Top 10 Guitarist Showdowns

IronSabbathPriest

The Top Ten

1 John Petrucci vs Kirk Hammet

Hammet is good, but when it comes to songwriting and long, complex solos, Petrucci easily wins. - IronSabbathPriest

John petrucci

2 Ritchie Blackmore vs. Tony Iommi

Ritchie wins - faster, more technical, more innovative. Some credits that belong to Ritchie are attached to Tony Iommi. - Metal_Treasure

3 Dimebag Darrel vs Marty Friedman

I'd like to see this battle! Sadly, Darrel is no longer with us. RIP Dime. - IronSabbathPriest

4 Jimmy Page vs Keith Richards

Two VERY influential guitarists in two of the most successful bands of all time. - IronSabbathPriest

5 Randy Rhoads vs Tony Iommi

Randy's awesome solos made Ozzy what he was back then! And if it wasn't for Iommi and his guitar, heavy metal wouldn't exist! - IronSabbathPriest

6 Adrian Smith vs Dave Murray

If you're an Iron Maiden fan, you have to like one or the other! I personally choose Smith. What's your opinion. - IronSabbathPriest

7 James Hetfield vs Dave Mustaine

The two had a falling out in the 80s and 90s. But they're best buddies again! And in two of the most successful thrash metal bands. M/ - IronSabbathPriest

8 Jimmy Page vs. Ritchie Blackmore

Ritchie Blackmore. Jimmy Page himself admitted that Ritchie was a step ahead. - Metal_Treasure

9 John Petrucci vs Yngwie Malmsteen
10 Ritchie Blackmore vs Robert Fripp

Ritchie Blackmore - his only competition was Jeff Beck. Ritchie Blackmore is criminally underrated - most of the credits that belong to him are attached either to Jimmy Page or Tony Iommi. - Metal_Treasure

Deep Purple and King Crimson... Two of the most underrated rock bands. SMOKE ON THE WATER! - IronSabbathPriest

The Contenders

11 David Gilmour vs Alex Lifeson

Both fantastic guitarists with great innovations and inspiration...but in terms of guitar playing skills I'd go with David Gilmour, the greatest emotion of rock history

Both are awesome. Solos beyond human understanding. Listen to Pink Floyds "Comfortably Numb" and Rush's "Limelight" to decide! - IronSabbathPriest

12 James Hetfield vs Jon Schaffer

I'd love to see this. Love them both, they are great rhythm guitarists. Don't know who's gonna win though... - Metal_Treasure

Jon's more articulate, plays tighter and has more stamina in his picking hand.
James has been at it longer and is tons more soulful and could fill in for Jon easily if he choose/had to. James is also a better lead player in a pinch.

13 Jeff Loomis vs John Petrucci
14 Marty Friedman vs Jeff Waters
15 Marty Friedman vs Jason Becker
16 Glenn Tipton vs Jeff Hanneman

If Hanneman was still alive, I would have definitely wanted to see this awesome battle! - IronSabbathPriest

17 Joe Satriani vs Steve Vai
18 Stevie Ray Vaughan vs Jimi Hendrix

Hendrix was the inovator while SRV improved Hendrix style. Overall I'd go with Hendrix.

19 Andres Segovia vs Django Reinhardt

In the non-rock world, Segovia [flamenco style] and Reinhardt [jazz style] are considered by far the best guitarists of all time.

20 "Fast" Eddie Clarke vs Synester Gates

I'm running out of ideas now. It's obvious who I'd want to win. As Motorhead are way better than Avenged Sevenfold. - IronSabbathPriest

21 Jimi Hendrix vs Eric Clapton
22 Eric Clapton vs. Duane Allman

This showdown actually happened, and luckily the recording equipment was running the whole time.
The result is the historic album "Layla, and Other Assorted Love Songs" by Derek & the Dominos.
Allman tragically died a relatively short time later.

23 Jimmy Page vs. Jeff Beck

This showdown did happen, and both guys were in the Yardbirds together for almost a year. Beck was the slightly stronger player, but Page had the much stronger personality, and eventually drove Beck out of the band, but not before making some of the most amazing music ever created as they tried to out-do each other.

Without a doubt - Jeff Beck. Jimmy Page is the most overrated guitarist and musician. - Metal_Treasure

24 Brad Delson vs. Ben Moody
25 Yngwie Malmsteen vs Michael Angelo Batio

Both of are one of the fastest shredders. Who is better?
I prefer Yngwie's style more but MAB gotta win. He is faster and works hard. While Yngwie repeats some of his licks in many songs. - zxm

26 Jason Becker vs Yngwie Malmsteen
27 Paul Gilbert vs Buckethead
BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Top 10 Rock Band Showdowns Top 10 Vocalist Showdowns Top 10 Drummer Showdowns Top 10 Bassist Showdowns Cartoon Network, Nickelodeon, and Disney Showdowns

List Stats

27 listings
3 years, 316 days old

Top Remixes

1. Ritchie Blackmore vs. Tony Iommi
2. Stevie Ray Vaughan vs Jimi Hendrix
3. Randy Rhoads vs Tony Iommi
zxm
1. John Petrucci vs Kirk Hammet
2. Dimebag Darrel vs Marty Friedman
3. Jimmy Page vs Keith Richards
IronSabbathPriest
1. Ritchie Blackmore vs. Tony Iommi
2. Jimmy Page vs. Ritchie Blackmore
3. John Petrucci vs Yngwie Malmsteen
Metal_Treasure

WRemix

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.
P