Best Metal Concept Albums


The Top Ten

1 Metropolis Part 2: Scenes from a Memory - Dream Theater

THIS ALBUM IS AMAZING! I'm trying to get the theater guild at my school to do this as a play/musical lol. they still can't figure the story out lol - fireinside96

I've listened to lots of music throughout my entire life... nothing really compares to the awesomeness of the instrumentalists of Rudess, Myung, Petrucci, and Portnoy, and the unique emotion jerking vocals of James LeBron.

Anyone who hasn't listened to this cd has never heard good music.

No metal album can beat this. - naFrovivuS

V 2 Comments
2 Operation: Mindcrime - Queensryche

There is no doubt that "Operation: Mindcrime" should be known as the best metal concept album ever made. Being a die hard Iron Maiden Fanboy, I feel that this albums blows away Seventh Son of a Seventh Son without a question. There is not one bad song on this album. This is Queensruche at it's best. This album is so amazing, it almost converted me into becoming an anarchist. The production is outstanding, the harmonies from metals great Geoff Tate blow me away every time I listen to Operation: Mindcrime, and the storyline is fantastic. Though, it does get a little slow during the ten minute "Suite Sister Mary. " Other than that, Operation Mindcrime should be known throughout the world as the best metal concept album of all time. Hell, it was #2 on a list of regular concept albums, except Pink Floyd: Dark Side of the Moon won that list.

Simply amazing from start to finish... Music wise and story wise. Come to think of it: That story would have made a darn good moovie!

This is a ultimate masterpiece. - ActOfGenesis

SFOM is amazing, but nothing tops this album. - MindCrime

3 Seventh Son of a Seventh Son - Iron Maiden

It was EXTREMELY difficult to choose between this and the sublime "Still Life" by Opeth. I gave it to maiden though, on the basis that this album inspired many metal concept albums which proceeded it. Each song can stand on its own, and become even more amazing when one listens to the album in its entirety. Arguably maidens best, and one of the best metal albums of all time.

haven't herd much of this but you don't need to iron maiden is just better thn the rest

I bought this album in 88 and I still listen to it. Enough said.

Not a concept album. - MindCrime

V 2 Comments
4 ...And Justice For All - Metallica

Actually, this is a concept album. It's not only a tribute to deceased former bass player Cliff Burton, but nearly every song on the album is anti-war/government. Plus, every song is long, with very technical arrangements and lengthy instrumental sections. - Johannes9

5 Abigail - King Diamond

This album should be number 1. It is way better than the overrated and boring Scenes From a Memory. - Rambles

Perfect album. His best.

Greatest of all time

6 Still Life - Opeth

Great story in the lyrics to the songs. You guys should really take a look at it. It will blow your mind.

7 Nightfall in Middle Earth - Blind Guardian

Scenes from a memory is definitely the best but this one needed some love. Its incredible. Other great contenders for me would be Crack the skye and the black halo.

Beautiful, intense and epic. Can't get enough of Hansi's vocals - Thorn, Into The Storm, Nightfall.
Hansi is not only one of the greatest singers, he is probably the best story teller on this list - for example, Time Stands Still (At The Iron Hill); Nightfall. - Metal_Treasure

8 The Human Equation - Ayreon

Does anyone here has seen the Theater Equation (live version of the Human Equation)?

V 1 Comment
9 Leviathan - Mastodon

This should be way higher, the storytelling on this album rivals the actual book 'moby dick'. And the song Blood and thunder contains the most epic line in songwriting history 'SPLIT YOUR LUNGS WITH BLOOD AND THUNDER! '

Unlike a lot of these, there is a lot to this album. It actually tells a story, which not many of these albums can claim to have. It doesn't matter if the style is all over the place at times, it still makes a consistent theme, which is a lot more than a lot of concept albums can claim.

This is the album that'll sell non-believers on. mastodon. It may not be there most ambitious but I find it a great escape. Kind of like sitting down to read a book.

10 The Black Halo - Kamelot

I feel like Epica should be included in this because they are part of the same story, but anyway, it has masterful instrumentation and phenomenal vocals coupled by an amazing variation on one of the greatest pieces of literature ever. Not only is this an amazing complete album, but it lacks the drawback of many concept album in that its songs do a great job as stand alone pieces and not just within the scope of the entire album.

Just an absolute amazing album, Kamelot's best album ever for sure together with Epica!

Simply the best!
A concept album loosely based on Goethe's Faust. Continuing the story introduced in Epica, it is the second and final record in Kamelot's two-part concept about Ariel.
Kamelot's amazing vocals and superb instrumentation is simply amazing


The Contenders

11 Them - King Diamond
12 Dark Saga - Iced Earth

Great album! Not the best in the list, but is still amazing! The human equation (or really any ayreon album) has an epic story line, scenes from a memory is one of my favourites, iron maiden, symphony x, kamelot, opeth, therion... Gah! There are just too many great albums by great bands to choose a best!

Although I prefer Horror Show and Night Of The Stormrider as concept albums, this album is still pretty great in my opinion! - IronSabbathPriest

13 Crack the Skye - Mastodon

How is this not above Leviathan at least... It is by far their best album

More prog rock than the albums before this. I like that. - IronSabbathPriest

14 Blood Mountain - Mastodon

An album about a wolf-like man climbing a mountain to place a crystal skull at the summit to (this is what I've read) reach the next step of human evolution, sure why not. Amazing story telling that rivals all books I have read, because if you think about it books are 90-98% filler. However this album is less than 10% filler, and that's just setting the mood for each of the songs. The plot furthers with each song except for pendulous skin which is about Joseph Merrick. Every song is heavy and have great writing. Plot heavy songs like "Circle of Cysquatch" and "Siberian Divide" are great and do not have a bad thing about them. I only have four problems with this album; 1: Why hasn't anyone made a cartoon dedicated to this album and its story? 2: Why couldn't have been longer? 3: Why doesn't it have an extremely large fan base that rivals those of Star Trek and My Little Pony? 4: It never explains how it ends leaving us on a cliff hanger that will most likely never be explained. These ...more

Simply the greatest Mastodon album, This should be at least top 5, Leviathan ain't that great and AJFA IS NOT A CONCEPT ALBUM

15 Beyond the Red Mirror - Blind Guardian

A lot of people seem to love this album on this site but I thought it wasn't very good compared to old Blind Guardian. - Rambles

Blind Guardian's 2015 album is flawless (symphonic metal). Epic, epic and epic.
The perfectionists from Blind Guardian worked on this album for 5 years and it paid off. Some of the songs had 8 versions to choose from for the final selection.
My favorite songs from this album are: The Ninth Wave, The Throne, The Holy Grail, Sacred Mind. - Metal_Treasure

16 Crimson - Edge of Sanity
17 V: The New Mythology Suite - Symphony X
18 Dead Winter Dead - Savatage

It's an anti-war album, released in 1995. It was pretty cool that an American band wrote a concept album dealing with a Serb boy and a Muslim girl who fall in love. The story of the album also focused on the Bosnian War, which was ongoing at the time.
My fave songs: Christmas Eve (Sarajevo 12/24), Dead Winter Dead, Doesn't Matter Anyway, I Am, One Child, Mozart and Madness (instrumental). - Metal_Treasure

19 Horror Show - Iced Earth

It's not a concept album because it doesn't follow a single story. All it's songs follow different stories.

20 House of Gold & Bones Part 2 - Stone Sour

One of the best concept albums of the decade. Corey Taylor created an amazing story that rivals some of the best concept albums.

21 Parallax II: Future Sequence - Between the Buried and Me
22 Epica - Kamelot
23 Dreaming Neon Black - Nevermore
24 Octavarium - Dream Theater
25 The Glorious Burden - Iced Earth
26 Mercy Falls - Seventh Wonder

It's always arguable what is the "best", but this is a damn good album, and Seventh Wonder deserve more attention than they get.

27 Remission - Mastodon

Not a concept album.

28 The Scarecrow - Avantasia
29 Imaginations from the Other Side - Blind Guardian
30 The Crimson Idol - W.A.S.P.

This should be in the Top 10 at least. - Rambles

Definitely one of those "Why didn't I buy you 10 years ago? " albums.

31 Night of the Stormrider - Iced Earth
32 01011001 - Ayreon

Love this album :D

33 Conspiracy - King Diamond
34 Antichrist Superstar - Marilyn Manson

One of the greatest concept albums of all time, it tells the story of The Worm who is considered inferior to society and it's fascism ways. So he build's himself up as The Little Horn to try and save humanity but only realizing that humanity does not want to be saved, thus he becomes The Disintegrator and destroy's humanity

Whether you like them or not this album has an amazing concept with some fantastic lyrics. It's part of the triptych which is an artistic masterpiece. - 1234567890qwerty

35 Secret of the Runes - Therion
36 The Downward Spiral - Nine Inch Nails

Tells of a man who slowly self destructs and eventually wants to commit suicide. An amazing album, best NIN album - RustyNail

37 Catch Thirty Three - Meshuggah
38 Paradise Lost - Symphony X
39 Magica - Dio

Best Dio album.

This album is amazing! Ronnie and Craig Goldy are amazing on this record and this is my favorite Dio record ever.

40 Blood on Ice - Bathory
41 The Time of the Oath - Helloween
42 Jomsviking - Amon Amarth
43 In Waves - Trivium
44 Pleasant Shade of Gray - Fates Warning
45 My Arms, Your Hearse - Opeth
46 Into the Electric Castle - Ayreon
47 Design Your Universe - Epica
48 The 1st Chapter - Circus Maximus
49 Death Came Through a Phantom Ship - Carach Angren
50 Obsolete - Fear Factory
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top Ten Metal Concept Albums That Should Be Made Into Movies Top 10 Best Concept Albums Top Ten Best Concept Albums of the 21st Century Most Underrated Concept Albums Top 10 Progressive Rock Concept Albums

List Stats

600 votes
113 listings
7 years, 172 days old

Top Remixes (12)

1. Metropolis Part 2: Scenes from a Memory - Dream Theater
2. Parallax II: Future Sequence - Between the Buried and Me
3. Dreaming Neon Black - Nevermore
1. Still Life - Opeth
2. Crimson - Edge of Sanity
3. Metropolis Part 2: Scenes from a Memory - Dream Theater
1. Nightfall in Middle Earth - Blind Guardian
2. ...And Justice For All - Metallica
3. Dead Winter Dead - Savatage

View All 12

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.