Top 10 Hardest Decisions Made in Telltale Games


The Contenders: Page 2

21 Minecraft: Story Mode - Who's the White Pumpkin?
22 Until Dawn: Kill Ashley or Josh
23 Tales from the Borderlands: Who to Choose for Your Squad in the Final Battle?
24 Walking Dead: A New Frontier: Shoot Conrad or Capture Clementine?

I really liked Conrad until he tried to shoot Clementine. I'm not gonna reveal which one I chose because it'll trigger a lot of people. - pokemonrater

This should be higher up - lukemcnamara72

25 The Walking Dead: A New Frontier: Make Peace with David or Fight Back?

This is in episode 5 and David starts attacking you for making out with Kate (his wife). He attacks you and each time you try to make peace, he attacks harder. This happens 3 times until someone else gets in the way. - lukemcnamara72

26 The Walking Dead: A New Frontier: Shoot Joan or Accept Clint's Deal?

After Joan (a mad lady who secretly orders raids to keep her community going) kills one of your group members, Clint tries to make it stop and harmlessly exile everyone else. This gives you an opportunity to shoot her. If you do, you cause everyone to fire guns. If you accept Clint's deal, David kills HIM and causes everyone to fire guns. - lukemcnamara72

27 The Wolf Among Us - Kill Georgie or Leave Him

Georgie is a cruel guy who was said to have killed two fables who worked with him (but we don't know if he was ordered to by his boss or not). He gets stabbed and is slowly dying. You can kill him quickly, or walk away and leave him to die slowly. There are multiple reasons on which choice you make. Maybe you kill him because you want to end his suffering. Maybe you're angry. Maybe you leave him because you want him to keep suffering. Maybe you don't want the blame. Maybe you want to be finished with killing people. - lukemcnamara72

28 Minecraft Story Mode: Accept or Decline Hadrian's Deal

In episode 8, Hadrian talks to you about how nobody ever wins his games and they end up being his slaves forever. He has your friends captured and tells you that he'll let all of your friends go if you stay as his slave or else he'll keep them all and you'll lose in the games. Everyone ends up free with a happy ending but they all find out what you said to him. - lukemcnamara72

29 The Walking Dead: Season Two - Shoot Walker Rebecca or Call for Help

In the end of episode 4, Rebecca dies from losing too much blood and while holding AJ. A group of other people who are trying to rob you point guns at everyone. Rebecca becomes a walker and is about to eat AJ. You (Clementine) can think fast or think carefully about disturbing everyone who will start shooting. This choice has almost no effect on this story, BUT in season 3 (A New Frontier) it affects Clem's personality about thinking fast or thinking carefully about outcomes. - lukemcnamara72

30 The Walking Dead: Save Ava or Save Tripp?

A) Joan betrays you
B) the other dies in the next episode
C) the REAL tough choice is whether or not to kill Joan - lukemcnamara72

31 Until Dawn: Shoot Ashley or Chris
32 Game of Thrones: Kill or Spare the Traitor
33 Minecraft Story Mode: Send Aiden Over the Edge or Leave Him There

This is hard because Aiden is a jerk and you have the chance to revenge him, but you don't want to stoop to his level.

You forgot taking him - lukemcnamara72

BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top 10 Hardest Decisions to Make About Certain Video Games Top Ten Lego Video Games That Should Be Made Hardest Video Games Video Games that Need to be Made Video Games That Should Be Made Into Movies

List Stats

200 votes
35 listings
1 year, 13 days old

Top Remixes

1. Game of Thrones: Season One - Who Stays Behind, Asher or Rodrick?
2. The Wolf Among Us - The Fate of the Crooked Man
3. The Walking Dead: Season One - Does Clementine Kill Lee?



Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.