Top Ten Dumbest Warrior Cats

This is a list of really dumb warriors/Medicine cats/Leaders/Queens/Whatever else. This list if not about personality or anything, just how dumb they are

The Top Ten

1 Hollyleaf Hollyleaf Hollyleaf was one of the rare, strictly loyal cats of ThunderClan. She cherished the warrior code as a kit and came back to her clan in a time of need to fight-- even though she was cast out for killing Ashfur.

It was kind of stupid for her To kill Ashfur, but he was EVIL!

She tried to kill your mother. Hollyleaf that's a big crime. She also killed Ashfur. She tries to kill cats out of fury and anger

Hollyleaf is just plain old dumb

Hollyleaf was and still is one of my favorites. Have you ever thought that maby she killed Ashfur because he tried to kill her.

2 Silverstream Silverstream

This should be number 1 - Murphypaw

Mainly due to her being an idiot as in; Y'know, FORBIDDEN LOVE. She deserved her death; She was an idiot and sincerely, chose that path. So what if she's beautiful and Graystripe loved her? She's still the stupid cat that chose Forbidden Love as her guide in life.

Added with the fact that these stupid FANARTS of her. They make her look like Edgestream. Just look at the picture of her with those bangs? WHY DO CATS HAVE BANGS?!

Now, of course the above paragraph is mostly about her fandom, but really? Also, Fun Fact: Whenever you comment on one, YOU VOTE FOR IT SO don't GO COMMENTING TO SAY YOU LIKE HER!

Overrated cat and annoying

Silverstream is awesome, - Aquastar_of_DewClan

3 Tigerstar Tigerstar Tigerstar is a villain in the Warriors series by Erin Hunter. Son of Leopardfoot and Pinestar, former mate of Goldenflower and Sasha, and father of Bramblestar, Tawnypelt, Mothwing, Hawkfrost, and Tadpole. This brown tabby cat almost causes the downfall of the clans. But is killed, firstly by Scourge, more.

He caused his own demise... It's not just him he's letting down, it's EVERY CAT that he's let down. Killing machine.

He was actually pretty smart. - RoseWeasley

Tigerstar deserves to be #1 on the list. Actually, Darkstripe should. Tigerstar would be #2. But Hollyleaf and Silverstream should not be on this list!

Tigerstar had lots of problems and I think the Dark Forest isn't a place he should be in. He should be IN NO PLACE AT ALL.

4 Foxheart

She is a TOTAL smug jerk

Foxheart really is a fox-heart. She knew Yellowfang was in love with Raggedpelt and she was just jealous.

5 Clear Sky Clear Sky

Disowned son twice I hate you

Clear Sky ist awesome! But methinks that is just my flavoured opinion.

Skystar/Clear Sky was doing what was right in his own eyes. I think it's great to stand up for oneself. In his eyes, Gray Wing was the reason that so many cats died. - Whitesplash

Just blah. Clear Sky is a hunk of Crap. Crap Sky!
He thinks he can take tiny kits out into the forest and make them fight without any training! And he doesn't want his own son. He's a jerk and I don't know what the heck his clanmates were thinking when they joined him. One of the worst leaders ever.
He's really stupid

6 Turtle Tail
7 Dovewing Dovewing Dovewing is a character in the Warriors series by Erin Hunter. She has light grey fur with Amber, green, or blue eyes. Her first appearance is in the fourth arc, know as Omen of the Stars, in the book The Fourth Apprentice. She was part of the Power of Three, and her power was to hear and see things more.

I honestly can not believe that Holly is first... It should be stupid Dovewing

She sucks and I don't see why anyone would think firestar sucks! Firestar is amazing and have u ever thought why everyone likes him? Ever thought that he's the MAIN CHARACTER? Hm? EVER THOUGHT ABOUT THAT AND THAT MIGHT BE THE REASON he's "OVERRATED" IF ANYONE IS OVERRATED ITS DOVEWING AND STUPID MAPLESHADE!

She's dumb. Ivypool was spying on the Dark Forest, she could've died, but Dovewing's like. Oh yea, I'll be mates with him, reject him, and go with anither tom. What's next, more toms she wants to reject, but first have kits with? She left her clan, which she was born and raised in, like really? I'd rather go with Bumblestripe. He loved her and Tigerheart preferred his clan to be honest. He only went with her because the kits, to be honest, in my opinion.

I don't agree with all of Firestar's decisions, but he most certainly isn't the dumbest cat. Dovewing should be the first cat on this list for the sake of how whiny and helpless she acts. She whines about how awful it is to have a power and talks trash about poor Hollyleaf a few times. Dovewing even knowingly falls in love with a cat from another clan.God, she's annoying and dumb.

8 Firestar Firestar Firestar is a character in the Warrior Cats series. He's the leader of ThunderClan after Bluestar. He's mates with Sandstorm and has 2 kits: Squirrelflight and Leafpool. He was formerly a kittypet named Rusty.

This isn't very nice. I mean, Firestar may have made mistakes, but he's not THIS bad. - Firefan

He can be a bit dumb sometimes like the Bambleclaw thing it was just odd and bit out of character because he is smart in the first series

They're acting like he leads every single Clan! He's nowhere near the best leader (that award goes to Bluestar) and he is completely weird! It is not normal for a regular cat to be attracted to dead cats who faded away and moved on! FiretoastFireface is bad! He's just a leader who has some kits that really don't mean anything special to the universe. I was so ticked off that I abandoned my books and gave them to my cousin to keep when Firepoop was the fourth cat. Seriously.

He is so overrated, and he brings loners, rogues, and kittypets into the clan. He is also a gary stu, the perfect cat that lived. He is so overpowered and every single cat must bow down to him. Bluestar shouldn't of went to protect such an annoying cat. But then again, no Firestar, no The Power of Three Series. Squirrelpaw would of probably been replaced by another apprentice, or no other apprentice would of came. Maybe The Dark Forest Battle wouldn't of happened, but if it did, the dark forest would rule over the world.

9 Leafpool Leafpool Leafpool is a character in the Warrior Cats series. She's the daughter of Firestar and Sandstorm, sister of Squirrelflight, mate of Crowfeather, and mother of Jayfeather, Lionblaze, and Hollyleaf

She basically ruined Squirrelflight's relationship with Brambleclaw, by mating with stupid Crowfeather, and Squirrelflight, however was just being a good sister, and covered up the lie by raising Hollyleaf, Jayfeather, and Lionblaze. I sort of hate Leafpool for ruin everybody's life. But mostly Squirrelflight's life. Leafpool should have just held her toungue, and stuck to the warrior code. STUPIDEST MEDICINE CAT.

When she married Crowfeather, she ruined everything for the other cats. Squirrelflight needed to tell a lie to cover it up, and it also ruined Hollyleaf's life. - Oliveleaf

Thinking that mating with Crowfeather is not going to do anything. And, she ran away from her clan, then lied to her kits and her clan.


10 Redwillow

The Contenders

11 Lionblaze Lionblaze Lionblaze is a character in the Warrior Cats series. He is part of The Three, along with Jayfeather and Dovewing, and has the power of being undefeated in battle. However, the power if removed from him after the Clans are saved from the Dark Forest.

Are you kidding?! Just because he's a good fighter does not mean he is bad.

Lionblaze doesn't want to be powerful so why not give Hollyleaf this power or something? Let Lionblaze have that cut to the throat by Hawkfrost (AKA Dorkfrost)

I find them out really stupid

He. Is. Stupid. And. Needs. To. Die.

12 Mothwing Mothwing


13 Daisy

I hate daisy she is a dumb idiot

She shouldn't be in Thunderclan. And that training secession with Cloudtail? But My kits really like you! You didn't warn me that you were going to knock me over!
And she wastes all her time in the nursery! We're good with Ferncloud and Dustpelt, you know! We don't need your kits to be depressed because they barely had a fathering figure! She doesn't get the hint that Spiderleg hates her. Dumb, Idiotic, Daisy.

SHE DOES NOTHING EXCEPT WASTE PREY AND TIME.Oh and by the way dumb means can't talk so none of these are dumb just stupid.Just saying also millie is a good warrior stop grudging silverstream is a brat

I hate her!

14 Millie Millie Millie is a character in the Warriors series. She's a small, short-furred light gray tabby with blue eyes and a torn ear. Also current mate of Graystripe and mother of Bumblestripe, Blossomfall and Briarlight.


Millie *sigh* How much more do we have to hear of her? She is too annoying. She stole Graystripe's love. And she's so fussy!

50% stupid, annoying, whiney 50% nice, kind, good mother

She picks favorites. She's a dumb cat. She was okay at the beginning, But any good parent knows not to pick favorites. Millie is not a good parent. And she's really dumb. And she doesn't quite realize that she's Graystripe's replacement Silverstream.
No more to say about her.

15 Rainflower Rainflower

Did you know that she hated Crookedstar but,at the nine lives ceremony for Crookedstar she still wanted to give him a life. I think she has gotten over the fact that he twisted his jaw. Sadly, the Starclan residents decided she should just watch.

I don't believe she deserves to be here. Yes, she made mistakes, but I'm quite sure she's aware of it. She knew it was her fault that Crookedstar twisted his jaw. She encouraged him. But she wasn't strong enough to accept that she was responsible for such a horrible thing. She renamed him to help herself believe he was a different cat. That this cat with an injury wasn't her son and it wasn't her fault that he had that injury. She was protecting herself, which yes was a bit selfish, for a good reason. Then Crookedstar climbs the tree and she tells him to stop showing off, but this is because she doesn't want him to be injured worse than he already had been. She couldn't change his name again to pretend that she couldn't have helped him. I think she was a good cat, but just a bit selfish. - Whitesplash

Worst. mother. ever! I feel so bad for Crookedstar. Rainflower is like: OH MY GOD! MY SON'S FACE! He IS SO UGLY! It is the end of the world! Hmm... I still have Oakkit. He'll stay with me in our nest. I hated it when she thought about letting Crookedkit have his own nest. "Still, you should still have your own nest because I don't want Oakkit waking up because of your injury." Dumbest excuse ever. I'm glad Shellheart broke up with her; she doesn't deserve a mate - HollyleafOfThunderClan

She should be below Dovewing and above Firestar... - Aquastar_of_DewClan

16 Spottedleaf Spottedleaf

Sure, Spotted is SUPER pretty, but Sandstorm is prettier on the inside. She's a irrelevant Mary-sue and has this annoying sweet scent around her every time. Spottedleaf just can't take a hint that Firestar loves his mate more than her. Come on! A blind rabbit could see how close Sandstorm and Firestar is, they were made for each other!

I'm sorry but I think I'll have to agree - HollyleafOfThunderClan

She's everywhere which is really annoying and makes her a Mary Sue.

17 Nightcloud Nightcloud

She all like, "Oh, Crowfeather! I love you so much! Let's have kits to express our love! " And Crowfeather is just all like " Whatever. Get away from me, creep"
She cannot take the hint!
( Has anyone else noticed that the cover for The Apprentice's quest looks just like that piece of fan art with Crowfeather walking away from Nightcloud and She saying ' Why won't you love me? '? )
She isn't taking the hint all to well. But when she finally gets it, she decides that she going to raise their son to hate him. She's very nice, Crowfeather, don't you think? Oh, wait, you're still thinking about Leafpool, aren't you?

So true, the top 4 are awesome. Nightcloud be like ''Oh Crowfeather! I love you, don't you love me? Why don't you love me my Crowyfeather? ''

18 Ashfur Ashfur

I hate this guy! He is not misunderstood just a sore looser! Squirrelflight is way too good for him anyway! Well, she's way to good for bramblestar too! - girly-dog-girl

His only mistake was that he loved squirrelflight to much. At first, squirrelflight was in a quarrel with Bramblestar. Ashfur snatched her heart, then squirrelflight loved bramblestar again and ashfur got jealous.

He wasn't that dumb. The only thing dumb about him were his thinkings. If it weren't for his anger issues, Squirrelflight would be dead, and HE would be deputy

I hate him. He is just so dumb. - AnonymousChick

19 Fuzz

Oh yes, so dumb, when he calls Barley all of those things, oh sweety, he wouldn't survive in the wild for a second! - CreamstripeOfButterClan

Yes he's dumb

Yes, he is so dumb (I don't think any of the cats above are dumb, just people don't like their choices

He's annoying.

1 Comment
20 Blue star Blue star Bluestar is a character in the Warrior Cats series. She was one of the leaders of ThunderClan. She is mates with Oakheart of RiverClan and her kits, Stonefur and Mistyfoot, live in RiverClan. She has a deceased kit named Mosskit, a sister named Snowfur, a nephew named Whitestorm, a mother named Moonflower more.

Yes, it is not so smart to choose only one warrior when you need them, it is not smart give poor Brightpaw ugliuest name in history of Warrior Cats, hate almost every cat in your OWN clan and start a war betwen you and StarClan. She is just stupid.

Are you kidding me? She made mistakes, but everyone does? I suppose you're God himself/herself? - Firefan

She stoopid

21 Appledusk Appledusk Appledusk is a RiverClan cat who was formally mates with Mapleshade (ThunderClan) which broke the warrior code. Later he took a mate—Reedshine and had kits with her.

Appledusk is very stupid but so is Mapleshade


I agree he’s a meanie

He blames things on Mapleshade and expects nothing to happen after he ruins her life. He didn't even say sorry.

22 Brightheart Brightheart

Why is she on here? She really didn't do anything! And it's not HER fault she got attacked by the pack! - Firefan

Why is Brightheart on this list? - IcetailofWishClan

I love her why is she on the list

This cats awesome.It's a really big mistake putting her here.

23 Mosskit Mosskit

She's not dumb! The evil brat who put her on here!

Have she lived enough for you to call her dump? She Didn't deserved to be on this list. - cassiabez

We you don't even know her you silly!

Mosskit died form the cold

24 Darkstripe Darkstripe

I like Darkstripe. He's hot.


25 Jessy


I don’t like how Jessy hangs out with Bramblestar, he says he could have loved her but he would have stayed with Squirreflight anyways. Plus Squirrelflight was expecting! Why would he abandon Squirrelflight to go with Jessy?! Brambleclaw/star barely knew Jessy and he knew Squirrelflight since she was KIT. I don’t like Jessy. But if she comes back and joins Thunderclan, I hope Bramblestar shows NO LOVE to her and Jessy dies in Thunderclan. TC IS BETTER OFF WITHOUT JESSY UGH

26 Mottlepelt

Eh...I don't know what to say about him

27 Ivypool Ivypool
28 Goosefeather Goosefeather

"weLL AS YOU CAN SEE I am achieving prophecies daily even though it is quite obvious that prophecies are rare/not very common but GUESS WHAT? This vole here this vole man It's telling me something I think we have to attack Windclan to result in Moonflower's death. CAUSE I'M A MEDICINE CAT NOTHING I DO CAN GO WRONG! Also I should have watched Snowkit more with those Poppy Seeds."

I get so many prophecies, and I understand them all so well! I chased Stormkit away so he broke his jaw in the gorge, oh my goodness, that vole is saying we have to fight Windclan and ruin their herbs. Moonflower is dead, but that's not my fault.

I hate you!

I quite like Goosefeather for some reason. Maybe it’s because he reminds me of my BFF (well, not really, but she’s always like “oh, look! That could be a sign! ” Not to make fun of her, but...). But the only reason I voted for him was.... Hmmm...
BECAUSE OF HIS WHOLE LIFE! When I looked on this list I expected “1. Goosefeather. 2. Dovewing (I hate her. She’s first not second though...) 3. Ummm... Daisy? ” Also, Millie’s better than Silverstream just saying. Wait, how did that get in here? Well, I was going to vote this, Dovewing or Jessy. Soz if this offends!

29 Lizardtail

Oh Lizardtail, If it weren't for you, Brokenstar would not be such a psycopath. If you weren't so abusive, Brokenstar would be a good cat

Um it's Lizardstripe you know...

Real name- Lizardstripe.

30 Stubbornkit

This isent even a cat..

Rainflower's second choice: rename graykit stubbornkit for going in ThunderClan when told not to and coming back with a torn ear tip - HollyleafOfThunderClan

31 Brambleberry
32 Ivystep
33 Frecklewish

She doesn't save Mapleshade's kits and partially ruins Mapleshade's life (Appledusk, Ravenwing, and Oakstar doing the other parts.) Then she expects Mapleshade to save her from an adder. She reminds me of a hyporitic fourth grader. Also anyone named Frecklewish would automatically seem dumb.

34 Hawkfrost Hawkfrost

He should be higher! He manipulated Brambleclaw and tried to kill Firestar! For those Firestar haters out there: Firestar isn't stupid. He just made mistakes, but we all do! I suppose you're little miss/mister perfect? - Firefan

Hawkfrost joined his father in the Dark forest just for power. He could have lived a long loyal life in riverclan BUT NO! He followed his father and tried to kill firestar! He also did many bad things

He listened to his con artist Father! If he hadn’t been so stupid and try to take over he would be a good leader. And side note FIRESTAR IS NOT STUPID.

35 Squrellflight (Squirellstar)

I don't think she should be on this list, but she should have tried to understand Brambleclaw. - Firefan

I have to agree I hate her and she new the aware of ruining her relation ship and just how is leafpool way higher? oh lol 46 is squirelflight star she should not be a leader and 47 is squirelflight

Okay, this cat is extremely stupid and definitely deserves to be on this list. In the second series she treats Brambleclaw like a total loser and then wonders why he won't talk to her anymore. To also support my point, she hangs out with Ashfur all the time and still doesn't know why Brambleclaw ignores her. She may just be the dumbest warrior cat ever.

She’s not stupid or dumb. I’ll give a bunch of reasons. As an apprentice, yes she was annoying and rude but she developed and grew into a kinder cat. Since Brambleclaw was ignoring her, she became friends with Ashfur. She was friends wit Ashfur because she wanted someone to talk to or even have a FRIEND, since Brambleclaw was being a jerk to her at the time. But Ashfur wanted to be more then friends even when Squirrelflight told him nicely that she doesn’t want to his mate. Ugh.

36 Squirrelflight Squirrelflight

Wait mosskit is above her...

She was annoying and a nuisance to brambleclaw. She broke ashfurs heart. She hurt lionblaze, jayfeather and Hollyleaf. She is rude to her father. She is one of the meanest, dumbest and most annoying cats. But, she did do lots of good things for the clan and she gets much better.

Ash fur was a jerk and maniac, THE END. - Blazingfeatherofsummerclan

Ashfur DID NOT understand when Squirrelflight told him she just wants to stay friends and not become mates. Plus there were SO MANY other she cats in the clan. But apparently to Ashfur Squirrelflight was the only she cat in the world. I think it’s Crowfeather’s fault for taking Leafpool away.

37 Thistleclaw Thistleclaw
38 Emeraldtwoleg

Wow...just wow...

1. Mated with the son of a cat he bullied
2. Made everyone assume he was gay JUST because he died his tail rainbow
3. Killed the Stoneteller, became Stoneteller, and the amedatly lef the tribe
4. Bullied Jays wing
5. Mated with a badger
6. Sent Mapleshade to the dark forest
7. Mated with a kit
8. Told the entire clan about Graystripe and silverstream
9. Mated with a kit (AGAIN)
10. Stole Sandstorm from firestar
11. Ate the entire herb supply ( I knew I was starving but still)
12. Killed Bumblestripe and Tigerheart
AnD tHe LiSt GoEs On AnD oN aNd On. I wonder what happened to his brain.
~mistpool of thunderclan

39 Swiftpaw Swiftpaw

He didn't know what was stealing the prey so technically he wasnt being dumb when he went to fight th edogs

40 Gorseheart
41 Cherrysun
42 Graywing
43 Leopardstar
44 Willowtail

I mean she was rude enough to lie to wind runner and tell her skyclan was stealing prey when it really was her! she was really the wosrt cat in moth flights vision she even had to chase redclaw up the tree I mean it was her fault micah had to die! also she started a war with skyclan and windclan for no reason there were only 5 medicine cats and millions of other cats to heal I mean after only after willowtail was blinded she told the truth about skyclan stealing prey it was actually her! worst timing because u are officially dead! hahha t her!

45 Crowfeather

He is such a jerk to Squirrelpaw I wanna kill him. He always wants to be leader. He needs to die.

He’s just as crool as breezepelt. - Blazingfeatherofsummerclan

46 Breezepelt Breezepelt

Breezepelt attacks jay feather and I forgot who else and meant to harm a medicine cat:jayfeather. He makes me sick, he just wants to be the only and perfect kit, yuck! - Blazingfeatherofsummerclan

Breezepelt is jerk

Why do you hate your brother?

47 Mudclaw
48 Cloudkit

All he does is cause trouble, he is probably gonna end up like Cinderpaw

49 Heavystep
50 Sleekwhisker Sleekwhisker

I hate sleekwhisker! She acted like a queen was her bff and then kitnapped her kits and threatened them!

8Load More
PSearch List

Related Lists

Top Ten Warrior Cats Top Ten Warrior Cats Names That Do Not Exist Top Ten Saddest Warrior Cat Deaths Best Warrior Cat Characters (Book by Erin Hunter) Top Ten Warrior Cat Villains 

List Stats

200 votes
52 listings
4 years, 54 days old

Top Remixes

1. Hollyleaf
2. Tigerstar
3. Silverstream


Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.