Best Big Brother US Players

The Contenders: Page 4

61 Roddy Mancuso - 6th Place - Season 3

For Danielle - biggest rival. He was many times nominee and always survive.

62 Jameka Cameron - Season 8

Let her religion get the best of her in playing the game well. - Tito1711

V 1 Comment
63 Brittany Martinez - 13th Place - Season 16

She was evicted way too early but it was only because the guys knew they couldn't manipulate her and they realized she was a force to be reckoned with if she stayed in the game

Yeah so the fact that she was seen as a threat that early made her a bad player

64 McCrae Olson - Big Brother 15 McCrae Olson - Big Brother 15

McCrae got good strategy and says what's needed when needed, and calms Amanda down

The issue with him was that he was on season 15

Hands down the best stratagist in his season and certainly top 3 for the game. Baring his relationship with Amanda he wins his season

V 4 Comments
65 Zach Rance - Season 16 Zach Rance - Season 16

Zach is obviously one of the best players ever to play Big Brother, even though his life in the house was short lived. He talked people out of evicting him earlier in the game (just like Dan), and openly hated everyone without much consequence (exactly like Dr. Will). Zach was a great player, and definitely could've gone much farther in the game had he not really blown up towards the end. ZachAttack is way to much of a character for Big Brother to just "let go". I'm pretty sure we all know it's save to say, we'll be seeing much more of Zach.

I think Zach played one of the best games and by trekking the truth it kept him longer because he can't lie without getting caught and he can't keep a secret witch made people wanna keep him in longer I think it was getting so close to Frankie is what screwed his game up.

By far my favorite houseguest ever! Nicole, Zach, and Donny were the smartest and most entertaining people in a house full of big dummies and babies who refused to make big moves. Wish one of the three had won, but hopefully they come back for another Allstar season!

Enjoyed watching his DR's!

V 14 Comments
66 Lisa Donahue - Winner - Season 3

While I agree Danielle was a much more deserving winner and Lisa only won due to a bitter jury, I also think she is an extremely underrated player. She was very observant and was the first to figure things out on multiple occasions. She knew what was best for her game and she did it.

How did she make the list at all, dumb luck? Please take her off the list

Doesn't deserve to be on the list

67 Diane Henry - 3rd Place - Season 5 Diane Henry - 3rd Place - Season 5 Diane Nicole Henry is an American model most known for coming in third on Big Brother 5, a reality TV show broadcast by CBS in 2004.

She kept a balance between her alliance with Drew, and her group alliance with Nakomis, Will, Karen, and Adria. If someone in her group alliance won HOH, she was safe, and if someone in Drew's alliance won, she could talk him into getting his allies to save her. She could also talk him into getting out some of his own allies. She made a fatal mistake by sticking with Drew and Michael and getting rid of Karen and Nakomis, because she was out in third, and Drew and Michael got rid of the coattails they've been riding.

Diane would have gone down as one of the all time greatest big brother players if she hadn't spoken in her sleep that one night in the final three week with Drew by her side. Unfortunately as well, she was in a bad place in her personal life at the time of the All-stars season.

By far the best player of BB5. The only reason I see her being so far in the ranking is her poor performance in the all-star

Switching to drew and Michael got her place in the final 2 bit she was evicted in 3rd place because she told drew that I can never beat you in final 2

V 1 Comment
68 Sheila Kennedy - 3rd Place - Season 9

She caused the most pivotal move of the game bu bringing a highly successful alliance later to be run by Natalie, and then organized Natalie's eviction five weeks later, and managed to get to the top three with two of her closest allies. Unfortunately, the winner of the final HOH was neither her, or her partner Adam, and she was evicted in third place, just shy of the final jury vote.

Split the house in half by getting Ryan to put up James instead of Matt, putting her on the stronger side. - koenbertens

Very good social game and knew how to get herself out of sticky sessions that made her a target (eg - Allison being her lesbian lover). She was also entertaining to watch and took no bs. - BlackDiamonds

V 1 Comment
69 Helen Kim - Season 15

She has the control over the right amount of people and is playing an impressive game where she is being nice and friendly to everyone, then taking in Aaryn and GinaMarie after all the chaos so she can still hold the numbers once a couple of people go.

She gave public speeches that almost hypnotized people to do whatever she said.

Ran the whole house at the beginning of the game, however her game got ruined by Andy. - Tito1711

No she bugged me bad

V 2 Comments
70 Amanda Zuckerman - Big Brother 15 Amanda Zuckerman - Big Brother 15

Amanda's tactics are harsh and she is very aggressive and crude, but she successfully ran BB15. BB15 was Amanda's season, not just for her drama but because of the ease in which she had everyone doing what she wanted. She is the reason why almost everyone was evicted from the game. The way she managed the houseguests was so incredible that it became too predictable for the fans, and they turned on her. (That, and the way she ultimately became an opposing force to Elissa) You have to remember that this is the same girl who was a huge target on week 2 (by the moving company) and she went from the bottom to controlling the next 7-8 weeks. Bravo!

Love her or hate her but she is just controlling the house like only few others did before (Danielle Reyes, Chilltown and Dan). She deserves to be there

It's a shame that fans mix emotion with gameplay, because she played an All-Star worthy game, even if she only won one competition the whole season. At the very last, she should switch places with Cody on the list.

She should definitely be higher on this list. She had her part in every eviction, kept her social game super strong, and basically had everyone on her side. If it wasn't for Andy flipping on her, she would've won.

V 8 Comments
71 Victor Arroyo - Big Brother 18 Victor Arroyo - Big Brother 18

Victor was AWESOME, maybe he will be back in another season or another All stars, he totally deserves it, and on top of that, he is totally HOT

Competition Beast. Great social game. To bad he does not think for himself and play the game.

My favorite player, got in 3 times

He's a competition beast, but unfortunately it looks like he's getting evicted this week. I wish he backdoored Nicole when he had been HOH instead of evicting Michelle.

V 1 Comment
72 Renny Martyn - 5th Place - Season 10

Loved her she was so funny

73 Jody Rollins - 16th Place - Season 14

She was the only one in the house that was a newbie who I could tolerate and of course she out in 6 hours if I was her I would because at them out

V 3 Comments
74 Elissa Slater - 6th Place - Season 15 Elissa Slater - 6th Place - Season 15

Just want to mention I found it funny how she was consistently the most popular houseguest because she was related to someone who was once in an alliance with jeff

Even though she got MVP the first three weeks. She quickly made friends! Like Helen and Candice. Even though she's not so good at compitions, she played the game very well! She was very smart when she voted for Amanda to stay! It would have payed off if Mcray knew! And plus if Kathy is up here why is elissa! Over all elissa played a very good game!

Deserved America's Favorite. She was the house primary target because of her kinship with BB winner Rachel Reilly. She was never allowed to make game moves because bully Amanda and "It's too soon" Helen. However she was probably one of the few people in the BB15 house who absolutely hated the racism that flowed through the house. She was able to win 2 POVs and HOH (that sent her biggest rival/bigot Aaryn Gries off to jury house).

75 Michelle Costa - 7th Place - Season 10
76 Aaryn Gries Aaryn Gries

It's true that she said some offensive things, but let's not act like almost everyone in the cast didn't say at least one offensive comment, let alone Aaryn being the worst of them all. Also, she deserves to be ranked higher because she actually improved her position in the house from the most hated houseguest to being considered as part of the majority, and she was a competition beast.

Even Though She Was Hated She Would Have Won In The Final 2 simply because everyone hated her and she still made it!

If Aaryn would have made final 2 she would have had many personal votes against her. Wouldn't see her winning at all

Umm... How is that thing good?

V 3 Comments
77 Brendon Villegas - 9th Place - Season 13 Brendon Villegas - 9th Place - Season 13
78 Devin Shepherd - Big Brother 16 Devin Shepherd - Big Brother 16

Although his veto move cost him his game, he stirred up the house. He divided it where it needed to be. He was such a fierce competitor. If it wasn't for Donny, he would still be in the game. He could of easily defeated Caleb. If he didn't fall for Brittany's tactics, he would be in there. His pluses now: he was aggressive and everyone feared him. Everyone except Derrick and Cody. Beast mode Cowboy Caleb feared him. His head was in the game, he was just too out there. Watch his time in the Big Brother house and think about it.

Anyone who couldn't even make jury should not be on this list

He was terrible and made half of his game decisions without consulting with the members of his alliance

V 1 Comment
79 Nicole Nilson Schaffrich - Runner Up - Season 2

Very under rated player. She positioned herself perfectly around top 6, and everyone felt as though they could trust her. Not to mention she was expected to be the first person evicted and was able to get herself out of that through pure manipulation.

She's forgotten now because of Dr. Will, but you have to give her credit for getting to the final two. She was the most hated house guest the first week and was nearly voted out, but paired up with the right person (Hardy) and made it to the final. Also without her Will never would've won.

80 Erika Landin - 2nd Place - Season 7 Erika Landin - 2nd Place - Season 7

Dr Will himself admitted that he underestimated her, and it cost him his game

Strategic goddess in BB4 and super underrated.

Flew under the radar pretty well. Don't understand why people hate Erika. She deserved to win over Mike Boogie in S7. One of the most underrated players in BB history.

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top Ten Best Big Brother Canada Players Top 10 Best Big Brother 14 (US) Players Most Underrated Big Brother U.S. Players Big Brother USA Players as of Dan's Funeral Top Ten Most Underrated Big Brother (US) Players

List StatsUpdated 19 Aug 2017

6,000 votes
90 listings
9 years, 121 days old

Top Remixes (85)

1. Will Kirby - Winner - Season 2
2. Dan Gheesling - Winner - Big Brother 10
3. Derrick Levasseur - Big Brother 16
1. Dan Gheesling - Winner - Big Brother 10
2. Will Kirby - Winner - Season 2
3. Danielle Reyes - Runner Up - Season 3
1. Will Kirby - Winner - Season 2
2. Dan Gheesling - Winner - Big Brother 10
3. Danielle Reyes - Runner Up - Season 3

View All 85


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.