Top 10 Games That Shouldn't Have a 90+ On Metacritic

The Top Ten
1 Undertale

Actually, contrary to popular belief, this game was more than deserving of its praise on Metacritic (maybe not perfect 10s halfway across the entire board, but still.)

It might not be the best game of all time...but honestly, it's pretty close at times.

2 The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

Another game that deserves its praise despite being ridiculously overrated.

I disagree. I adore this game and I can see why people think it’s the greatest video game of all time. It’s a fantastic adventure game with fantastic gameplay mechanics, a great story, and amazing music.

3 Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
4 Uncharted 2
5 The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time 3D
6 Metal Gear Solid 4
7 The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
8 Soulcalibur
9 The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
10 The Last of Us
The Contenders
11 Grand Theft Auto IV

How does a crime simulator make it on the 90% list let alone become the highest critically acclaimed game of all time.

12 NFL 2K1

It's beyond me why sports games get such high scores

13 Flipnote Studio

No longer avalable for download unless you download it's sequel for the 3ds, Flipnote Studio 3d through obtaining a code from My Nintendo.

14 Portal 2

I respectfully disagree. One of the greatest puzzle games of all time. Maybe the 2nd best behind Tetris.

15 Street Fighter IV
16 World of Goo
17 Civilization II
18 Civilization IV
19 Company of Heroes
20 World Soccer Winning Eleven 6 International
21 Rock Band 3
22 The Sims
23 Final Fantasy XII
24 Peggle
25 Halo: Reach
8Load More
PSearch List