Best CreepyPastas Everbooklover1
The Contenders: Page 2
An amazing creepypasta about the inevadibility of death. It truly raises questions, not to mention has several alternate endings.
I like this one. It raises questions, and has good buildup. Also, it has lots of great symbolism. Gold dying in the ends symbolizes the death of the Gameboy Pokemon games. The number of badges increases like the number of pixels 8 first, as 8 bit. Then, it goes to 16, then 24, and so on... Those are all other multiples of eight. The increasing number also acts as a grim reminder that everything you do... Doesn't matter because someone will surpass you, and you will die. Your accomplishments don't change that, - GREATEST
I love this story so much! It deserves to be first on tip ten. It is creepy, exciting and when it ends it leaves thoughts and questions bouncing around in your head.
I like that they put this on hereV 15 Comments
I like him as a creepy pasta and I could just say ever girl out
There that likes masky always wonders what he looks like
Underneath that mask. One thing I don't like is that he is one of slenders
Goon. ( fact ) his real name is Tim
Honestly people should stop spouting the 'he isn't a creepypasta', shut up and do your research. Creepypasta is defined as horror stories on the internet, and oh wow guess what, videos are visually telling a story! Who knew? Saying that he isn't a creepypasta and Marble Hornets isn't because it's not a original and based off the slenderman, newsflash: a hell of a lot of creepypastas are based off another, like Jane the Killer! They took the authors original Slenderman work and made videos for it, and added characters to it, and is widely accepted as having the best representation of the slenderman, and if you research the slenderman most sites, Slenders' official wikia for example, will include the authors original idea and that of Marble Hornets, and since they just used all the true information on the Slenderman, it's adding onto that of the original creepypasta. Masky, and his Partner Hoodie, need to be more recognized as actual creepypastas!
Masky is a brilliant character from the channel MarbleHornets. I am actually quite scared of his character as he is shown to appear out of no where and is very aggressive. MarbleHornets was presented amazingly, seemed so real. I don't know how many times I have been jumped scared by Masky appearing around the corner in the videos. Masky also scares me as where ever he is, slenderman is sure to be close by. As well as he can easily tackle you and even kill you. The whole concept of him being anywhere anytime by him being teleported around by slenderman actually makes me paranoid and creeps me out.
Definitely one of my top five favorites.V 14 Comments
I love hoodie! Even though he's just a proxy, he's awesome! He stalks you, then bashes your head in with a brick. And all you see of him is glowing red eyes and a stitched closed mouth. He is epic!
Again, going to say this character was a great creepypasta and is actually terrifying, and yes, he is a creepypasta, because he is from an Internet based horror story, thank you very much, and creepypasta's aren't always short. Saying that they aren't creepypastas because they aren't original is so messed and wrong because they used the original idea and expanded on it and used the facts of it and made Slenderman so much more popular.
I've noticed many versions of how Hoodie kills you. There is the brick, the gun, and I've seen the metal pipe. I wonder which is the real version. But none the less I still fall in love with the story of this red eyed proxy.
Hoodie is so cute.V 12 Comments
I'd read creepypastas before, but this is the creepypasta that got me into creepypastas! I find it odd that so many people didn't like the ending, because the story did such a good job of building your hatred and anger for the villain that it was really, REALLY great to see the little bastard get his comeuppance at the end! I wish I could have viewed the sequel, but either it isn't posted yet or I just can't find it anywhere.
This was my third creepypasta, and I have to say it's the best. I'm having trouble believing this isn't in the top ten, since it's so damn good. Tons of pictures to accompany the story make it all the more believable and thrilling. I believe there's even music from the game you can find online. It's not exactly lose-sleep scary, but it's a great thrill ride and puts an amazing twist on the beloved original game.
A masterful creepypasta. it's tense, mysterious and (of course) very creepy. If you don't believe me then just take one look at Red and you'll know what I mean.
My mind was blown. That was terrifying, that was exhilarating, that was an experience. I wouldn't even call it a creepypasta. This story is truly an epic.V 10 Comments
It's a little cheesy, but it's pretty scary, especially what happens during and after the encounter of the tunnel. - booklover1
Holy crap, that was surprisingly good...
I read it, and I didn't want to go into any more abandoned tunnels. - username34V 2 Comments
That was so good! But still really creepy @ the same time. Its really well written and it is something you can really call creepy! It was disturbing @ some points but that is what you should expect from a good creepypasta! The best creepypasta I have read by far! I love it!
This was an -amazing- pasta, especially compared to some of the horribly written ones ranked above it. Some typos and stilted suspense part of the way through, but really? Why the hell is this #30?!? AWESOME PASTAS ARE AWESOME.
This is something we can call as creepy. Its excellently written. Something that really gives you creeps. Plus, the subject is somewhat different. No video games or lost episodes stuff. My opinion? I ♥ it
This creepypasta will always remain one of my favorites. A great introduction to fun and games meets grotesque genius and downright scary. I recommend this one to the diehard creepypasta fan.V 13 Comments
Jane The Killer is the best of the best and deserves to be number one because in almost every story she kills jeff and her story creeped me out but she is the best go jane if you don't agree remember this is just my opinion
She deserts more credit. She nearly kills Jeff the killer and gave birth to his child!
In my opinion Jane the killer was better than Jeff the killer for many reasons and the story is very well written and the way she looks a lot more awesome and she just has more character once more this is just a opinion
Jane is basically a hotter, less creepy version of Jeff. Just don't meet her on the street. - ChibiDaFoxV 20 Comments
WHY ON EARTH HAS THIS NOT BEEN MENTIONED YET?! Let's take a look, shall we?
So Tom gets a game, blah blah blah note, don't play it, he's coming, yadda yadda yadda. But then the game... OH THE GAME!
The first button he press sends him to a strange title screen for a split second, already making him wonder about this. Then, he selects Tails from a select screen. He moves, and soon sees MUTILATED ANIMALS! And then there's Sonic, who's not really Sonic... Oh boy.
He sends Tails to a burning field, then chases him down, and get this, WITH THE DROWNING MUSIC. Afterwards, he does who knows what to Tails. Oh, by the way, Sonic has dark eyes with red glowing pupils that bleed. Just FYI. Then, Tom chooses Knuckles. Knuckles goes into a room, and sees Sonic. So, he tries to punch him. You know what happens afterwards. Teleporting, Knuckles is tired, death, and now Tom takes a nap, where Sonic haunts him in his sleep and Tails and Knuckles mourn about their deaths. Then, Tom finally ...more
I got nightmares after reading the story, because of that I never played sonic the hedgehog ever in my life again. And what makes it creepier is that there's a game of it, I've seen game plays of Youtubers like PewDiePie and Markiplier and I got really creeped out and the ending is just scary as hell... When Sonic just popped out on the screen saying 'I Am God' with that laugh I can't remember that character he laughs like plus... You can't escape the game, even if you press escape it won't and whatever button you press it just shows Dr. Eggman, Knuckles and Tails' heads on a wooden pole and their bodies are laying on the floor and also in another picture it shows Sonic was levitating behind a wallpaper saying creepy stuff. By far this is one of the most scariest creepypasta stories ever.
This is way scarier than Tails Doll, and this is an actual game that can be downloaed or even be played on disc! A friend of mine has played the game on disc and got so scared, he sold the game to someone else and luckily, he did it before he saw the plush!
WE HAVE TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT THIS HE IS NUMBER 27!? NOT HAPPENING - Narutomaster5000V 33 Comments
Really awesome creepypasta!
The concept of a creature created by your own imagination is brilliant!
Also, this Tulpa thing is REAL. Just Google it, you can find tutorials on how to make them. After reading this creepypasta I gave it a try and I have successfully created one. Anyways, awesome creepypasta, good story and good build up.
What the hell? Why is it right down at 114? It's a good Creepypasta In fact, I daresay it's better than the original. It makes a lot more sense, and is a lot creepier. But it's easier to get creeped out by the video, rather than by just reading it.
Fangirls are annoying... but what can I say?
This was one of the best what I don't get thought is the Jeff the killer fan girls who have crushes on him? Personaly I love the story its self so horrifying almost as good as the first
LOVE YOU JEFF!?V 3 Comments
There is no words to describe this pasta. But, lets just say I very do think this pasta should be in the top ten. I don't think I have read anything more horrifying then this story. So I think you should totally read this story, but I warn you it may give you nightmares.
A very thrilling Pokemon creepypasta. Was fun to read.
I literally feel sick after reading this. I swear ill never touch a Pokemon game in my life EVERV 2 Comments
I think he should be top 10
Zalgo is underdeveloped and thus under appreciated. Once he gets a few good pastas going for him, instead of just the short comics, he should pick up in popularity, especially since he already has a clear and menacing description, even if it doesn't explain much about him as a being.
Should be in the top ten, considering he might be Satan himself. Zalgo's become my favorite creepypasta character so far.
I love Zalgo! He is baeV 6 Comments
I didn't want to play Minecraft anyways...
Herobrine is a dead person who will kill you and if you play and see herobrine you will die.
Herobrine should be at a higher place than this cause he is a bad a$$. And just think about it, you are in a large dark place by yourself and you suddenly see two white glowing eyes in the distance stalking you with a bloody sword in its hand. CREEPY.
I hope herobrine is deleted to not feeling spyingV 29 Comments
Do you see him? I'm not sure. But that picture is actually from a whole different episode. It's an earlier episode when Homer Simpson forgets Bart at a soccer game and Bart hates him a whole bunch after that (there was a rain storm for 4 hours while Homer was gone). When Bart finally got into his dads car, Homer tried to apologize, but Bart was still mad at him and, in his mind, made his dads face look all decayed because he was mad at him. The picture being part of a creepypasta is a lie. - username34
Do not, and I mean do not watch the dead Bart video unless you want to have nightmares for the rest of your life!
Apparently, I read if you watch it fully, Bart will stare at you in your sleep, he will appear everywhere and you will be cursed.
Dead Bart is easily the scariest thing I've ever read. As a 12 year old Simpsons fan, I found this story absolutely horrifying, Make SURE to avoid the video. I watched it, and now I keep seeing Bart out of the corner of my eye.V 6 Comments
It's not so much of the creepy-pasta, but more of the fan art. We know the basic looks from Sonic R. But the fan art is just adding blood, teeth, and claws. Boom. All of the Tails Doll fan art in a nutshell.
So I think it's very creepy.
Great creepy pasta needs to be in the top ten. - htfan792
My personal favorite creepypasta it may not be scary but the tails doll have a really awesome design and curse
CAN YOU FEEL THE SUNSHINE?!
(because I don't.) - ChibiDaFox
I feel like the Luna game has a good concept. But it's more hilarious than it is scary. The fact that it traps your computer and forces you to keep playing is pretty good though. But the pictures that pop up several times aren't creepy until you stare at them for a while.
I hate My Little Pony but I have to say...
This story is more hilarious than it is scary
Not scary at all! Suck it, bronies!
As much hate as this comment is getting, this is not scary at all. There are so many cliches, it is unbearable! - GREATESTV 2 Comments
Falls into theory but makes you think twice about watching kid cartoons. They can make even adults scream in fright
This theory is so fake, one hole in the theory's logic is that there have been Rugrats episodes WITHOUT Angelica. - CommentandList
I wasn't impressed at all by this theory it had to many holes in it
Not really scary, to be honest. It has so many plot holes anyways, - TheEvilAlpacaV 1 Comment
This really is a wonderfully creepy idea of what could be the basis behind an awesome show. Although it's a little heart wrenching for me to think that some of my favorite characters were based of these poor girls.
When I first saw this as a creepypasta I thought it was going to be bad but when I read it made absolutely sad because they all died in terrible ways definitely deserves to be higher it's my favorite creepypasta and I've read a ton of them
So sad, I cried. My eyes were bloodshot I cried so much. I've read a lot of creepypastas, but this wins the award for saddest.
So...Twilight caused Suicide because her friends died and Luna saved her? this story ain't realV 9 Comments
I probably just put this here because I'm a huge fan of the show, but this one is one of the few that still haunts my nightmares. - booklover1
What the? Is this one even a real creepypasta?
Well they finally realized how bad the show was
What's phinea's suicide?V 2 Comments
Related ListsTop 10 Scariest Creepypastas Top 10 Gaming Creepypastas Top 10 Creepypastas That Should Be Made Into Movies Top Ten Pokemon Creepypastas Top Ten Things You Probably Didn't Know About Creepypastas
6 years, 164 days old
Top Remixes (65)
2. Squidward's Suicide
3. The Russian Sleep Experiment
2. Jeff is Back
3. Lost Silver
3. Slender Man
View All 65