Top 10 Battle for Dream Island (BFDI) Characters

The Top Ten
1 Leafy

Leafy is so kind! Screw Firey for not letting her on Dream Island, JUST BECAUSE when she rode his Ferris Wheel, she said, "Get me out of this thing!" WHY?! It's either he should have talked to her about it earlier, or he should have let it go! (I still kinda like Firey). Another reason why I didn't vote on him is because what he did to Ice Cube because she's his opposite was wrong. Incorrect. Inaccurate. Flawed. And because she bought Dream Island (thanks to Firey), oh ho ho ho, everyone hates her. I'm sure she was derailed.

She only took because he upset for all that she's done for fiery he refused to let her in because one ride which leafy disliked. She just left out and I really disappointed when some people saw that episode they made her onto the bottom of the list despite what others have done to each other. Sure it may be but, it was out of sadness. I don't believe that Leafy initially was planning to steal dream island. I believe had she did plan to steal the island she would've done it earlier, hacked the speaker box's results or done something a bit more dramatic. But that scene just looked like she blew bad fuse. I mean I may done the same thing and not just me lots of people would. I just don't get how little crime could make someone the worst character but

leafster! shes great, even if shes made some mistakes in her past. I really relate to how she struggles with the need to be liked, god she deserves the world.

I just love Leafy so much. She has such a two-faced personality, giving you gifts one second, and ending your friendship the next. She’s so interesting! I feel bad for her. Rage clouded her vision when she stole Dream Island from Firey, and everyone completely hates her for it. I think Leafy has the most character development out of the original characters form BFDI. Go LEAFY!

2 Tennis Ball

Tennis Ball is smart. PERIOD. I feel so bad for him. His friendship with Golf Ball, (I ship them,) is amazing. And whoever thought of the, "I can't climb the ladder thing," deserves to be eliminated.

He's actually pretty funny when he's like "ahhh" cause it actually just sounds funny, his personality is being clumsy, funny, happy and more which is why I like him

He is pretty much me. I like the way he can be a jerk and funny at the same time and balance it perfectly. Definitely my favorite.

I like tennis ball to, but I would not put him in first place.

3 Pen

Pen is one of my favorite characters, he is cool, and has good moments like everyone else.

I love how he can raise ten kids with his wife after being in the army for twenty+ years

Pen tries in the game and deserves to be out of the TLC

He is better then literally anything on earth

4 Firey

People hate him just because he won dream island. Just because he won first season it doesn't mean that he is going to win BFB and people are rushing to vote him off. You say he turned bland, why not give him a chance to become a good character again. And I'm talking to you Fireafy shippers, you want Firey and Leafy to interact again, right? Then why do you want Firey eliminated early? At least give him a chance to have character development again. But don't worry, there's not a big chance that he is going to win this time. There are many more characters than they were in BFDI so what makes you think that he is going to win again?

Fiery is the best because he won BFDI and has not been eliminated yet but he might because his team lost in episode 6. Fiery is deadly but is still joyful and fun

I liked him but he sucked in episode 25 and he was the reason why the 3 other seasons happened (and nobody blamed him! )

I have wanted Firey to win throughout all the episodes he is the best character on Bfdi

5 Teardrop

Teardrop is so cute! She is even a parody of B from Total Drama! 4, you should not thank Gelatin, you should thank her! Teardrop! TD herself! She really is smart, creative, and quiet like B. I kinda thought she wouldn't have B's smart personality, but she proved me wrong. Thanks Teardrop! Woody is kinda lucky. She was funny kicking him when he liked her. And her elimination was unfair! Why Pencil! (I still like Pencil, lol.)

I definitely respect someone who walks the walk more than they talk the talk. even if she people misunderstand what shes trying to say (god damnit pillow) shes rlly smart!

I have loved teardrop since I was 5. She is so cute and friendly, full of mysteries and is overall a friend who you can trust.

Who care if she can't talk? Whoever voted woody or teardrop needs to be (something extremely tragic)!

6 Woody

I feel bad for Woody on how ya know...but at least he got development in BFB, especially calming Flower down. Good job! It was also funny on how he was simping on TD, and she kicked him. Both of his eliminations were unfair, and why couldn't he be in Bfdia? Why?

ik he's an you either love him or hate him character, but I'm on the love side of the spectrum! he was pretty wimpy, but him and blocky becoming friends was really sweet! 10/10

I like Woody, he was once scared but I like the AhHHhh when he gonna get eliminated and the relief. I still like him, he turned brave

Why is he even on this list? He's annoying, his voice is annoying, and he screams all the time at the most stupid things.

7 Rocky

For she is so awesome but I kind of think he kind of looks bad when he vomits like this blah I wanted does that he likes you like I don't know what to say how to say this but he acts dumb when he vomits what you saw how he vomit on pencil

Rocky is just awesome. His agreeing noise is awesome, his barf is awesome, his smile is awesome, everything about him is just awesome. I'm surprised that he almost always comes second to puffball in the prize competition!

Aw! He's cute! I love his barf! He has Great Friends (TB and Balloony). This Little One (Get it? Balloony calls him Little One) is the first random character. He should have won Dream Island! "

Rocky is adorable! He is the cutest character with his vomit! Even in season two, he was cute! BULLEH! *barfs on me.* Fan Favorite!

8 Bubble

Hoir oiccent is so funny! I feel so bad for her because of Blocky when he rejoined the game...this is the 2nd reason why I hate Blocky! So mean to Bubble for no reason! What did she do to you? Explain the physics of what she did to you! Screw you Blocky! I also felt bad for her when Pencil and Match demoted her, and were stern to her. At least she stood up to that. I understand how it feels when people do that to me. It's really painful. Trust me, you do NOT want to go through that. Another example of abuse.

Bubble is very underrated. She(or he I'm not sure) is often left in the shadows with not much intresting screen time, but I like her(Or him) for her (Or his) personality.

Bubble has to go down as my favourite character. TB second. Bubble has by far the best voice and is full of YOYLECAKE! he also came 3rd in BFDI!

Bubble is in the top 3 of my tier list.

9 Yellow Face

Personally I don't like him, I think he's annoying. Pencil's alliance, Rocky, Puffball, Leafy, and Snowball are better characters in my opinion

Every one loves Yellow face. He's an awesome character.

Yellow face is the best because it has no arms and legs.

He is amazing and awesome in any season in BFDI!

10 Spongy

Every time someone says fat and smelly to spongy it makes me feel bad for him but I did like leafy giving spongy a complement THANK YOU LEAFY!

I feel bad for him for sacrifices, people call him fat and smelly, Spongy doesn't deserve to be eliminated :( But at least he made it in finale 5. He sooo squishy and I like squishy things :3, what he says about himself is true

I feel bad for Spongy about everything. They call him fat and smelly, and they tell him to sacrifice himself WHEN HE DOESN'T WANT TO :( He so squishy and I like squishy things. AND WE NEED MORE FAT CHARACTERS

Spongy can be the oddball. He is helpful in most cases too. I didn't see him winning but he still is strong, heavy weight, and fast, he's just not energetic enough, but I still like him.

The Contenders
11 Ice Cube

Ice Cube's revenge is awesome, and she is funny. I love her friendships! Although she isn't my favorite character, people are lucky if she's their favorite character. I don't know why some people hate her! WHY! Explain! Her elimination was so unfair. Geez, can't you get an AC or something? Or vote Spongy off? Thank goodness someone did. (Pin)

Even though she says revenge a lot, she is still a very cute character

Eh. I don't really like Ice Cube. She is mean with the revenge thing.

For some reason, a picture of a person named Ice Cube is here.

12 Golf Ball

I am appalled by the people that hate Golf Ball. She is funny, and WOW, she was amazing with spinning the 7 balls on her legs. Screw you, Snowball, I care! Brighten up a little! Although, their conflict was funny, especially when she called his brain small. Thank goodness somebody likes her, (cough cough, TB, cough cough.(I ship them.)) Her elimination was unfair. It should have been reversed!

God I love her so much. Even if shes a bit of a jerk sometimes shes really smart and a pretty good team leader, and just her and tennis balls friendship is really nice! plus shes just adorable

Golf Ball is hilarious! Bossy, sure, but she's really funny, especially in BFDIA.

She is a huge character in BFDIA plus she manages team no name

13 Pencil

Although Pencil is my favorite character, I can see why people hate her. She still is, but she should stop abusing Bubble. Anyways, Pencil had so much potential in BFDI. Obviously for one, where she told Snowball that he shouldn't be going around, killing people with his finger. To bad she got eliminated 16th, though. Shoulda been Spongy. Her friendship with Match was amazing, and her alliance power with Bubble and Ice Cube was fun.
This is the Pencil we need. First I didn't get why Pencil was eliminated 1st in BFB, but now I do. I still wish it were Fanny though. I don't blame her for what happened to Match and Bubble's interactions, I blame the writers. Since when does she do these stuff:
1. Become a hypocrite by using a contestant to hurt people, especially when they clearly DON'T want to do it.
2. Become bossy, stern, and mean to her alliance members (especially Bubble) instead of helping them in need.
3. Demote her alliance members! Whoever thought of that deserves a ...more

How is Pencil so low on this list? She's the best character in BFDI history. She killed it in so many challenges and she's 0% Mary Sue. She's not really all that mean either, though - she can be pushy, but a good character has flaws, and Pencil's really flesh out her character. Meanwhile somehow Spongy is on the list? I don't care if people "feel bad" for him, the fact stands that he's barely done anything worth mentioning in any of his time on the show. He's just a filler character... Anyway, Pencil deserves more respect on this list.

Can't believe she isn't in top ten but spongy and rocky are

Blink your eyes, yeah yeah yeah. close them both, yeah yeah! so I can win the contest, so I can win the contest!

14 Snowball

This guy is extremely underrated. Sure he's a jerk, but he just acts so stupid and goofy, he's bound to screw things up in the stupidest ways possible, that's what makes him funny.

And who can forget the most legendary line ever said in BFDI...


He was just putting the game into his head too much but, he nice outside of the game. I mean he helped rocky before the game started. I guess the game just got him

He's a jerk, but most of the time when he's being one, he just makes himself looks like an idiot, which I find absolutely hilarious.

Honestly, I'd rather choose Flower

15 Blocky

"Recovery centers, my inspiration! They're all gone." don't worry, Woody helped you

Blocky is kinda funny. The kicking Overrated Dude in BFB 17 was funny.

Don't call me stabable!

he's very funny XD

16 Coiny

During bfdi he was bland not gonna lie being only a firey slapper, but when bfdia came along firey became blander and blander giving coiny a chance to grow a big personality, we see most of that in bfb 7 (or 6) when he's talking to pin

I really like Coiny. He is NOT a "mary sue" and I... Just really like him

Why is Pen at the top? He doesn't have the charm and humor Coiny possessed in BFDIA.

Coiny is my fave character since I first watched bfdi

17 Fries

Fries you are cool

Yes my boy fries

The best one of my favourites

18 Needle

She did become bland in BFB, but she by far my favorite BFDI and BFDIA contestant.

19 Eraser

Needle is a pointless slapper, teardrop has no character, and well we know that David and Rocky are home characters. However,eraser is next level. Maybe he was supposed to be a kid of pen and snowball, but that didn't really work out, NOW DID IT! All he does is copy whatever his clique does and is SUCH a follower, making him THE worst character imao.

Hands down the best contestant on the show!

My favorite character in the show

Had a big improvement in BFB

20 Loser

Loser is so great. I feel bad for what happened to him in BFB 7, screw you Fanny! If she shut up, none of that would have happened. You guys should have voted Clock instead! Just because Loser said something that nobody believed, ohhhhh, now is the time to hate him! Why?

Honestly just voting a contestant because that contestant is good at contests doesn't mean you should and I don't get why Pen isn't voted out either I mean he's good at contests :/ its kind of undair or is it his name..

Super nice (or is he) we know in bfb 7 he lied, maybe he does it for attention... we'll never know

Being a pal of Winner! (as mentioned by Clock in TPOT 1)

21 Match

Sure, Match was derailed in BFB, but she did redeem herself in BFB 11. To bad she was eliminated in the next episode. :( Again, Match doesn't deserve the hate, guys. Anyways, like Pencil, Match had potential in BFDI. She had lots of funny moments. Like, her conflict with Pin, and when she slapped the Announcer for calling Pencil "Pence Pence." And her likes are, like, amazing. See? So much, like, potential. And, yet, some people think Pencil is less mean and can redeem herself more often, unlike Match, it's not true. It's not true, guys. She's still my 2nd favorite, though. The only reason why I still like Pencil more is because she was the most derailed. And Match apologized to Bubble, but, sadly, Bubble didn't forgive her. I love her and Pencil's friendship and I think that they do have the opportunity to be in a new season, if the writers don't screw them up. So, yeah, like Pencil, Match is just misunderstood, guys, which is why I think we should stop hating her. Thanks for, like, ...more

She’s pretty much the same as Pencil, but at least Pencil is determined. Match just does nothing and whine about the other contestants.

Match is like so totally like coolio

Many people hate her but in BFB she got an improvement

22 Pin

She is a great contestant, so why was she eliminated so early

Pin is sometimes mean but funny at the same time

Have you seen where my blueberry seeds are?

Bossy and funny sometimes

23 Puffball

She is so cute! And her voice is funny to hear! She is such a unique character by her abilities.

Puffballs voice is soo cool and they are very useful and fLuFfY

She is really cute and her voice is cool

Puffball is the best contestant!

24 Tree

He can be mature and sometime not, he's a balance character and I love it. Love his accent too.

His voice is just so good

25 Nonexisty

Everyone's favorite non-contestant

Nonexisty is nothing.

I love him beucase he is like me

he's really Cary's favorate XD

8Load More
PSearch List