Best CreepyPastas Ever


The Contenders: Page 19

361 Mr. Angel
362 Hyper-Realistic

This is just a funny parody of people always using the term, Hyper-Realistic. - booklover1

Don't look at the picture! It's worse than Jeff, Squidward's suicide, and Luna game combined! Unlike the other creepypasta, this one is... hyper-realistic.

This hyper realistic story is so hyper realistic, that your hyper realistic mind will hyper realisticly explode. - SirSkeletorThe3rd

363 Wake Up
364 The Portraits

Shocking ending, scared the hell out of me

This one's really short, and not so very scary but a pretty shocking ending. I recommend it.

V 1 Comment
365 The Theater

This one is so interesting! I really wondered if this game ever existed. I was also creeped out by the simplicity of the game

The game was pretty creepy. In the game, the creators said that you were supposed to click one of the posters with the movies labled on them on the wall.

No one will play it because we are not doing just walk beside worker men and what at last just a wall I mean ho creat this game

V 1 Comment
366 The Truth About Ed, Edd, N Eddy

A very creepy (yet convincing) look at the truth behind one of Cartoon Network's best shows. The creepy thing, it makes so much sense!

Another well made childhood destroying theory. The thought that the cul-de-sac is a cursed plane of existence makes this a thought provoking and horrific story.

It is a creepypasta so deal with it.

367 Jeff the Killer vs Slenderman

One of the best stories I think as it is two of the best creepypastas (in my Opinion) fightng each other, great one to listen to at night as well, might not get to sleep, just watch out...

If you think about it Jeff can't be full human if he survived being burned cut and stabbed so many times. Slenderman isn't human so what is he?! So I think it's a draw.

Come its slenderman vs jeff the killer its going to be a draw

Very well written, if I do say so myself. I loved it.

V 4 Comments
368 Sonic CD Hidden Message

It's not really signed by the devil. Mejin or whatever is just a shortened version of the producer's name. - Pikachulover1

The message reads fun is infinate with SEGA Enterprises signed The Devil.

V 3 Comments
369 Crappypasta

Crappypasta stories may have flaws but they're not THAT bad. People who say they deserve no credit at all are just haters.

370 Team Fortress 2 Engie's Suicide
371 I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream
372 Nurse Joy

Wow. My mind is blown. I looked for this online, but the one that I read is called, "Jessica" and I think that that's the same one as this. This is not a scary story, but a heartwarming story about a Pokemon game. You have to read this and you will instantly be touched. I was.

373 Clockwork

This story is awesome! It should be top ten! I highly recomend it. Its just not very popular though... but is my personal favorite! Its just a girl with a messed up life that goes insane! What is there not to love

333, Dang why is she so low on this list?

May be on here but did not see
This was my 2nd creepypasta I ever read and it was awesome even though it's a jeff the killer knock off

I'm glad shes at the bottom shes a poor character just poorly made and the story, please nina the killer is a better story than this and I HATE her the writer took on the strong subject of rape and exacuted it very poorly I can't say eny more than to sum it up that...SHE SUCKS WITH ALL OF THE WORLDS PEOPLE AS MY WHITNESE SHES THE WORST CREEPYPASTA IN THE UNIVERSE! I hope Iv made myself clear.

V 2 Comments

By far the creepiest thing that I have ever read in my life. This should disturb anyone. It's a pretty quick read, but that last line is so horrible..

Yeah it's not that scary though.

He scary the picture doesn't really show you anything of what he looks like so it's kind hard to tell what he is but still the words who was phone is pretty scary I thought was done reading them like what it's really scary it freaked me out now I'm scared to answer the phone

I have yet to read another creepypasta that has stuck with me for as long as "who was phone". It still gives me the chills when I am home alone at night and the phone rings. Bluh, don't read by yourself!

I laughed

V 8 Comments
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top 10 Scariest Creepypastas Top 10 Gaming Creepypastas Top 10 Creepypastas That Should Be Made Into Movies Top Ten Pokemon Creepypastas Top Ten Things You Probably Didn't Know About Creepypastas

List StatsUpdated 18 Aug 2017

6,000 votes
376 listings
6 years, 50 days old

Top Remixes (65)

1. Jeff the Killer
2. Jeff is Back
3. Lost Silver
1. Jeff the Killer
2. Herobrine
3. Slender Man
1. Jeff the Killer
2. Jeff is Back
3. Jeff the Killer vs Jane the Killer

View All 65


Worst Types of People on the Internet EP-16 Season Finale
WonkeyDude98 (Mini) Analysis: Squidward's Suicide
Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.