Top Ten Ice Cream Flavors


The Contenders: Page 2

21 Pistachio

Pistachio nuts are so good anyways, but with ice cream it is heaven! Why doesn't everyone who thinks that pistachio ice cream is good, rate it good? I suppose people just think "Hmm, I don't want to vote pistachio even though it is the best... " Join me men and girls! Join the revolution to making pistachio number one!

This is so good. Not many people have tried it and so I'm guessing that is why it's not that popular. But seriously you have to give it a try. Not the one with heaps of little nut bits thought, you need to get the store bought stuff.

I understand that some of you out there are under peer pressure and did not vote pistachio, or have not eaten pistachio. But pistachio will one day have a revolution and it will rise again.

Best underrated flavor!

V 87 Comments
22 Strawberry Cheesecake

I had this in a gourmet shop with my friends and it was creamy and sweet with swirls of strawberry in it. There were four of us and three had that flavour. I usually don't like cheesecake, it's a bit too cheesy, but you couldn't even taste it and it was DELICIOUS

The creamy rich Cheesecake ice cream, with fresh strawberries, and graham cracker bits, this is the best flavor ever!

YES! It is the best flavour! I never get tired of it and it's very reliable. I also like cherry cheesecake flavoured but strawberry is good too! If you haven't tried it yet you defiantly need to! It usually tastes just like cheesecake which I love!

It's awesome

V 6 Comments
23 French Vanilla

Tastes like vanilla... BUT BETTER

That's because it is vanilla. But it comes from France. Which means,10 times better than regular vanilla. - Finn-Mordecai-Gumball

Oh yes it's so creamy and I hope this will be well praised

Best EVER but is the same as vanilla. Should be #1!


V 7 Comments
24 Mango

Mango is just plain delicious. I mean who couldn't like it? It's so sweet fresh and so delicious! GO MANGO! It does deserve to be on the top!

Why isn't this higher up on this list? Mango is the most exotic, sweetest, just Best flavor Ever!

The number one delicious flavor of ice can melt you and you out because it tasted good because it is exotic flavor and unique flavor...i super love it..super will addicted when you taste it...YuMmy...the best flavor in the whole world and that s flavor is MANGO...

THIS SHOULD BE number 1!

V 29 Comments
25 Butter Pecan

This is the best ice cream yet... I can eat this ice cream all day with no problem. One day I had bought 60 pints and ate them all in one day and didn't even throw up not even once. But then the next day my mom got mad at me because I made and mistake in her restroom...

I didn't see this one on the list. How could that be?

Butter Pecan or Butter Pecan? Whichever way you want to pronounce it, your tongue will dance in your mouth. Get some!

Butter Pecan, isn't just an ice cream flavor. It's a way of life! People who like butter pecan ice cream know what is up.

I love Butter Pecan and don't no why it is so underrated, it should at least be number #10! My favorite twist of this is Butter Pecan with Toffee or Coffee.,

V 12 Comments
26 Chocolate Peanut Butter

I'm not sure if this and 'Peanut Butter Cup' count as the same flavour. Either way, peanut butter and ice cream are a match made in heaven. - BKAllmighty

YUMMY! This ice cream is the best. Try it! You will instantly fall in love.

WAY better than peanut butter

Okay now that was good

V 4 Comments
27 Mint Fudge Oreo

Mint is awesome!
Fudge is awesome!
Oreos are awesome!
Combined is very very very awesome!

When I think of mint fudge oreo, I think of an amazing oreo chip, green volcano that just oozes out the deliciousness.

Best ice cream flavor ever why isn't it in the top ten

It's amazing. Oreo, mint, fudge. What could go wrong?

V 3 Comments
28 Lemon

Lemon is one of my favourite flavors of ice cream! It really tastes great! I love it! Please vote the lemon flavor! Go Lemon flavor! Lemon Rocks! Hope you love the lemon flavor too! :-bd

lemon is so good if you get at the right place

Why is lemon on this list last winter my friends gave me a lemon ice cream and it didn't taste like lemon it tasted like piss

Lemon ice cream in Europe is the best!

V 16 Comments
29 Triple Chocolate with Chocolate Chips

I love chocalate so I don't understand why should people like regular chocolate over triple chockolate its more chocolaty than regular and has chocolate chips It's THE BEST IN THE WORLD!

Definitely! Triple chocolate is so tasty. Hm

Too much chocolate

Yu-ummy best flavor in the world!

V 5 Comments
30 Banana

This is a very weird flavor and will probably never get to the top 10, but what the heck it's an awesome flavor. Besides, chocolate ice cream is boring. Let's go unique!

I had fresh made banana ice cream at the beach and I almost died it was so good, I wish they sold it in stores

Banana Ice-cream is AMAZING!

Best. Ice. Cream. Ever.

V 10 Comments
31 Peppermint

It lasts in your mouth and it tastes so good. In general, I love anything that's minty. It's so yummilicious, you know what I mean?

Should be available year round for those of us who love the mint flavor without the chocolate. I love it

The BEST. All year round. Hard to find one with just the right amount of mint and not too creamy.

Good for Christmas time - 1507563

V 8 Comments
32 Cherry Vanilla

Great combination of black cherry halves and smooth vanilla ice cream

Great fruity and chunky flavor of ruby cherries in velvet smooth vanilla ice cream. Also, known as Whitehouse.

It is not available any more in Federal Way, WA

33 S'mores

Are you kidding? If you haven't had this one, your vote shouldn't count!

The Ben & Jerry's one is the best by far. It is delicious and I always have it in my freezer but in the rare moments when the store is out, I become very sad. Nothing can possibly beat s'mores ice cream

I have never herd of this flavour before but it certainly sounds very appealing. A marshmallow and biscuit ice cream. Delicious.

V 3 Comments
34 Coconut

Climb a tree and open the balls on top

Frosty mangos sells the best ice-cream in north queensland

Coconut and chocolate is great


V 7 Comments
35 Dulce de Leche

! BEST ICE CREAM EVER! I mean, seriously? Chocolate? What could get better than caramel ice cream with caramel swirls? NOTHING! If you haven't had this ice cream yet you HAVE to try it.

It's amazing! The creamy caramel just oozes in your mouth! Awesome!

Best ice cream flavor

Relly?! Cookies and cream on the first place?! I think that the ones who voted never tasted other flavours then cookies and cream, chocolate and vanilla. This is caramel ice cream with caramel sirop. It should be the first one!

V 5 Comments
36 Peach

Peach is amazing. You have to try Peach Bellini though.

V 1 Comment
37 Brownie Batter V 1 Comment
38 Chocolate Fudge Brownie V 4 Comments
39 Blueberry

Definitely my all time favorite! So yummy! The color, the smell, the look of it are the perfect combination together

If there was any ice cream better than blueberry ice cream it would be blueberry cheesecake ice cream

This is not my favourite but it is ever so refreshing after a summers day.

When you see a blue ice cream you would give everything for it

V 3 Comments
40 Bubble Gum

I love bubble gum brings back so many child hood memories! Hands down bubble gum ice cream is the best! Even after your finished you still can blow a bubble while you dump your cup in trash.

Bubble gum is the best ever! When your having trouble deciding what flavor to choose, try bubble gum, you can never go wrong with it.

I love Bubble Gum ice cream need to go I'm in class

This should be the best flavour. it's my favourite. kids love this flavour and I'm a kid and I love it bubb-le-gum! bubb-le-gum!

V 24 Comments
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Best Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream Flavors Weirdest Ice Cream Flavors Top Ten Ice Cream Flavors That Go Together Top Ten Best Candies That Could Be Made Into Ice Cream Flavors Best Baskin-Robbin's Ice Cream Flavors

List Stats

16,000 votes
291 listings
10 years, 72 days old

Top Remixes (128)

1. Cookies N' Cream
2. Vanilla
3. Birthday Cake
1. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
2. Cookies N' Cream
3. Chocolate Chip
1. Cherry Vanilla
2. Cookies N' Cream
3. Chocolate

View All 128


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.