Top 10 Creepypastas That Should Be Made Into Movies

Horrible_Username

The Top Ten

1 Jeff the Killer Jeff the Killer Jeff the Killer is a creepypasta usually accompanied by a picture of a white face looking in to the camera smiling in an unsettling manner. The creepypasta is also usually accompanied by the term "Go to sleep".

No no no no! If there will be a movie about Jeff the Killer it would end up like the Slenderman movie - ElSherlock

Knew it he was going to be first

HAHAA NO this would be too funny! Not only that, but that the story is too poorly written to be made into a movie. - OnlyInDreams

Perfect ideas but they should make Jeff look like a very very psychotic person make his gums show have blood dripping off his mouth after he makes a smile.

V 69 Comments
2 The Smile Dog

Well I guess it would be a good idea to make the movie

If they made a movie of this I would imagine it as a mystery thriller vibe. It would have an investigator who visits the mom of a teenager who kills herself a week after seeing the picture. The investigator doubts that the picture had anything to do with the suicide and doubts that the picture is possessed but after seeing it himself he starts to be haunted by the dog in nightmares and is taunted to "spread the word"

I have read this story something like...12 times or more

Still scares me

Just the image is creepy in and of itself

This deserves a VERY good movie with a GOOD director and not some cheap ass director either

Its story is GOLD and deserves nothing but the best as a director

Smile, so cute... Anyway I would love to see it. It would be like a psychological suspenseful scary movie. If they make it they should have the main think he sees Smile everywhere. And he buys a Husky to help him feel safe but said Husky is Smile!

V 13 Comments
3 Slender Man

There was a movie of this and it was bad - ElSherlock

I heard the movie wasn't good.

This would be amazing! It would be so refreshing and different from your average cheap slash-horror movies, just like this CP is so different from all horror stories and urban legends that I've usually heard growing up.. Someone PLEASE make this into a movie!

I wish though they should try and make a slenderman origin story, also the movie would be hectic because maybe we can find where slenderman hides the bodies

V 33 Comments
4 1999

They should make a Disneyland 1999 movie

I had a dream about this being a movie
Cast: Me, Chris Pratt and Tobin Bell as Mr. Bear (and my crush ) - oofoff

I think this could be a really amazing movie like say if they make it like a documentary, from the main characters point of view, and throw snip its of the episodes from the shows when called for. It would be way better then another damn Slender Man movie I mean come on, one is already coming out this year. And Jeff the Killer... really what would you do with it, although smile dog is a kinda good idea because, "Chain Mail" and "Unfriended" type movies are kinda cool and not very like, known we could use a few more of them.

This could be played out like True Detective and Silence of the Lambs, with a much more dark and menacing theme that would feel like you are alone. - Drewstar

V 13 Comments
5 Eyeless Jack Eyeless Jack

I think it would be a really interesting to see how E.J. became what he is now

Yass I would watch this 10 times a day

Defiantly eyeless his backstories interesting

His character is amazing itself, a movie would be breathtaking but in my own opinion I think that we should make a movie where we see them all. All of their stories together or maybe the creepy pasta club. It should be a funny/romance/horror and action

V 22 Comments
6 The Russian Sleep Experiment

Lucky for you guys, one has already been made. It's pretty good.

This would make such a good movie. I would definitely watch it if it was ever made.

I Might be making this into a short film at my school. We will need a lot of fake gory props.

If this was made into a film it would be one of the best and scariest movies of all time

V 18 Comments
7 BEN Drowned

It will be amazing as Ben drowned in the movie but I think there is already a movie of him because he is a antichrist

I love ben drowned

BENs' story as a movie would be interesting because we don't know how he drowned. His story could go two ways, a young boy with abusive parents who gets a 64 and Majoras' Mask as a gift from his grandfather to help get his mind off things but is later drowned in the tub by a drunken mom/dad. Or normal family situation normal life and BEN accidentally drowns either in the tub from slipping or drowns at the beach/pool and is just trying to explain to whomever picks up his game how he died.

This would make a great movie. It was so scary and one of the most believable stories ever on Creepypasta. Also... I think that they should make a movie with the RAKE, too

V 19 Comments
8 Candle Cove

At least they have a T.V. series. - Persephone_Hell666

There is a show about it on Channel Zero

Got to love the show

Well, they could easily pull this off. If they got some good actors, and good props, and made it well, the movie would definitely be watched.

V 4 Comments
9 The Rake The Rake

The rake is completely terrifying and it would be a great horror film where a group of teens go into the woods thinking he's some dumb creepy pasta then they find out he's real and tries to beat it (but of course all the teens die and the rake wins)

Okay, I'll admit it, I'm a HUGE Ben Drowned fan. But I don't think think things like BEN or Smile dog would make good movies. Smile dog doesn't have enough to work off of for a movie, BEN already has creepy game plays, and you would need Nintendo's permission, and Jeff is super overrated. The Rake would scare me to death in a film.

... Who needs sleep anyway? I would love to see his (? ) story as a movie. So far thy have many documentaries on this guy (? ). My teacher showed us one for Halloween... I didn't know what we were watching until someone said the Rake.

This Must Come To Be

V 7 Comments
10 Laughing Jack Laughing Jack

He's my favorite creepy pasta. I would love him in a movie!

I must have this. - Persephone_Hell666

I've seen a pretend trailer by the creator of Laughing Jack, and I have to say that it would be neat to have a movie. I would so watch it. I love Laughing Jack!

This would make an amazing movie. It would bring horror, gore and maybe some sick humor together to make an interesting movie. Tim Burton would be great for a movie like this

V 17 Comments

The Contenders

11 Ticci Toby Ticci Toby

Here's the basic origin:

Toby grew up with several mental disorders during his childhood, making it difficult for him to fit in with "normal people". He was constantly bullied by his classmates for his tics and was ultimately deemed unsuited for a public school surrounding, so he switched to homeschooling. While he received plenty of support from his mother and older sister Lyra, his father was nothing but a negative influence on his son. Having lost himself to alcohol, drugs and gambling, Toby's father became increasingly abusive towards his family, especially Toby.

When Toby was seventeen, he and his sister were involved in a tragic car accident that resulted in Lyra's death. Toby's symptoms worsened greatly because of this; he lost his appetite for food, became even less social than before, and slowly began to lose his memories. On the night he returned from the hospital, Toby saw the Slender Man watching him from the street. Slender Man repeatedly stalked ...more

I think this would be a amazing film because his story is just so cool I could so see this as a film plus he is the BEST

I really want to see this happen. I just got into Creepypasta and really love Toby's story. Maybe they could throw something in about him meeting Clockwork as well? (Clockwork is another Creepypasta, who's creator and Toby's creator have been working together to make them into a canon relationship) - OpalEssence

He's the only one that I can personally see being made into a movie even if you cut out the non-canon being one of Slenderman's proxies the movie would be amazing.

V 27 Comments
12 NoEnd House

This I can actually agree with unlike Jeff or eyeless this is ACTUALLY SCARY

I pictured this as a movie the entire time I read it anyway, and it would be so cool. Just the feeling of dread and no hope the entire time you watch it, hopefully would be just as strong as when I was reading this CP. Yes the ending is slightly predictable, hence the name, but this was an amazing creepypasta nonetheless. If this was made into a movie, I would most definitely watch it.

When I read it I imagined it as a movie. It perfectly bleands a good story that is not too heavy on cliches and gore which could be favorable with the critics. Is premise is simple, yet unique and I would love to see this as a movie.

Yes they could make it like "Horrid Henry" imagining your in the house, creepy!

V 7 Comments
13 The Strangest Security Tape I've Ever Seen

Would be a great short films or Sundance movie but not sure if it could be too long before people realize whats happening or get bored. but definitely this.

I can see it being made by a fan like a fan film not a really big production like warner bros or something like that lol

I just read the story, it was weird and scary, so it should be made into a movie

I would fall in love with this all over again

V 6 Comments
14 Abandoned by Disney

Yes... just yes!

I would think of it kinda like a “Blair Witch Project” type movie - oofoff

This movie would most likely be a documentary.

This would put Disney out of business! Do it! Haha just kidding it would be a good movie

V 6 Comments
15 Penpal

I love this creepy pasta so mutch

I swear this would be the first horror movie that would scare me since this was one of the first creepypasta that made me both scared and curious it would be awesome if directed by someone talented like Wes craven or something

I would do 1,000 jumping jacks on hot coals with 300-pound weights hanging from my testicles to maybe, just MAYBE, get to see a film adaptation of Penpal.

It's so much better than the teen trash like slender and jeff. Its written (incredibly) well and long enough for a movie and its horror is a lot more subtle. It would also be very low budget

V 6 Comments
16 BooTube

It would be great to have a movie

What even is this one

17 The Seed Eater

I can't think about a scarier movie than a thing eating children yes

I love this one! It may seem really, you do not this made into a movie. Really, trust me it made me wet myself from scaredness and I never got sleep for nearly 3 months now

Get it? Children, seeds, both youngsters?

Peter Peter seed eater, he eats children!

V 5 Comments
18 The Ronald McDonald House

Please make a movie of this!

The story is a 10 year old boy that go's crazy

I love this story so much... Same with Russian Sleep experement and Candle Cove though... AND the Rake! - MoldySock

The Ronald McDonald house is a terefying idea. The process of filming it would be amzing and epic. I couldn't think of a better creepy pasta to be made into a film.

V 1 Comment
19 Play With Me

Must have this. - Persephone_Hell666

Sally is awesome and movies of scary little girls sell good

Sally and Chucky would make good friends

Good idea not being sarcastic

V 1 Comment
20 The Killswitch Experiment

Also known as "kagome kagome" this Nazi based experiment/ghost story is truly terrifying look into the world of immortality.

I am filming an ameature lost footage style film based on this story.

21 Where Bad Kids Go

It would be cool and I agree too it would probably feature the song "where do all the good boys go? " by Daya

Yes, this one would be AMAZING!

It would get kids to behave!

Agreed

V 2 Comments
22 Robert the Doll

No. Just no... This guy gives me shivers when I look at dolls. Plus there is already a movie made about him.

Weird thing is, this one is in a musiem... or so they say

23 The Cell Phone Game

Really practical for a movie

Would be awesome as a movie

24 Lost Episode Compilation

A compilation of either accurately reconstructed lost episodes of cartoons or shows the FREAKED us out or a documentary styled film that views these and an investigation starts to find the freak responsible for them. Dramatizing to children's psyche. The perfect sick crime.

-Squidward's Suicide
-SpongeBob Bootleg Episode
-Dead Bart
-Max & Ruby 0004
-Ed, Edd, n Eddy: Lost Episode

25 Polybius

Polybius could be made similar to Jacob's Ladder

26 Zalgo Zalgo

Why do I like the idea of this so much - OpalEssence

We make a Zalgo movie there goes the world

I could see this as something way diffrent where it is like a Zalgo v slender man and his proxies and Zalgo is just wanting to be a good guy even though he is a demon

yep

27 The Expressionless

Maybe a sequel that could show the expressionless as a virus spreading rampant through a city

Just, read it. All I can say. It could possibly be in black and white?

YES!

Love this one

Reminds me of a mental institution

28 Psychosis

Come on guys! This would be amazing! All the suspension leading up to the big revelation? The creepy atmosphere? And the viewer gets to figure it out as the film plays along! It would be awesome!

Omgeee yes this needs to happens Psychosis is my favorite creepypasta

29 Sonic.Exe

NOPE with a extra side of NOPE - OnlyInDreams

I would wet myself within the opening seconds of the commercial/teaser

The movie will be about sonic dying and egg man puts a spell on him making him kill every one in till they named him sonic Exe and then hide but one died so they rocket lanched a cannon of stopped the spell.

It should be a movie because of how great the creepypasta actually is

V 3 Comments
30 Masky and Hoody

Yes well they made marble hornets but I could see them like a origin story broke Into how they both met slender and then a proxy movie

Marble hornets is kinda like a movie so if you haven't seen it look it up on YouTube

The proxies are my favourite creepypastas ever this should so be a movie!

Being they already made marble hornets. But I would love another.

V 3 Comments
31 SpongeBob Bootleg

Would probably be a short movie even with the story of it's founding included, but still a good movie - CommentandList

32 Clockwork

Personally, I really liked Clockwork's story! Her design/style is far from that of a Mary Sue, though her backstory could use a little work. My only real complaint is that some of the sensitive topics (Rape, child abuse etc) could've been handled better. 7/10 for the story.

I really would like to see the movie though, as like a spinoff of a Ticci Toby movie - OpalEssence

Honestly I can't stand clockwork. Hate the Toby x clockwork ship.

Why do people like this crap? The story was almost as bad as jeff the killer.

A great story with movie worthy drama

V 2 Comments
33 Don't Look Back
34 Candy Pop

At first I thought Candy Pop was a girl until I read the story and found out he's really a boy. - Ilovestephanie

I'm obsessed with jesters and clowns, so I must have Laughing Jack and want to have this. - Persephone_Hell666

Candy pop is my favorite creepypasta besides Ticci Toby. I just love how he/she gives out purple balloons so they can die or they just get nightmares forever so its die or have nightmares where your dyeing for the rest of your life

Why aren't their any comments for this? I love the creepy Clowns and Jesters type creepy stuff. Go team Candy Pop!

35 The Holders

This is an underrated idea. I can see an ongoing series revolving around the various quests the main characters have to go on in order to collect the various macguffins.

36 Anansi's Goatman

This would be an amazing idea. Think about it... A horror film that doesn't give too much away at first, but quickly amps up throughout as this little campsite quickly becomes terrorized by the Goatman. There could be a little more backstory and a little more of a build-up, and... Ugh, I'm gonna have a nosebleed. This needs to happen.

I'm an 18 year old guy and I cried blood... I can't bring myself to listen to it anymore. Definitely needs to be a movie

YESSS!
This story is just bloody brilliant in of itself
It deserves a lot more love than it gets

37 Borrasca

Probably the best, darkest, most well-written creepypasta ever created. The concept itself is so dark and unpredictable that I'm surprised no directors or producers up at Hollywood have considered making this into a movie. If you haven't read Borrasca, you will definitely not regret reading this fantastic story (although it's around 5-6 hours long in total.) After reading, your definition of what makes a creepypasta good will have completely changed. In Borrasca, what's scary isn't the supernatural, but the terrible, disgusting things humans are capable of doing. - Jedijonathan

38 Happy Appy

I always wanted to see an actual episode and for the movie, it will be essential.
Also, who wouldn't want to see that fight seen with the narrator and forenzik

It just has to be

39 The Rainbow Factory

This is one of my favorite creepypastas.

You should read it.

A Rainbow Factory movie would be awesome! I highly doubt any official Rainbow Factory movie would be made, though, because of the mature content(Swearing, blood), and I don't thing the owners of MLP would make something like that. It might happen on YouTube, like a fanmade thing, but other than that, I don't really see a Rainbow Factory movie coming out in theaters. It'd be cool, though.

40 Rap Rat

Creepy but would be worth watching on the big screen.

This should be called Rapping to the rat.

41 Cupcakes

I don't think it should be a movie. I think My Little Pony should get a little darker and do this for an episode. - Persephone_Hell666

Is that about pinkie pie?

I like the story but a movie of it would be crap

It could be a great movie

V 3 Comments
42 NES Godzilla

I just finished that pasta and oh my god if this was a movie just holy mother of god

Red needs to be in a movie.

Yes do this, THIS NEEDS TO HAPPEN!

43 Jane the Killer Jane the Killer Jane the killer is the main character of the creepypasta story Jane the Killer: The real Story. She is know to be a rival to the creepypasta Jeff the Killer.

Seriously, JANE HATES JEFF FOR WHAT HE DID! DO NOT put Jeff and Jane together in a film especially not as a ship. If you have Jeff and Jane in a movie together it should be as a brother and sister sort of thing (See: Needles and Smiles Mr. Betty Krueger on YouTube! ) or as morbid enemies!

No. I don't think I even have to explain why this is a bad idea.

This should be combined with Jeff the killer since Jeff's story is kind of short for a movie

Mix her with Jeff
Or better yet Her, Sally and Jeff

44 Homicidal Liu

It would be a good like twist final battle at the end of Jeff the killer but I couldn't see this as a movie so I would have to pass on this one

This one is very dramatic and has an awesome story line.

It can also be mixed in with Jeff the Killer.

No no no if they made jeff the kiler in this film need to be and his brother!

V 2 Comments
45 Tails Doll

This would ruin Sonic on T.V. forever for me.

NOPE! Sonic.EXE already ruined sonic for me so please I would like to hear no more of the tails doll

NOPE

This one would be sort of tied in with Sonic. Exe, but with the setting taking place on mobilus and then the real world. Also, it could involve the seven pure souls either being the first one movie, or a mini-series show. And maybe, he could get his own saturday cartoons! YEAHHH!
Tails Doll: I'd like that.

46 Pokemon

Well, they could make a movie about ash visiting kanto and getting stuck in lavender town.

Okay, for this they could make one about buried alive, lost silver, snow on MT silver Pokémon Dead Channel creepy black or escape from lavender town

47 Murdershy
48 Radiation's Halloween Hack (Earthbound)
49 Mr. Bear
50 Fuzzy
8Load More
PSearch List

Related Lists

Top 10 Sonic Characters That Should Be Made Into Exe Creepypastas Video Games That Should Be Made Into Movies Books That Should Be Made Into Movies Call of Duty Games That Should Be Made Into Movies Video Game Series That Should Be Made Into a Movie Series

List Stats

800 votes
65 listings
5 years, 343 days old

Top Remixes (8)

1. The Smile Dog
2. Jeff the Killer
3. Eyeless Jack
lolfmn13
1. The Smile Dog
2. Slender Man
3. The Rake
Horrible_Username
1. BEN Drowned
2. Candle Cove
3. Jeff the Killer
Unknowntohumans

WRemix
View All 8

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.
P