Best American Idol Contestants From Season 9

The Top Ten

1 Siobhan Magnus

2 Crystal Bowersox

3 Lee DeWyze

4 Casey James

5 Michael Lynche

6 Aaron Kelly

7 Tim Urban

8 Katie Stevens

She is very, very, very underrated. Did you listen her version of "Big Girls Don't Cry"? She was awesome! Almost like Carrie Underwood kinda stuff.

9 Andrew Garcia

10 Lacey Brown

BAdd New Item