Top Ten Classic Examples of Nightmare Fuel from the Paper Mario Franchise

The Top Ten

1 Mimi's Transformation from Super Paper Mario

2 The River Twygz Bed from Super Paper Mario

3 The Shadow Queen from Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door

4 The World of Nothing from Super Paper Mario

5 The Shunned Guy from Paper Mario: Color Spash

6 The End of the World from Super Paper Mario

7 Chapter 4 from Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door

8 The Parallel World from Paper Mario: Color Splash

9 The Boo-faced Toad from Paper Mario: Sticker Star

10 The Forever Forest from Paper Mario

The Contenders

11 The Ghost Toad from Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door

What's more terrifying at one point he asks Mario to find his diary and makes it pretty clear that he not read it the player stupidly decides to read it after finding it the ghost Toad will show up and be furious at the player for reading his diary and basically kills Mario leading to a game over.

12 Faceless Toads from Paper Mario: The Origami King

13 Two Bowsers from Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam

14 Paper Macho Chain Chomp Jumpscare from Paper Mario: The Origami King

15 Becoming the Shadow Queen's Servant from Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door

16 Tubba Blubba's Heart from Paper Mario

17 Flavio from Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door

BAdd New Item