Hardest Decisions In The Walking Dead Video Game

The Top Ten

1 Shooting or Leaving Lee

It doesn't matter which one you choose because you're still gonna bawl your eyes out. But it's hard to choose which one is sadder. When shooting him, seeing Clem's face before she does it was so sad. But leaving him, looking back at Lee and seeing him fall to his side, dead.. ugh...

It was hard enough to tell a 9 year old girl to kill her guardian angel much less lose the main character

It should be an easy choice in my opinion. Gotta shoot him.

This barely impacts the game. - DapperPickle

2 Shooting Kenny or Letting Jane Die

Should be at number 1. Shooting or leaving Lee won't make any difference since he is dead anyway. Shooting the fresh alive one is harder. - zxm

Too bad that Jane was manipulative, because she know how to kill a walker quickly, has some good strategies.
but the moment when she pushed Kenny and crossed the lines, ignoring what he have been trought wasn't acceptable from her.

Yes, the decision was hard, but I wanted to give a 2nd chance to the wounded man who lost his family and friends first, to the man who apologized for being a douche and put the kids lives before himself.

Jane saying that he was a danger was ironic, since the russians group of Arvo attacked them, both her and Kenny helped to protect their group.

Either kill your friend who would always look out for you but also was insane sometimes, or a manipulative woman who puts an innocent child's life at risk. Hmm, that's a tough one...

Easiest decision in the game. Who should raise a baby? A great father or a selfish psycho?

3 Staying at Wellington or Leaving with Kenny

This was HARD because we know how groups usually end in the apocalypse

But at the same time you want what is best for AJ even if it might not last

I tried staying at Wellington just to see what would happen, but I cried my eyes out, so I reloaded and stayed with Kenny. He's my favorite character and I knew I could never really leave him.

I couldn't leave Kenny, but now I feel like a wimp :(?

I would never leave him, because I love the man so much.

4 Saving Ben or Letting Him Go

Ben would have died if you save him but he was a good character

I had to save Ben because if I was Lee I wouldn't want his blood on my hands. Plus Kenny didn't deserve to have it his way that time

I let him go because I was like "He was gonna die anyway..." - DapperPickle

If you save him he gets one awesome dialogue

5 Agreeing or Disagreeing to Loot the Stranger's Car

Nah, we'll never see these people, not in a million years!

Doesn't go anywhere, except a few lines, sorry. - DapperPickle

Hard decision but ultimately I looted it

To steal

6 Cutting Off or Doing Nothing to Lee's Bitten Arm

Hard decision but cutting of the arm buys you time but at the same time there are so many ladders

I figured it could reverse it right?

Telltale really made this feel significant, but...nope! - DapperPickle

Cutting off

7 Saving Carley or Saving Doug

This one is hard but I went with Carly I liked her a bit better

Plus Doug eats all the biscuits I mean how could he

Guess what? They both die in forced ways anyway! - DapperPickle

Of Course Carley

8 Leaving or Saving Sarah in the Trailer Park

Killed her, like Ben and Duck she deserved it, she caused some major deaths... Like... Loads! - DapperPickle

If you save her she will be useless until she dies because Telltale says so. - DapperPickle

I didn't like Sarah, she was going to die one way or another

I could never be like her but I save her.

9 Helping Save Larry or Helping Kenny Kill Him

Well, let's see... First of all he tried to kill me, then he doesn't give a crap about me when I gave him food (Am I the only one? ) and have him the axe, he saved my life but only to kill the zombie, yeah, lets kill him. - DapperPickle

Larry was an ass

Kenny’s approval or Lilly’s

Also do you really want Clem to see you as a murder

Doesn't matter, Larry is ded. - DapperPickle

10 Shooting Duck or Making Kenny Shoot Him

I couldn't make Kenny shoot his own son

It is so cruel to make even their own son or daughter, so I did it myself.

Guess what? Does crap! - DapperPickle

The Contenders

11 Trying to Help Shawn or Duck at Hershel's Farm

Have somebody’s blood on your hands or lose some approval of Kenny

I chose Shawn cause I figured Kenny could save his own kid

12 Killing or Leaving Clementine

Even though Clementine didn’t actually die, it still was a difficult choice.

13 Shooting Sam (The Dog in Season Two) or Letting Him Suffer

Shoot don't let the dog suffer):

I literally had to stop playing to pull myself together after this part.

14 Killing Both Brothers at the St. John Dairy
15 Leaving Lilly or Letting Her Stay
16 Saving Louis or Saving Violet

Love interest or Best friend ouch

17 Showing or Hiding Lee's Bitten Arm

I didn't want to make anyone panic about it, so I didn't say anything

I could not trust anyone. exception Kenny.

18 Helping Luke or Leaving
19 Fighting David or Showing Him Love

If you don't fight him your idiot he desevered to die in the end

20 Saving Ave or Saving Tripp
21 Inviting or Turning Away Family at Howe's
22 Slapping Luke or Hugging Luke
23 Appealing to Louis or Appealing to Violet
24 Leaving the Gas Station or Killing Stephanie
BAdd New Item