Top 10 Most Forgettable WWE Superstars

The Top Ten
1 Mordecai Mordecai (a blue jay) is one of the two main protagonists of Regular Show, along with his best friend Rigby (a raccoon). He made his debut in the non-canon short ("2 in the AM PM") as a human cashier, who then morphs into a prototype Mordecai-like character with a fanny pack. He later makes his first official appearance in the Pilot episode. Mordecai is voiced by the show's creator, J.G. Quintel.

Dangit someone screwed up Mordecai from Regular Show's profile

2 Simon Dean Michael Bucci is an American semi-retired professional wrestler. Bucci is probably best known for his appearances in Extreme Championship Wrestling as Nova, Super Nova, and "Hollywood" Nova and World Wrestling Entertainment as Simon Dean.
3 Colin Delaney

Lost a whole lot of matches before finally getting a win over Armando Estrada to get a contract in ECW, later turned on mentor Tommy Dreamer and got the wholly hell beat out of him and got sent packing from WWE.

4 Phantasio
5 Daniel Puder

Won the 1 Million Dollar Tough Enough back in 2004, appeared only once in the 2005 Royal Rumble match and got the crap beat out of him he later turned down a contract for WWE making the Whole tough enough contest a total waste with the exception of the Miz the only former Tough Enough competitor to win the WWE Championship.

6 The Boogeyman
7 Deuce N Domino

They look like extras from the movie the Outsiders.

8 El Phantasmo

I meant to put Phantasio here but I had trouble remembering his name shows how forgotten he is.

9 Sylvester Turkay
10 AJ Lee April Jeanette "AJ" Brooks, better known by her ring name AJ Lee, is an American retired professional wrestler. Aj Lee started her professional wrestling career in 2009 where she spent 2 years in Florida Championship Wrestling. She debuted under the ring name of April Lee at FCW, until a few months later when she changed it to AJ Lee. Aj not only became the FCW Women’s Champion, she also was a 2 time Queen of FCW. She then moved on to participate in the 3rd season of WWE’s developmental branch, NXT. Aj’s pro that was assigned was former WWE superstar, Primo. Throughout the season of NXT, Aj developed a friendship with fellow competitor Kaitlyn. Unfortunately, Aj made it to the final 3 ...read more.

If we look at the women's divi sion now it's clear their all better than her she would have been more memorable but peoplkd already forgot she existed because of how much better women there are now their is literally zero chance of her ever returning as she moved on in life and is now very low key she is by far the most forgettable wrestler of all time to me

A tragic fall from grace. 5 years ago she was the face of the women's division. Then she retired and the only thing she has done since was make a book that nobody bought. I can't believe I even remember her since nobody else does. I hate her so much but her fall to obscurity is still very sad.

The Contenders
11 Vance Archer

The most underrated WWE superstar ever

12 Kevin Thorn Kevin Matthew Fertig is an American professional wrestler. He is best known for working with World Wrestling Entertainment under the ring names Mordecai and Kevin Thorn.
13 Kizarny Portrayed by professional wrestler Nick Cvjetkovich, Kizarny was a WWE character with a carnival freak show persona. Despite the unique and eerie gimmick, the character had a short-lived run and did not achieve significant success in WWE.
14 Nathan Jones Nathan Jones is an Australian actor, powerlifting champion, strongman and retired professional wrestler.
15 Sean O'Haire Sean Christopher Haire was an American professional wrestler, mixed martial artist and kickboxer, better known by his ring name, Sean O'Haire.
16 Marcus Cor Von
17 Elijah Burke Elijah Samuel Burke is an American professional wrestler and color commentator, currently signed to Total Nonstop Action Wrestling as a commentator under the ring name "The Pope" D'Angelo Dinero.
18 Tyler Reks Gabbi Tuft is an American retired professional wrestler. She is best known for her tenure with WWE under the ring name Tyler Reks. In 2021, she came out as transgender.
19 Gunner Scott

He beat Booker T once.

20 Luther Reigns
21 Orlando Jones
22 Dave Taylor
23 Brian Kendrick Brian David Kendrick is an American professional wrestler and promoter, currently signed to WWE, performing on the Raw brand, in the Cruiserweight division under the ring name The Brian Kendrick.
24 Paul London Paul Michael London is an American professional wrestler, best known for his time with WWE and NWA-TNA.
25 Paul Burchill
8Load More
PSearch List