Top 10 Biggest Best Picture Snubs at the Oscars

Have a movie that you think should have won Best Picture, but lost to something else? Vote here!
The Top Ten
1 Citizen Kane (lost to How Green Was My Valley)

Come on, it's Citizen Kane. About half the film critics in the world consider it the best American movie ever.

2 Dr. Strangelove (lost to My Fair Lady)

Kubrick's classic was the best of his films to be nominated for the Oscar, and it's a shame that the genius never won.

3 Pulp Fiction (lost to Forrest Gump)

There's nothing wrong with Forrest Gump. But Pulp Fiction is a Tarantino film, which means its entertaining, stylish, and quotable.

4 High Noon (lost to The Greatest Show on Earth)

Keep in mind, Singin' in the Rain was also released that year. Many film historians consider it the best movie musical of all time. It was ranked number one on AFI's best movie musicals. Both Singin' in the Rain and High Noon are on AFI's top 100 greatest movies of all time. Strangely enough, Singin' in the Rain wasn't even nominated for Best Picture.

This was just a fail. Go to AFI's list of top movies and look at High Noon. It's one of the best westerns ever.

5 Saving Private Ryan (lost to Shakespeare In Love)

The Big Lebowski also came out that year.

6 The Dark Knight (lost to Slumdog Millionaire)

It wasn't even nominated and is #4 on IMDB's best movies of all time. Certainly my favorite movie of all time.

7 Goodfellas (lost to Dances with Wolves)

Dances with wolves is seen in every worst best picture winners list not because its bad film but because it beat goodfellas and rightfully so, goodfellas is one of the greatest movies of all time

8 The Thin Red Line (lost to Shakespeare in Love)

Dare I point out that Shakespeare in Love's biggest threat was actually Elizabeth.

9 The Shawshank Redemption (lost to Forrest Gump)

Forrest was good but it's crystal clear Shawshank was the best. Sometimes the best things are left for the test of time I guess.

10 Apollo 13 (lost to Braveheart)
The Contenders
11 E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (lost to Gandhi)

Okay, Ben Kingsley's performance is stellar, but it doesn't make the whole film better than one of Spielberg's greatest.

12 Inception (lost to The King's Speech)

A mind bending epic.

13 Brokeback Mountain (lost to Crash)
14 Taxi Driver (Lost to Rocky)
15 The Full Monty (Lost to Titanic)

The smart and cheeky British film about the plucky Chip & Dales led by Robert Carlyle lost to some big boat.

The Full Monty got screwed, on the other hand Titanic did at least prevent that borefest L. A Confidential winning.

16 Black Panther (lost to Green Book)
17 The Social Network (lost to The King's Speech)

They were both excellent films, but "The Social Network" was just a little bit more well-made.

18 King Kong (lost to Cavalcade)
19 2001: A Space Odyssey (lost to Oliver)

There is evidence that 2001 was never even a real contender. The fact that it couldn't get nominated ahead of Rachel Rachel says it all. Back then the Best Picture race was considered a duel between The Lion in Winter and Funny Girl.

Actually Oliver! Was still a deserving winner given what was actually nominated for Best Picture that year; Oliver!, Funny Girl (a vanity project for Barbara Striesand), The Lion in Winter (Peter O'Toole and Katherine Hepburn bitching like schoolgirls, Romeo & Juliet (Shakespeare with hippies) and Rachel Rachel (essentially 1968's The Kids are Alright but with Joan Woodward instead of Annette Benning).

20 Black Swan (lost to The Kings Speech

Black Swan is a superb horror thriller, as well as one of the best movies of all time. I like the King's Speech, it's a well made movie, but it was one of the weaker nominees that year.

21 All Quiet on the Western Front (lost to Everything Everywhere All At Once)
22 12 Angry Men (lost to The Bridge On The River Kwai)
23 Fargo (lost to The English Patient)

At least Frances Macdonald won for best actress.

24 The Elephant Man (lost to Ordinary People)
25 The Pianist (lost to Chicago)
8Load More
PSearch List