Top 10 Best Nostalgia Critic Episodes

A great internet comedian. A critic that's interesting to watch. He's hilarious, now I want to count down the top 10 favorite episodes of his.

The Top Ten

1 The Room

That's meee! - Johnny

you're tearing me apaaaaaaaaart lisaaaaaaaaa - LucasMota

All these guys do is play football, they need to get a new hobby. This guy has one, banging his best friends girl and acting totally surprised about it every time.

I did not hit her it's not true it's bull I did not hit her I did nat oh hai mark

2 Batman and Robin

Best review - Alexh

A BAT CREDIT CARD?! Laugh out loud Love it! So hilarious! I especially love the part where the Nostalgia Critic had to be calmed down multiple times just because of that one moment.

This is basically everything that embodies a good Nostalgia Critic review. He's appropriately angry, and the film is just awful. The "bat-credit card" bit deserves special mention.

I showed this to my buddy and know we talk about NC all the time

3 Neverending Story 3

Honestly this is a classic

"But wait... (strained breathing)... There's MORE! "

I laughed so hard at the part about jumping the shark

Neverending Story 3, while maybe not a classic, is definitely an excellent review. But also... Why is garbage pail kids number 50? I mean, I thought that was one of his best!

1 Comment
4 Titanic: The Animated Movie

Rapping dog!

5 Alvin and the Chipmunks

I love all of his episodes. They're so good, interesting, and relateable too because there's always those movies that make us want to tear our hearts out in agony and I think it's funny to see Doug Walker (Nostalgia Critic) experience that (maybe a little bit exaggeratedly) too because it sort of reminds of all of that. - Anonymousxcxc

The funniest episode in a while. The "Girls and Boys of Rock and Roll" tribute is the best part, but the jokes are sharp, clever and bold as ever. - SourNote2014

Best one yet - BoyGenius234

This live-action franchise has my most hated movies of the years they were released. What the hell is with the one-dimensional chipmunks (not just their voices)?! >:(

1 Comment
6 Mad Max: Fury Road

"You will walk the red carpet sugared in glaze, you will walk the red carpet sugared in glaze." That quote officially made this my favorite episode.

LMAO through pretty much the entire episode. Devil Boner telling off the meninists, hooking up with Hyper Fangirl...hell, just when the fangirls showed up was hilarious...and then of course there was Crazy Ass Guitar Guy. Best episode ever.

7 FernGully

Big lipped alligator moment!

8 Foodfight!

NC (scared): WHAT?! WHAT?!? WHAT?! WHAT?! WHAT?! WHAT?! WHAT?! WHAT?! (We see the scene continue as Dex and Dan are chased around the scary lady and her equally scary baby.) Oh, my God, I get it! I totally get it now! This movie is punishment for me to repent all the terrible things I've done in my life! All right! If it will stop you from scaring the living animal Jesus out of me, I'll confess! I'LL CONFESS! I was the one who cancelled Firefly! I was the one who encouraged Fred to be an online series! I was the one who told Taco Bell to make a breakfast menu! I was the one who told John Travolta how to pronounce Idina Menzel! I was the one getting rid of the cartoons on Cartoon Network! JUST TAKE ME OUT OF THIS SCENE!

That one whole paragraph of made-up confessions in a script was a work of genius. - ModernSpongeBobSucks

I love the intro and the jokes spliced throughout, "Boy have the Ratchet and Clank games really gone downhill", this is my favorite review.

Everything about this episode is pure perfection in a Nostalgia Critic episode. The jokes were hilarious, so much of the movie was made fun and the best part: the Brand X Sales Man impression.

The best part is were the phone tells him is he sure he want's to review this movie - BoyGenius234

9 Tom & Jerry the Movie

This is the review responsible for giving us the idea of the most unholy duo of all time...Russel Crowe, and Shakira if she swallowed Kermit the Frog

My first nostalgia critic episode which made me love his videos.

His reactions to the singing are hilarious. -

Oh my god is that blood

1 Comment
10 Moulin Rouge!

Not only Doug's favorite review but you can tell how hard he worked in this episode, and it also helps how funny the ending result is, deserves more than 11th to be honest - Pato_cargo

His first BIG video with amazing production values and singing. When he semi-retired the show, he released a video counting down his 11 favorite episodes with this being #1. It's always been my favorite since it came out, as I do to hate the movie

Ooo, the first singing review. Dare I say it's the BETTER singing review? -

The Contenders

11 An American Tail: Fievel Goes West
12 Casper

I've always loved this review with the addition of Casper being a dbag. I wish he would make other Casper reviews so as to see his thought's on those films.

13 Son of the Mask

Death is the only salvation!

I laughed uncontrollably at this one - 445956

This was the first review I've ever saw from him. And I gotta say it was hilarious! Great humor, interesting subplot with the devil, definitely check this one out. It's worth your time. Trust me.


1 Comment
14 IT

You know, like it 1990 and it 2017 nostalgia critic's review of it is better than his original one.

Drunk NC Is the funniest!

Oh Hey, It's a beautiful Tim Curry out there tonig-AAAH

15 The King and I

I watched this film as a child and was delighted to see the Critic making fun of it.

16 The Other Animated Titanic

This review was so perfect. The film is just exactly what a nostalgia critic episode is all about. It just had so many ridiculous twists and turns that made it so funny, and nc was on the top of his game as always.

This movie was a big bowl of what? Great review!

,I laughed so much that I was crying!

17 The Garbage Pail Kids Movie

Really this was his least favorite movie

It’s so bad that when PhatomStrider was doing his worst movie list Doug told him that this
movie was the worst

Ohhh myyy god, it suuucks, it really s the worst movie of all time

18 Kickassia

I think this movie is hilarious

19 Bebe's Kids

Now looking at this review I wonder why Universal didn't get bankrupt.

20 Felix the Cat

His hate for the movie is the main thing about the review. Seriosuly, he acts like this is the worst movie he has seen.

21 Cool As Ice

Even though it's a some what recent one, Vanilla Ice sucks. And this review is hilarious. -

22 Dr. Seuss' The Cat In The Hat

This one actually got a huge laugh from me including the chart scenes lol

23 Bartok the Magnificent
24 Thomas and the Magic Railroad

Here's a generic song it sounds like hundreds of other songs everything's nice in this song that's why no one remembers it. Generic song Generic song some Jackass wrote this in his sleep Generic son Generic song I shuts up your kids so you can't complain.

Do trains have sperm?

Oh lighten up! It's Thomas the Tank Engine!

Baldwin goes full... uh... whatever the hack he was

25 Junior

That scream during the baby scene made my day! - NickXH

I'm so bored. SO VERY VERY BORED.

26 Jingle All the Way

An Arnold Schwarzenegger Chritstmas. -

Put the cookie down... NOW!


"I'll be 'buck'! " - SourNote2014

27 A Troll in Central Park
28 The Langoliers

The Critic pokes fun at this wonderfully goofy horror miniseries and its overacting and sub-standard CGI effects with great joke after great joke.



29 Inspector Gadget

No I've got to get out of here

30 Drug Cartoon Special

I lost it when Simon said "marijuana", it was just so unexpected!

31 Baby Geniuses
32 The Wizard

Pretty much shows how much Kool-Aid the 80s kids were drinking at the time. The critic's review both praises and makes fun of what could be considered the first video game based movie.

Main kid, "Cali-fornia".
Nostalgia Critic in high pitched voice, "California, California, California." - Anonymousxcxc

33 Raiders of the Story Arc: DuckTales

From the tuning fork to the jokes about EL CAPITAN, this is a must watch.

34 The Care Bears Movie


The jokes never get old.
You gotta admit the Spirit was really cool though. - SourNote2014

35 Animaniacs Tribute

Yakko's Critic - XtheXlmao

36 The Making of Coming Out of Our Shells Tour

Both the Nerd's and the Critic's humor are very funny, and the movie is pretty awful. -

Both Doug Walker and James Rolfe make one hilarious review of quite possibly the only band that can be three times worse than young money

37 Moonwalker

You'll love this review if you like to see Nostalgia Critic review god-awful movies.
The scene that made me crack up is when Michael Jackson turns into a cyborg to kill drug dealers. No joke.

This review is just all around hilarious, especially how he
Does the impressions and makes fun of the utter weirdness of the movie.

"The hills are alive with the sound of SHAMON! " That just sums it all up. Who knew that the critic liked smooth criminal so much?

38 Scooby Doo

I think his Scooby Doo rant in the beginning sums up what it's like to live the life of a world wide celebrity.

39 Top 11 Drug PSAs

"This... Is crack" Very funny. -

40 Top 11 Nostalgia Mindf****
41 Bio-Dome
42 Musical Review: Moulin Rouge!

Moulin Rouge makes Frozen look as underrated as a retro classic game.

Best musical review ever.
"guilty plesures" is the best song they've done.

And let's not forget: Chester: I didn't even get a line!

43 Video Game Review


44 Captain Planet Captain Planet

I'll admit, while I like the Nostalgia Critic, I did not appreciate his review on this show, it is one of my favorites!

45 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

But they have guns

46 Hammerman Cartoon Hammerman Cartoon Hammerman is a Saturday morning cartoon, produced by DIC Entertainment and starring pop rapper MC Hammer, which aired for thirteen episodes on ABC in 1991.
47 Top 11 Animaniacs Episodes
48 North
49 Raiders of the Story Arc: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

"Turtles cheat with honor! " - SourNote2014

50 The Secret of Nimh 2

The Secret of NIMH 2: PENIS to the Rescue review
Animation: 2
Sound: 2
Story: 1
Characters: 1
1.5/10 (the only weaker Don Bluth movie is A Troll in Central Park)

8Load More
PSearch List

Related Lists

Best Nostalgia Critic Season One Episodes Best Nostalgia Critic Season Two Episodes Best Nostalgia Critic Season Three Episodes Best Nostalgia Critic Season Four Episodes Best Nostalgia Critic Season Five Episodes

List StatsCreated 25 Jun 2010
Updated 30 Sep 2019

800 votes
145 listings
9 years, 167 days old

Top Remixes (16)

1. An American Tail: Fievel Goes West
2. Mad Max: Fury Road
3. Alvin and the Chipmunks
1. Alvin and the Chipmunks
2. Rapsittie Street Kids: Believe in Santa
3. Foodfight!
1. The Room
2. Batman and Robin
3. Scooby Doo

View All 16

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.