Best CreepyPastas Everbooklover1
The Contenders: Page 10
This one should honestly be higher on the list. I heard CreepsMcPasta got recognized for this one. I love how the attention shifts from the girl and her terrible life to the narrator and his psychotic murder spree. And the ending...
I threw up reading this, super gory and detailed. A must read for fans of Unbranded Laptop and Dating Game.
Makes me want to vomit. If you can't handle gore PLEASE don't read this..
Not super scary but more suspenseful...
In my opinion, one of the only pastas to efficiently use gore to scare me. It has some deep meaning to it as well. There are many creepypastas that have the whole "I accidently watched a murder, now I'm dead" theme, and they're just full of holes and lame. This one however completely makes you think the person is still alive, and you actually want to wonder what ever could have happened. It's in my Top 5 favorite
I like this one, but, I knew what the "twist ending" was about half way because of the obvious hint they drop in the middle.
Really good, plus really underrated. Liked the ending, too.
Never heard of it but sounds cool.
The masks change when you not looking. Don't look to long or she atacks you when you blink so don't look
I love "Where the Sidewalk Ends" and "A Light in the Attic"V 1 Comment
Great story with an amazing twist ending! It is a five to ten minute read, and a seven minute listen. Due to the ending, it has earned the spot as my favorite Creepypasta story of all time.
Short, and not nightmare fuel but definitely worth the read.
It makes you scared when your air conditioner turns off at night. If you think you're the brave thinker in bed at night this will change that.
Related ListsTop 10 Scariest Creepypastas Top 10 Gaming Creepypastas Top 10 Creepypastas That Should Be Made Into Movies Top Ten Pokemon Creepypastas Top Ten Things You Probably Didn't Know About Creepypastas
List StatsUpdated 18 Aug 2017
6 years, 50 days old
Top Remixes (65)
2. Jeff is Back
3. Lost Silver
3. Slender Man
2. Jeff is Back
3. Jeff the Killer vs Jane the Killer
View All 65