Best CreepyPastas Ever


The Contenders: Page 9

161 Jason the Toymaker

I actually like this one. In a way, Jason is a lot like Laughing Jack. If you abandon him or forget about him, he will be your worst nightmare. Jason the Toymaker is actually a very cool and interesting character; I really like his hair.

Jason the Toymaker is Terrifying I mean just straight of creepy that voice and the phrase he uses ( I will fix you) it's just creepy he should be in the top 10

This is a great pasta. Never abandon Jason or he will kill you and make you into one of his own creations.

He's my personal favorite, I mean, burning kids alive with wax? How's is that as good as just stabbing someone?

162 Teeth.jpg

A great one that sent shivers down my spine, gave me nightmares and the fact that he labeled everything is just insane

163 Doors

Overlooked horror story with a fantastic twist! Unlike the 'Jeff' stories, this one is smart and well written.

164 The Scary Burger

This pasta involves a burger that eats people, instead of people eating burgers. It's really an environmentalist/animal rights thing, but it's a good one.

165 Fog
166 Rugrats Lost Episode: Chuckie's Mom V 1 Comment
167 Midwest
168 Die Before You Sleep
169 I'll See You In Hell
170 Halo Ghosts

Yeah they were ment to be AI bots but got removed at last minuet and you still find them. I think they can kill you but you. Can't kill them and that's what makes it creepy

171 Super Mario 64

Ok, this is by far, the most scary, horrifying, terror-causing creepypasta EVER WRITTEN! Along with Emine and other Super Mario 64 creepypastas.
It shows Luigi dying, a black thing chasing Mario along, the Japanese whimpering when Mario's face was spinning, the family that turned into skeletons in the time it took to dunno.

THIS IS SCARY, The way you picture it makes it even EVEN more scarier, Tell me this isn't at least giving you the chills. Terror-full

172 Teddy

Which one is it? Their's two of them and the one I think this page is referring to is the one I haven't read. The one I have read isn't that scairy, but the second half is funny as hell.

Teddy scared me and I'm not usually scared of creepypastas but this one made me look around my bed to she if it was there o :

V 2 Comments
173 Dark Link
174 KageKao

Yes! KageKao! Both scary and entertaining at the same time (even though he's an OC).

175 The Black Dog and Goat

A story twisted in every single way that just feeks wrong but little bit of right as well as making and not making any sence. Its not exactky nightmare fuel but it's a worth reading. It's so well written to the point of looking like a short book, it also has detail every where it matter as well as keeping out details where they shouldn't be

176 Ted the Caver

Seriously, among all of these, read this one! It will stay with you and you will obsess over it. The writing is just too good, simply too realistic for you to remember that this is a work of fiction while you are reading it. Well, a work of fiction, inspired by real events with pictures to prove it. Seriously, cozy up and read, you won't regret it!

I'm half way through this. Very long read.

V 1 Comment
177 It

Hello Everyone Iam KatnToastyMomo I've Made Steam
So If Anyone Wants Any Game Just Post And I Swear
I Will Give You The Game As Fast As I Could
Which Will Be Only Mere Minutes
It Will Be A Giveaway So Write Down Your Steam Profile
And Thanks For Reading

V 2 Comments
178 Spongebob's Suicide

The YouTube thumbnail is creepy enough.

179 Glitchy Red

I love him and silver! Top ten or at least top twenty

180 UBOA
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top 10 Scariest Creepypastas Top 10 Gaming Creepypastas Top 10 Creepypastas That Should Be Made Into Movies Top Ten Pokemon Creepypastas Top Ten Things You Probably Didn't Know About Creepypastas

List Stats

6,000 votes
377 listings
6 years, 114 days old

Top Remixes (65)

1. Jeff the Killer
2. Herobrine
3. Slender Man
1. Jeff the Killer
2. The Russian Sleep Experiment
3. Smile.jpeg
1. Eyeless Jack
2. BEN Drowned
3. Jeff the Killer

View All 65


Worst Types of People on the Internet EP-16 Season Finale
WonkeyDude98 (Mini) Analysis: Squidward's Suicide
Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.