Best American Girl Dolls

The Top Ten
1 Samantha

The best-selling doll on American Girl.
She has the most collections and books out of all.
Her appearance is unique and full of contrast.
It's easy not to forget her.
She's one of the original three (including Molly and Kirsten) and the first one to retire and come back.
She lives on.

Love her story! She (unlike Molly) can be friends with Nellie despite their differences

Samantha is awesome. I have her mini doll, but I lost it.

2 Rebecca

I wish I had the mini version of her. I used to watch videos of people unboxing mini AG dolls, and Rebecca was the prettiest doll in my opinion. I had the mini dolls for Kirsten and Samantha, but they went missing.

Poor Rebecca was always outshined sibilings. I know how that feels. Come on fellow Rebbecans, together will shall triumph!

Rebecca Rubin has a nice ring to it.

3 Mia

BEST DOLL EVER! Love the unique features unlike any old AG doll, She is the only figure skater, and the only one to play hockey. She is by far the best AG has ever made.

4 Julie

Love Julie! And when I was 10 I looked exactly like her long blond hair and all! I always loved her the most! American girl dolls is so cool!

I love Julie and Kit the most they are lovely dolls and even Molly she's a cute dolly dork.
Love, Fire wolf ultima.

One of the three American Girl dolls to have a video game. The other 2 are Kit Kittredge and Mia St. Claire.

5 Addy

I checked out a library book a few years ago and brought it to Creekside Intermediate School but Roosevelt pulled a page from my library book. Mary Margaret Campbell was upset. She took my library book and threw it in her Black Hole Box. I was so pissed off at my teacher. From now on, I chose to get rid of those filthy, disgusting Phonics Practice Readers (which Mary Margaret Campbell owned) and allow her students to read Beginner Books as a good alternative.

My daughter and her have the same birth day!

6 Kirsten
7 Kit

Awesome doll, glad AG made a movie. She really shows how girls lived back then in 1933

I got her when I was 9, she is one of my favorites.

8 Caroline

@visitor Caroline IS in the top ten. She's awesome. She is a tomboyish girl living in 1812 and not afraid to take chances and risks. Her father and brother were kidnapped by the British. She wants to be captain of her own ship.

9 Molly

One of the original three (along with Samantha and Kirsten) and the first doll my sister got for Christmas from American Girl.
So she holds a special place in memories.
I have a paper doll of her and it's the oldest piece of paper in my house so far, at nearly 13 years old.

I love her hair! I use her without her glasses but she is very pretty. I like putting her hair in a bun.

10 Isabelle

She's a great dancer, which's a great idea in the American Girl franchise.
Even her movie was fun.

The Contenders
11 Lea Clark

She may have a spoiled personality, but the doll was still fun.

12 Grace Thomas

She was an underrated doll.
Too bad she retired.
Now we know her as Olivia Rodrigo when it comes to the actress in the movie adaptation and she's active as a singer.

Played in her movie by Olivia Rodrigo. Too bad the doll had to be retired.

13 Nanea Mitchell
14 Tenney Grant
15 Felicity

She was among the best dolls of all time.
Such a shame she's still retired.

16 Maryellen Larkin

One thing about Mary Ellen is that she is still in stores. Her beautiful hair is a great thing about her and her clothes are beautiful.

17 Melody Ellison
18 Blaire Wilson
19 Kaya
20 Marie Grace
21 Saige Copeland
22 Molly McIntire
23 Camille
24 Josefina Montoya
25 Chrissa Maxwell
8Load More
PSearch List