Greatest Symphonies of All Timeplmilligan1968
The Contenders: Page 2
Leonard Bernstein's interpretation of this piece is absolutely phenomenal, truly Mahler's greatest work.
Mahler 5 is probably one of the greatest compositions of music ever. The emotion and truth and beauty embedded within the pieces is breathtaking. Mahler really knew how to put love and his life into his product. symphonies 1,2, and 5 are some of the best forms of art ever to be heard. Mahler knew how to reveal the tragedies and beauties in life so elegantly through his music.
The adagio is the most beautiful piece of music I have ever heard.
A massive dynamic emotional powerhouse!
It is curious that this symphony should not even make it into the top ten, as it is one of the most introspective, emotional, and passionate symphonies of all creation, beginning with the heartbeat of Mahler, continuing a sense of warmth throughout the Landler, a ruckus of violent chaos in the Rondo, and the famous release of the Adagio. That this symphony be so far neglected is criminal; surely it is the fault of being incomprehensible to the uninitiated that bars it from the popular appeal of a top ten list.
To criticize the work, especially, for being overlong is deliriously foolish; a single melodic line of thought is present throughout every movement, with every note contributing so fascinatingly and constructed so purely with objective view of emotion and sweetness in death. Perhaps only in the first movement there are moments of boredom, but even these moments are justified and necessary in the context of the whole; after every war comes a period of great prosperity and ...more
My personal favorite work of art. The finale is the most moving single movement in the repertoire. - mahlerialiszt
It's a sin not to include this piece in the top two. The opening notes of the last movement is beyond any human creation that have ever existed.
Best music everV 4 Comments
This incredible piece of music has a depth, drama and beauty that surpasses the greatest Shostakovich symphonies, and makes a mockery of all who calls Prokofiev a cynical an non-personal composer. The last minutes of the Adagio is one of the most heart-breakingly beautiful places in all orchestral music.
This symphony absolutely belongs to the very best and most wonderful symphonies of all time! Listen to the fantastic finale. It is one of the greatest highlights in history of music. Coda and reprise are unmatched and on the same level as the most tremendous finales of Anton Bruckner.
Absolute intensity throughout. Slightly folksy, but still majestic on a grand scale. Transitions effortlessly from the brooding to the triumphant.
The opening trumpet fanfare in the finale provides such a feeling of triumph and elegance, making the ending to a concert beyond spectacular.
Shapeless and weak despite its often strikingly original thematic material. The last movement is torture. Completely surpassed by the composer's Fifth. Life is too short.V 3 Comments
One of the really great symphonies.
Big and beautiful!
Big and strong like another 5th symphony we know,take a listen to the Sibelius 4th.
Number 1 for me - intensely moving
Simply the greatest piece of art ever created by a Han being. I would like to die listening to the fifth movement.
The builds and blends in and out of woodwind solos really do it for me.
I love nature, I love this symphony. Coincidence? I don't think so.V 9 Comments
Stunning masterpiece particularly the French horn movement and the finale, amazing vitality, before his death symphony no. 6V 2 Comments
I was extremely fortunate to be present at Bernard Haitink's recent Proms performance at the Albert Hall. To see this work live was to behold a wondrous miracle. The diversity & inspiration of the composition show what an inspired composer Mahler was. The first movement is a multidimentional symphony in itself. The addition of a boys choir in the 5th movement lightens the intensity of the other movements. A must see at least once in your lifetime.
I played the finale of this symphony in the 8th grade, so I have a special place in my heart for it. - higgsboson2142V 1 Comment
One of the greatest symphonies of all time. As I get older I found out the greatness in this work, not when I was younger. Cannot believe Schubert in his mid twenties, can compose such a work - the 2nd movement, in a different world!
Surprised to see this down here. This is one of the greatest Symphonic masterpieces ever written.
Comes from another dimension. How Schubert thought it up defies my comprehension.
Special... Even with only two movements, but it sounds perfect and beautiful
This symphony is really great and wonderful. It is probably the most Important milestone, that was directly leading to the fantastic symphonies of Anton Bruckner.
Ah, Schubert, the master of the melodic symphony. What a brilliant piece of music. Should be higher up on the list.
This has got to be the most underrated symphony on the entire list.
Have always loved its wide romantic verve
A big Russian boisterous sounding symphony. - plmilligan1968
This symphony is actually easy to listen to, and has some great music.
Beautiful opening; uncharacteristic Schubertian slow movement, famous hotn call in the scherzo and a stunning final movement coda that only conductor Celibidache interpreted as a vision of entering into Heaven. Truly Spiritual.
A real wonder. I love Schubert, Beethoven and others' symphonies, but Saint-Saens' work is the one I can listen to again and again with always the same admiration
This symphony is powerful and moving and works both at an intellectual level and an emotional level. Most satisfying.
A very under played and under rated symphonic work but its truly awesome. - plmilligan1968
I am never tired of listening to this extraordinary masterpieceV 3 Comments
Light hearted and cheerful themes run through this wonderful symphonic work. - plmilligan1968
Totally can tell what perspective he was writng it from
Folklore based on Prague
Related ListsTop 10 Mahler Symphonies Best Songs On Carcass's Symphonies of Sickness Best Silly Symphonies Best Songs From Leaves' Eyes Symphonies of the Night Top 10 Best Songs on Lucifer's Heritage Symphonies of Doom
9 years, 185 days old
Top Remixes (10)
2. Symphony No. 5 in D Minor, Op. 47 - Dmitri Shostakovich
3. Symphony No. 1 in D Major - Gustav Mahler
2. Symphony No. 2 in D Major, Op. 43 - Jean Sibelius
3. Beethoven's 9th (Choral) Symphony
2. Brahms Symphony No. 4
3. Dvorak's 9th (New World) Symphony
View All 10