Best Members of Metallicarocker1796
The Top Ten
Metallica wouldn't be the same without James. - BlueSphere
Greatest rhythm guitarist of all time and the fastest right hand out there.
James is Metallica! All those great riffs,epic lyrics,great transitions,awesome songwriting, insane downpicking, palm muting, versatile vocals, inspiring frontmanship, mind-blowing combination of singing and playing at the same time are some of his defining qualities. Along with lars, he formed Metallica. He is such an inspiration to millions. All the great Metallica songs are the results of his hardwork and talent.
1)Most skilled members = James and Cliff
2)Most dedicated to the band=James and Lars
3)Most of the workload= James
4)Most of the writings= James and Lars
5)Most of the compositions=James and Cliff(earlier)
6)Most brutal=James and Jason
7)Most influential members=James and Cliff
8)Most solos = Kirk and James
9)Most riffs= James and Kirk(few)
Greatest Vocalist ever, I have been a fan of metallica since I was ten, I loved listening to enter sandman, then got into thier less known stuff. James will always be rhe best vocalist ever, just listen to Nothing else matters, mama said and low mans lyric and you will see just how amazing his vocals are, METALLICA 4 EVA! - dragon13304
He was the smartest, and the most tolerant.
Living god of bass
Should be No. 1.
Why was Trapped Under Ice and Escape the worst songs on Ride The Lightning? Probably because they were the only ones where Cliff Burton wasn't one of the writers.
Why was Master of Puppets so good? Well, It probably wouldn't of been so good if Cliff Burton didn't write some of the song. Damage Inc. would of been my least favorite song in the album if Burton didn't write it, and I would of hated Orion if it weren't for him.
Thinking about others (Wikipedia), Check.
Made Metallica a good band, Check.
Pretty much the best Metallica member of all time.
THE best bassist ever
He is there best guitarist - Legend1221
Very original guitarist
Ok, so Dave Mustaine was just a talented songwriter and guitar player, who was famous for being good at it.
Kirk Hammett is a terrible guitarist, who uses a wah pedal to make things easy, and was only famous because of the band he's in. His riffs were also not as good (except for Enter Sandman) and the solos were just ok.
He was underrated because Cliff was there in Metallica. He was a better vocal than James in Reload age.
The definition of brutallity
He was the best live performer that Metallica never had. I wish he never left the band...
He was bullied by James and Lars...I'm so sorry for him... - Idiot244
Lars Ulrich is a legend. And I know you guys think I'm crazy but in actual fact you are the one that is crazy. METALLICA would not be METALLICA without Lars. People don't really give him the credit that he deserves. For example in Enter Sandman his drumming is spot on and so badass.which is why it is one of my favourite songs of all time. And I'm sure that TRUE METALLICA FANS would agree with me. STOP HATING ON LARS!
Overhated, yet he's my favorite drummer. metallica wouldn't be metallica without lars. - awesomedp900
THE REASON WHY ENTER SANDMAN WASNT SO TERRIBLE, and still sucked.
Robert Should be #3
Dave is an an incredible musician, there is no doubt about that. However, he was just not the best fit for Metallica, and if he were still with Metallica to this day, then there would be no Megadeth.
I think Metallica should've stuck with their original guitarist and bassist.
They were better with dave :(
People give him more credit then he deserves. He isn't even as technical as his own guitarist in megadeth - Sabbath
Shouldn't be on the list because he was only a member for less than a year and didn't even contribute to the band. All he got was a garage demo, and played during the 30th anniversary. I might of put him in the top 3 if he never left Metallica, and they probably would've always been good.
But he decided to quit and let Metallica get terrible. Cliff Burton wasn't too bad, but if he were still alive, I bet Metallica would be worse than they are today. Jason Newsted was actually pretty good, had a nice bassline in "My Friend of Misery", but none of the albums were as good. Robert Trujillo is just the metal bassist you shouldn't care about because when he joined, they were making St. Anger, and Death Magnetic and Lulu came out, and James became a table.
So basically, thanks to him quitting the band, Metallica became terrible, but not until after Burton's death, and this is why nobody cares about him. Also, he was not a placeholder, he was a real member.
Did the bass on St. Anger after Newstead left and before they hired Trujillo -