Top Ten Best American Idol Performances

Out of every performance of every season of American Idol, which is the best of all time? I started it off with ten of my favorites, and I really want to know what everybody else thinks are the best performances.

The Top Ten

1 Clay Aiken - Bridge Over Troubled Water

I loved Clay singing grease...he was out of his comfort zone and I could tell he was uncomfortable doing his hip shaking. This is what made me watch him week after week, and he just got better every week. No denying the kid had talent. Even more impressive was his need to help children. Later I found out he started The National Inclusion charity.

Not only were the vocals incredible, it was spectacular in a way that can't be explained in words. Clay brought the house down with this performance, and there's no way to deny tht. - ilovekelly75

There have been so many wonderful performances on Idol that it's hard to pick just one. Clay's Bridge Over Trouble Water stands out though as the best of the best.

By far the best

V 22 Comments
2 Adam Lambert - Mad World

Adam sung this song with so much emotion. His beautiful voice gave me chills. I was speechless when he finished and so was Simon Cowell apparently. He had no words but a STANDING OVATION! It was evidently the first time Simon had done that and this was Season 8. That speaks volumes right there!

Such a beautiful performance. No wonder he got the first standing ovation from Simon. I still remember the look on Simon's face when they announced Kris Allen won. Simon couldn't believe it. Poor Kris has been trying to overcome it ever since.

Very haunting, unforgettable performance that moved me and really just took my breath away.

The first standing ovation from Simon Cowell. Adam's performance left Simon speechless!

V 4 Comments
3 Carrie Underwood - Alone

Although she's been the fan favorite, as well as the judges' favorite for a while before this performance, Carrie needed to prove that she could be a versatile performer and vocalist. That's exactly why she picked this song, and she did exactly what she intended to do. - ilovekelly75

The only American Idol performance that gave me shivers (and still does). I think Carrie launched herself into the finals with that performance.

Simon was 100% right! I absolutely love her!

4 Katharine McPhee - Somewhere Over The Rainbow

Katharine started of the performance in acapella. The first part alone had a big vocal range, and riffs that she nailed perfectly. Then she went on with the rest of the performance, which she knocked out of the park. - ilovekelly75

5 Kelly Clarkson - Natural Woman Kelly Clarkson - Natural Woman

Starting off the song in a soulful voice, in a low range was difficult enough to do, but it sounded amazing. Then came the chorus, where she belted out the big notes like she's been performing her entire life. The bridge led up to a pitch perfect, beautiful sounding G6 whistle note, straight into the final chorus where she belted it out again with some chilling riffs, leading into the end of the performance, and the massive audience reaction including an obessive fan running on the stage to congratulate her. - ilovekelly75

What a range. #kellebrity

6 Haley Reinhart - House of the Rising Sun
7 Benny and The Jets - Haley Reinhart

HALEY's defining performance! She was sexy in this. No one should ever ever try to sing this song again. She set the bar that high. Loved it so much!

This performance was simply fantastic and so fun to watch. I watch it many times a day because her rendition was, in my opinion, better than elton john's. She is awesome.

8 Pia Toscano - I'll Stand by You

Pia inspired me to be a performer with this touching performance. She has an amazing, huge voice and she doesn't only have talent, she has also soul and heart. I admire her so much.

9 Caleb Johnson - Dream On
10 David Archuleta - Imagine

Randy called it one of the best performances he's ever heard, and Simon called him the one to beat after this performance of the John Lennon classic. He took a simple song, with a limited range, and turned it into a vocal masterclass. He has sung the song many times before, practicing it as a kid, and it all paid off when he performed it on the idol stage. - ilovekelly75

The Contenders

11 Haley Reinhart - Bennie and the Jets

That's the same song as item #7 in the original 1973 cover it says Benny and the jets which is the same song as Bennie and the jets which later they change it- Kevinsidis


12 Kris Allen - Heartless

Not the best but the most game changing performance in the history of the show. Kris appeared on the stage as the underdog, two minutes later he was the favorite to win the show. A brilliant move at the perfect time.

I love Kris's version of this song!

13 Fantasia Barrino - Summertime

Fantasia proved that a little bit can go a very long way. Sitting on the stage, Fantasia gave a classy, and unforgettable performance, which was compelling and moving as well. - ilovekelly75

14 Angie Miller - Who You Are
15 Jessica Sanchez - I Will Always Love You

It wasn't only a perfect performance vocally, it was also a memorable moment of AMERICAN IDOL, that people will remember for many years. Jessica is awesome! Good job, Jessica!

I wonder why it isn't number 1 or 2. She sing it perfectly and the song have many view on YouTube. She made thousand of people cry for Whitney Again

Jessica Sanchez is AWESOME! I'm sure she will do AMAZING things in the future. She is extra talented. This song was her best performance. I wish I could sing like her.

16 Candice Glover - Lovesong

Goosebumps for this lovable performance..

Excuse me, but why is this not higher? - DCfnaf

17 Kris Allen - Ain't No Sunshine
18 Blake Lewis - You Give Love a Bad Name

Blake Lewis's You Give Love a Bad Name showed that he really wanted to win and he just let it come out. It was awesome. I also loved Hayley Reinhart's House of the Rising Sun, and Lee Dewyse's Hey Jude.

19 Crystal Bowersox - People Get Ready

Checked all these out, this one is the best and most heartfelt, I think Haley Reinhearts version of Blue should be on this list and Jacob, god bless the child.

20 David Cook - Billie Jean

This should be in the top ten.

21 Jordin Sparks - You'll Never Walk Alone

Next to Fantasia's Summertime, it ws probbly the most emotionl performance ever, and next to Kelly's Natural Woman, it probably was the most powerful vocal ever. If anybody underestimated the young contestants on the show, they didn't anymore. - ilovekelly75

Really an emotional performance. An inspiring song as well.

22 Elliott Yamin - A Song For You

The song has been remade many times by many different highly accomplished artists, and Elliott knew what he would be compared to, and he stepped up to the plate, and delivered the performance of a lifetime. - ilovekelly75

23 James Durbin - Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow

What is James doing now? I heard he was screaming his head off for some metal band.

To hard to pick just one. He was great every single time.

Will always love James

He was awesome in every performance

V 1 Comment
24 Melinda Doolittle - My Funny Valentine

Melinda chose a simple ballad, and her pure voice shone through. She became the top contender after that performance. - ilovekelly75

25 Bo Bice - In A Dream

Added to the fact that singing a song with no background music in front of 35 million people isn't exactly the easiest thing in the world to do, it was also sung technically perfect, with great vocals, and an unbelieveable amount of emotion behind it. America had no choice but to send him to the final two after this. - ilovekelly75

26 Tamyra Gray - A House Is Not A Home

What an amazing performance. Very heartfelt. Watch it on utube. - funtigg

27 James Durbin - Uprising

Where is he screaming these days. Never hear a word about him. Maybe he lost his voice.

Could never watch this guy. Always had to mute my T.V. when he performed. So much screaming with the most irritating voice. Now I see he sings (or should I say screams) with some metal band.

28 Angie Miller - You Set Me Free

I love the fact that she wrote her own song and she had the guts to perform it in front of everyone. We know Angie, we know her voice is phenomenon but just seeing her songwriting talent was heartwarming because I just love it when singers write their own songs.

What separates her from the rest of the American Idol Contenders is that she has the ability to write great songs. This one caught everyone by surprise! - drummer

29 Jena Irene - I Can't Help Falling In Love With You


The way she sings it with so much meaning and with that epic voice of hers :') PROUD to call myself a Jena fan, I don't care if she didn't win (SHE SHOULD HAVE), I'll always listen to her music, she inspires me, THANK YOU JENA, I LOVE YOU

This is the performance, by far, of season 13. It is just so beautiful and Jena's voice just complements to the meaning of the song

I am in SHOCK. I just can't believe this. This is the best performance idol has seen in that season. Her range. I can't even...

I saw her peform this on the show her voice is beautiful she should've won

V 1 Comment
30 Allison Iraheta - Alone
31 Jessica Sanchez - And I Am Telling You I'm Not Leaving

From the start, I was amazed. Every run, heck, every note was amazing! Especially at the end, when she sang that last 'me' it blew me away, to the other side of the room. - boeingrules

32 William Hung - She Bangs

Admit it, his singing is the most entertaining.

Not to mention that he is confident at what he does, and he does not act so robotic and stiff when he performs. Charisma? He got it!

33 Kris Allen - Falling Slowly
34 Haley Reinhart - I Who Have Nothing
35 Colton Dixon - Piano Man
36 Joshua Ledet - It's A Man's World

Whatt! This should be number 1!

37 Paul McDonald - Tracks of My Tears
38 Adam Lambert - Ring of Fire
39 Elise Testone - Whole Lotta Love
40 David Cook - Always Be My Baby

Better than the original version

41 David Cook - Hello

This day I saw him as an Idol. Best ever. Love you.

42 Jena Irene - Creep

Jena is the best person ever on American idol PROOF she should have won

43 Constantine Maroulis - Bohemian Rhapsody
44 Jessica Sanchez - You Are So Beautiful
45 Skylar Laine - Wind Beneath My Wings
46 Phillip Phillips - We've Got Tonight Phillip Phillips - We've Got Tonight Phillip LaDon Phillips Jr. is an American singer, songwriter and musician who won the eleventh season of American Idol on May 23, 2012. His coronation song, "Home," released after his win, became the best selling of all coronation songs.
47 Casey Abrams & Haley Reinhart - Moanin

Probably the best singing duo in the history of the show.

I just listened to it 10 times on YouTube. Now I'm gonna listen some more

48 Kelly Clarkson - Stuff Like That There
49 Kree Harrison - Up to The Mountain

Her one-of-a-kind tone meets an amazing country-gospel song with beautiful lyrics. This is the performance that brought her to the frontrunners seat. One of the most soulful performance of season 12.

50 Kree Harrison - Here Comes Goodbye
PSearch List

Related Lists

Best Haley Reinhart American Idol Performances Top 10 American Idol Performances of Season 10 Best Jessica Sanchez American Idol Performances Top Ten American Idol Season 8 Performances Best Performances of American Idol Season 7

List Stats

700 votes
100 listings
9 years, 200 days old

Top Remixes (7)

1. Kelly Clarkson - Natural Woman
2. Haley Reinhart - I Who Have Nothing
3. Carrie Underwood - Alone
1. Carrie Underwood - Alone
2. Katharine McPhee - Somewhere Over The Rainbow
3. Adam Lambert - Mad World
1. Benny and The Jets - Haley Reinhart
2. Haley Reinhart - House of the Rising Sun
3. Kelly Clarkson - Natural Woman

View All 7

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.