Biggest Mary Sues of the Warrior Cat Universe

The Contenders: Page 3

41 Sharkfall

Not a cat - Frogjaw1996

I'm getting the Sharknado vibe from this e.e

42 Marysue V 1 Comment
43 Appledusk
44 Feathertail

Well, there is a steep hill argumement on if she's a mary sue or not. I think she is. She's described as kind, pretty, gentle, a weakling, and looks a lot like her mother, who could have easily been described as the prettiest she in the clan. She attempted a forbidden relationship, while knowing her mother died from a forbidden relationship. Ignoring tradgedy in favor of instinct is pretty stupid for such a loyal clan cat, and it doesn't make since either. She was always so nice, but then argues when Stormfur and kills Sharptooth. Logic? I agree that she's a stereotypical girl from the 40's. - Diistortions

I don't love Feathertail..but I still don't think she's a Mary-sue! How is Feathertail a Mary-sue?! Yes, she's pretty, gentle, kind, looks like her dead mother, saved the Tribe, but she still is not a Mary-sue! She tried to pursue a forbidden relationship with Crowpaw(feather) even though her own mother DIED because of a forbidden relationship! That's not Mary-sue. And she argued with Stormfur. Not mary-sue.

Also, to add to my post, Sharptooth was a MOUNTAIN LION, don't forget. He killed many from the Tribe of Rushing Water, and then is killed by a tiny little wild cat. - Diistortions

Silverstream didn't REALLY kill Sharptooth on her own. Sharptooth was crushed.

V 6 Comments
45 Stargleam

Yup. Queen of mary-sues just about covers it. The ONE cat every single person in the fandom can agree is a Mary-sue! I mean, ugh why does she have to be so perfect?

Ugh, when I read Starkit's Prophecy, I wanted to strangle this cat. I mean, can you even call her a CAT? With her "super duper special powers", she should be the next queen! Seriously, there's, like, a million toms after her, one of which is her GREAT GRANDFATHER! Feh...go die in a hole, Stargleam.

Is it just me or does this warrior cat stuff have the DUMBEST names ever? I mean seriously, "snowfur", "stargleam", "feathertail". Ugh, gag me with a spoon. - Brobusky

She annoys me so much, I hate her!
But she is not a cat in the series so...

V 26 Comments
46 Moonflower Moonflower

I don't really like Moonflower, but that doesn't mean she's a Mary Sue. Sure, she has the prefix moon: which I'm surprised the Erin's let happen, she wasn't very understanding to her brother, and honestly I think she was pretty awful to him: but she wasn't mentioned enough in Goosefeather's curse and she died too quickly in Bluestar's Prophecy to have any real evidence of being a mary sue. At the very most, she's an underdeveloped character.

Bluffer and Snowfur loved her so much, she was definitely described as beautiful and sweet, but she doesn't really have any character development. I haven't seen examples of these traits. Plus, she's Goosefeather's littermate, so while he's described as old and crazy, she's young and motherly. They're the same age, guys!

She has the prefix "Moon", is gorgeous, and described as young and lovely while her littermate is described as old and cranky. Enough said.

MoonFlower was a kind caring cat, not a Mary Sue - SeeU

V 2 Comments
47 Billystorm

This name is so funny all I think of when I hear his name is a bunch of goats in a hurricane!

This cats name...

Seriously. This guy is just annoying. Leafstar should've picked someone better. In my option, Billystprm is a Gary-stu. I just find his act heroic. Suddenly being a kittypet gets you three kits with the leader? I know he has an emotional side, but I just think he needs to get a grip.

His name... His NAME...HIS NAME LOL

V 3 Comments
48 Russetfur

Plus, do you even know how OLD she is now?

Okay, she's not a crazy marysue like Stargleam or Dovewing, but I just think she's overrated. She's always the one in battle who is oh so witty and throws back a sassy retort at anything any warrior says. Still, not a crazy marysue thankfully.

49 Wind Runner

Even though Wind Runner is a bit overpowered compared to other cats, she isn't a total Mary Sue, because she goes through real hardships that aren't handled too unrealistically, and she does have obvious character flaws that impact the storyline.

She skilled. That makes her a Sue? She has a LOT of character flaws. She's stubborn, ugly, irritable... There's no way she's a Sue.

She is always right and is an amazing hunter and fighter. Even her daughter is special

It's odd how she is suddenly amazing fighter

V 2 Comments
50 Tigerstar Tigerstar Tigerstar is the biggest villain in the Warrior Cats, also the cat that Firestar wants to kill . He has two mates, Goldenflower and Sasha, and four kits, Bramblestar, Tawnypelt, Mothwing, and Hawkfrost . After he dies, he goes to the Dark Forest where he is killed again except this time by Firestar more.

I just added this for fun, just to see if anyone could find any way for Tigerstar to be a Gary Stu.

Ha! This just goes to show that so many people don't even know what a Stu is. Nice one to whoever added this!


Ugh where do I begin? Tigerkit NEVER got in trouble and blamed it all on poor little whitekit! THE SON OF A CLAN LEADER? Kills so many cats is the leader of the dark forest? Um Brokenstar? Honestly the biggest marysue on here.

51 Longtail

Long tail is not a Gary Stu. Seriously, who added him in? I'm getting tired of defending everybody.

Don't ask me why...


52 Yellow Flame

Yellow Flame? - Walla

So fake - Frogjaw1996

I is stuupid

53 Mosskit Mosskit

Just because she died early doesn't make her a mary sue. - IcetailofWishClan

She died too early.

WHAT?! Mosskit hardly had time to grow a personality before she died! It's impossible for her to be a Mary-Sue! WHO ADDED THIS IN?!


54 Lionheart

Lion heart is a strong cat, and he seems like a Stu at first glance, but it hard to tell with his limited time in the books.

Though I do love Lionheart he IS a Gary-Stu

He isn't shown enough to know that he's a Stu..

55 Cloverflower
56 Dawnwhisker
57 Tawnypelt V 2 Comments
58 Morningstream
59 Graypool
60 Turtle Tail

Why is Turtle Tail here? She never did anything wrong. - IcetailofWishClan

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Biggest Mary Sues from Disney Movies Top Ten Mary Sue Warrior Cat OC Names Best Warrior Cat Characters (Book by Erin Hunter) Top Ten Saddest Warrior Cat Deaths Best Warrior Cat Couples

List StatsUpdated 19 Oct 2017

800 votes
85 listings
4 years, 190 days old

Top Remixes (4)

1. Millie
2. Dovewing
3. Spottedleaf
1. Spottedleaf
2. Dovewing
3. Cinderheart
1. Spottedleaf
2. Onestar
3. Millie

View All 4


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.