new favorites, and I’ve just recently gotten into them. My favorite song of theirs is probably Dancers To A Discordant System, which is nine minutes of heavy prog goodness.
I haven’t really gotten into them a ton yet, but they seem pretty amazing. The first song I heard of theirs was The Ivory Gate Of Dreams, which I atill absolutely love and it is still my favorite from them, but they’re super proggy with a lot of fantasy elements as well. Borderline progressive power metal, it seems. But they deserve a spot on this list because of the influence they’ve had and for the quality of what I’ve heard.
I’m a latecomer to them, but I do love Colors. They’re a proggy yet chaotic band with a lot of great material. I don’t love them as much as some of the others on this list but they’re still an absolutely amazing band. Thanks to kempokid and cjWriter1997 for getting me into them.
They were a progressive death metal band in their later albums, but they still deserve to be on here for that. They’re a very good band, I prefer some of the others on here, but I’m being objective as well, which is why they’re so much lower than I’d like to put them on here. I’ll likely move them up my remix later on. Rest in peace, Chuck.
Funny, because their guitarist is John Petrucci’s nephew.
I think they shouldn't be on this list because they aren't only the least proggy band on this list (as MindCrime noticed). They are also the least metal band and they never sounded like metal to me. By the way, they aren't on the Metal Archives. - Metal_Treasure
Their general sound is nothing like progressive metal, alternative or experimental rock fits them much better - kempokid
Should be second behind Dream Theater, why the hell are they at the bottom
Not a big fan of Tool, which is partly why they’re at the bottom. The other reason is because they’re the least proggy band on this list. I hear much more alternative metal/rock in their music than progressive metal/rock. They’re still proggy in a few cases (i.e Third Eye), but I don’t hear that much, plus they just really bore me. Not because of the song lengths, but because a lot of it is either repetitive, or just uninteresting, which is the case more often. Plus I hate all of the pointless interludes and noise/static. I like them, but they’re flawed.
I managed to type up an entire thing about what I dislike about Tool without mentioning Maynard. But that sorta just went out the window.
Related ListsBands to Make the Big Four of Thrash Metal the Big Five Top Ten Bands that Should Make the Big Four of New Wave of British Heavy Metal Best Bands to Make the Big Four of German Power Metal Best Bands to Make the Big Four of Grunge the Big Five Bands to Make the Big Four of Metalcore
191 days old
2. Ne Obliviscaris
2. Symphony X