Best Big Brother US Players

The Contenders: Page 3

41 Donny Thompson - Season 16 Donny Thompson - Season 16

Donny has a great attitude towards all of the houseguests that they all love him, making him a huge threat. If Donny makes it to the end it is almost guaranteed that he will get the money because of everyone's fondness of him. Without being in "the loop" Donny still knows everything going on and warning the houseguests and gaining there trust. If Donny doesn't win, I will be very upset. TEAM DONNY!

Big brother is a game of numbers, so if you are a beast socially and competitively but don't have an alliance, then you will be TAKEN DOWN! - Tito1711

We have the same last name he is my family pick for the win and the america favorite vote so pic DONNY so a TEAM DONNY

2nd Best BB16 player behind Derrick. He was a target since Day 1. Won a BOB by himself and never gave up

V 10 Comments
42 McCrae Olson - Big Brother 15 McCrae Olson - Big Brother 15

McCrae got good strategy and says what's needed when needed, and calms Amanda down

The issue with him was that he was on season 15

Hands down the best stratagist in his season and certainly top 3 for the game. Baring his relationship with Amanda he wins his season

V 4 Comments
43 Shelly Moore - 6th place - Season 13 Shelly Moore - 6th place - Season 13

Played both sides (newbies vs. the vets) beautifully the first half of the game, and then turned on the vets at the right moment, trying to make a big move and keep Daniele. Unfortunately, Adam was too spineless to make a big move. However, she then helped evict the biggest threat left in the game, Jeff. She would have made it even further if it wasn't for that stupid Pandora's Box twist. - janiepierzina

Good strategy of playing both sides of the house. - Tito1711

I actually liked Shelly! Yes did she help breakup America's favorite couple and ruin Jeff's shot at 500k - Hell yeah! Jeff thought Shelly would be taken to F3 with he and Jordan and Shelly would settle for 3rd place. I understood her betrayal, she was handing the power couple 500K. She placed 6th place, but had not been for Porsche opening Paradox's Box who knows if Rachel would had won.

Lol just met her in person

V 1 Comment
44 Keesha Smith - 4th Place - Season 10

Keesha had a fantastic social game. She made it to fourth place because she was able to flip flop sides in the house and kept herself out of the line of fire by aligning with people who had bigger targets on their backs (like Libra). She went from the outhouse to the penthouse on multiple occasions. Having been on one of the most intense seasons of the show, she proved what a great competitor she really is. I hope she comes back for an All-Star season!

45 John McGuire - Big Brother 17

Johnny Mac actually broke the record for being on the block repeatedly and winning the most vetoes to save himself in bb history... He was a loyal player and did anything his alliance told him to even if it meant putting a huge target on his back! If he was in final 2 he would have won hands down and I don't know how James won favorite houseguest and not him...

He's not a good player but he's hilarious. GO JOHNNY MAC!

He was a pretty good player not to mention the fact that he was hilarious. "How come I always end up with a bunch of idiots!? " ~ Johnny Mac. Also at first you thought him and Steve would be great Allies but his comments thought otherwise "Steve is an AWFUL ALLY! " Love you Johnny Mac

He played well besides volunteering to be a pawn a lot. He was good at comps

V 10 Comments
46 Zach Rance - Season 16 Zach Rance - Season 16

Zach is obviously one of the best players ever to play Big Brother, even though his life in the house was short lived. He talked people out of evicting him earlier in the game (just like Dan), and openly hated everyone without much consequence (exactly like Dr. Will). Zach was a great player, and definitely could've gone much farther in the game had he not really blown up towards the end. ZachAttack is way to much of a character for Big Brother to just "let go". I'm pretty sure we all know it's save to say, we'll be seeing much more of Zach.

I think Zach played one of the best games and by trekking the truth it kept him longer because he can't lie without getting caught and he can't keep a secret witch made people wanna keep him in longer I think it was getting so close to Frankie is what screwed his game up.

By far my favorite houseguest ever! Nicole, Zach, and Donny were the smartest and most entertaining people in a house full of big dummies and babies who refused to make big moves. Wish one of the three had won, but hopefully they come back for another Allstar season!

Enjoyed watching his DR's!

V 14 Comments
47 Shelli Poole - 11th Place - Season 17

Shelli played a fantastic game early on, she won competitions, made moves, and was not afraid to get blood on her hands. Had she not been in a showmance she could have easily made it through the game, with her winning two head of households week 2 and 4, put a target on her and clay. Making them the power duo that James took out. Had she waited a little longer or not been in a showmance she could have been one of the best players.

48 James Huling - Big Brother 17 James Huling - Big Brother 17

He's so bad. Every time he has an opportunity for a good game move he turns it into gossip. Plus I found it hilariously stupid when he and Meg were thinking "we shouldn't tell Vanessa about that deal to keep me save because it might piss her off..."

What I have seen from James is that we have a player that is not afraid to make a big move and the two people he got out, Jace and Clay, was in my mind two smart moves. He is also the main reason that the High Rollers are still alive in this game and we don't get to see the annoying Clelli get to the end

One of two competent players on his side of the house, the other being Becky.

I thought he definitely improved in BB18 and put up a respectable game socially

V 3 Comments
49 Michele Noonan - 4th place Big Brother 11

She was the nerdy girl nobody expected to do well, and yet she made it to the final four by winning competitions, staying under the radar and making the right deals with the right players.

Shes right up there with Danielle Reyes that could had won her season! I liked the fire in her as competitor and was able to make moves in the game. Liked her a lot.

I fell like this is Michelle Meyer from s18! I love her!

50 Austin Matelson - 5th Place - Big Brother 17 Austin Matelson - 5th Place - Big Brother 17

Yes, he was not a fan favorite by any means and for good reason if one watched the LiveFeeds and episodes. Yet I can't knock he had a good social game and didn't get nominated til week 11 (that's saying something). He did a good job keeping the huge targets twin sisters, Liz and Julia, as his shield and protected them at all cost in the game. He was able to rope and build trust with one of side the house to keep himself safe til Meg and James were ultimately evicted. Had potential to win the season then he was ultimately blindsided by one of the best gameplayers of the season Vanessa (whom he aligned with in Day 2) in a 2-1 tiebreaker vote that sent him to jury barefooted. - BlackDiamonds

Best guy in the games felt sorry for him rock on Austin

V 2 Comments
51 Ragan Fox - 5th Place - Season 12

Very good player, only one actually to fight back with Rachel

52 Kaysar Ridha - 10th Place - All Stars Kaysar Ridha - 10th Place - All Stars

How on earth is he on this list

Most strategic his powerful gameplay was his downfall

53 Judd Daugherty - 5th Place - Season 15 Judd Daugherty - 5th Place - Season 15 V 2 Comments
54 Hayden Voss - Season 16

Without a doubt the hottest contestant in big brother. Nicole and Hayden are the perfect couple and season 16 went so downhill when he was evicted.

In my opinion Hayden was the best big brother player in history. His physical, strategic, and social game were all flawless.

If he had voted to evict jocasta instead of zach, he could have gone a lot further in the game

V 1 Comment
55 Jessica Hughbanks - Season 8
56 Jozea Flores - Big Brother 18 - 15th Place

Absolutely not

57 Sharon Obermueller - 4th Place - Season 9 Sharon Obermueller - 4th Place - Season 9

She played the perfect pawn role. Stayed out of the line of fire. She was able to tell when someone was lying and that got Matt out. She was screwed at the final four hoh competition.

How is anyone from season 9 on this list

Really wished she and Shelia made F2. Sharon was a pawn queen, but a very likeable houseguest among a bunch of duds that season. - BlackDiamonds

58 Dustin Erikstrup - 9th Place - Season 8 Dustin Erikstrup - 9th Place - Season 8

The photo beside was probably the best face I've ever seen in when someone was evicted

I'll feel so good to see dick evicted! Put me up next to him so it's a slap in the face! Gets evicted himself...

V 1 Comment
59 April Dowling - 8th Place - Season 10
60 Sarah Hrejsa - 11th Place - Season 6
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top Ten Best Big Brother Canada Players Top 10 Best Big Brother 14 (US) Players Most Underrated Big Brother U.S. Players Big Brother USA Players as of Dan's Funeral Top Ten Most Underrated Big Brother (US) Players

List StatsUpdated 23 Jun 2017

5,000 votes
90 listings
9 years, 64 days old

Top Remixes (84)

1. Will Kirby - Winner - Season 2
2. Dan Gheesling - Winner - Big Brother 10
3. Derrick Levasseur - Big Brother 16
1. Dan Gheesling - Winner - Big Brother 10
2. Will Kirby - Winner - Season 2
3. Danielle Reyes - Runner Up - Season 3
1. Will Kirby - Winner - Season 2
2. Dan Gheesling - Winner - Big Brother 10
3. Danielle Reyes - Runner Up - Season 3

View All 84


Buzzfeed's top 193 Big Brother (US) Houseguests Part I
Buzzfeed's Top 193 Big Brother (US) Houseguests Part II
Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.