Top 10 Most Ignorant and Absurd Music Comments On TheTopTens


The Contenders: Page 3

41 "The host says it's thrash." - about Hail to the King By Avenged Sevenfold

List: Best Thrash Metal Albums

This album Thrash Metal? LOL if it is Thrash then its just ripoffs of Metallica and Megadeth songs plus is this album even metal? Its more Hard Rock if you ask me also who is the Host? This Host guy obviously knows nothing about metal - christangrant

42 "You're all wrong. He's the vocalist for Black Flag." - about David Ellefson of Megadeth

Black Flag has never had a member with this name. And they are not a metal band. The list is "Best Metal Guitarists" (Dave is currently at #58). - Metal_Treasure

Forgot to mention David Ellefson of Megadeth is a bassist, not even a guitarist. - Metal_Treasure

43 "gawd-awful monotony" - about Sacred Worlds by Blind Guardian

But Boogie Chillen' by JLH is the best composed and most progressive song ever... agree - somekindofaguy

44 "Unimaginative lyrics and licks, monotonous vocals... and it's hard rock" - about Hallowed Be Thy Name by Iron Maiden

The statement that Hallowed Be Thy Name by Iron Maiden is hard rock and not metal is as true as all the rest in this sentence. - Metal_Treasure

45 Queen's greatest single lyric line: "We will rock you!" - fun, but pretty meaningless.

Is this really the best Queen line? I mean, it's a song title and not even a line, LOL. - Metal_Treasure

46 "Actually, according to Encyclopaedia Metallum, those bands aren't metal. You are not a metalhead if that is all you listen to." - about Korn, Slipknot, and Linkin Park

Can't say I disagree, but that's a little harsh - Lucretia

Honestly nu metal is like its own genre so I guess they could be called nu metal heads - _Jack_

True - Du

This item wasn't added by me - the comment isn't absurd or ignorant. This comment wasn't written by me but I myself often write the first sentence which is accurate - yes, according to Encyclopaedia Metallum these bands aren't metal and I personally agree with that.
I wouldn't write the 2nd sentence although I think it's true, too, because it’s logical. - Metal_Treasure

47 "I have not listened to their songs [Death] but I have heard of the band. I am much more of a mainstream pop fangirl." - list description to a list this author made about the band Death

Why would you make a list about something you don't know about? - lovefrombadlands

(list - Best Death Songs with Which to Shock Mainstream Pop Fans).
Shortly, the autor of this list had not listened to Death songs but made a list about them... No wonder she put Voice of the Soul at #2 - a soft instrumental that wouldn't shock anyone. - Metal_Treasure

48 Black Sabbath invented Progressive Metal with the album Sabotage

Prog metal went along the lines of prog altogether, with most of its roots coming from bands like ELP and Atomic Rooster. Sabbath came quite a while after them. - naFrovivuS

49 "Metal, and any form of it, it just garbage. The people who like this crap are just senseless humans, who have no taste in anything worth spending your time on!" - Excerpt from comment on Metal on Worst Music Genres list

The whole comment was too long to put here even though the entire thing is awful and quite inaccurate. - Element119

50 "Why is this only #7? Metal hurts my ears! Sure, pop is annoying, rap is unexplainable, country is boring, dubstep is just question marks whenever I hear it, emo is just a mess, and pornogrind is just crappy rock, but metal is the ABSOLUTE WORST!" - Comme

So what does he like then lol? - _Jack_

So right now I am hurting my ears with Wheel Of Time by Blind Guardian?! (sarcasm) - Metal_Treasure

51 "Metal is a bunch of nonsense. It's all just a bunch of useless screaming. Metal fans are a bunch of losers with mental problems who actually think this garbage takes talent to make."

So this person thinks if you like metal, you're a loser with mental problems, let alone the rest of this comment. This is one of the worst comments I've seen on this site. - Element119

I guess such things about metal are written by people who think that screamo and emo are metal when they aren't. Blood on the Dance Floor and similar aren't metal. - Metal_Treasure

52 "You're all wrong. He's the vocalist for Black Flag" - about bassist Dave Ellefson on the list "Best Metal Guitarists" David Warren "Dave" Ellefson is an American bassist and co-founding member of the American thrash metal band Megadeth from 1983-2002 and again from 2010-present.
53 "Marilyn Manson is better than what you think he is." - about Alice Cooper
54 "No one likes lame metal music. Compared to metal, Breadwinners is 100000000x times better."-about Pink Floyd

No one likes, except around 50 million people all around the world. - somekindofaguy

55 “AC/DC is metal”

Actually this is just a common mistake - _Jack_

56 “Metal is just screaming and bashing a guitar”
57 "I'm talking about the bad bands. Not good and true bands like Three Days Grace, Suicide Silence, and The Beatles."

Who the heck compares The Beatles to two bands meant for angsty teenagers? - Aragorn98

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Best Music Comments on TheTopTens Top Ten Music Questions to Ask Users of TheTopTens Top Ten TheTopTens Users With the Best Taste In Music Top Ten Most Overrated Music Artists on TheTopTens Top 10 Music Artists You've Heard of for the First Time Thanks to TheTopTens

List Stats

100 votes
58 listings
2 years, 2 days old

Top Remixes

1. "Writing your own songs doesn't define talent"
2. "Rock is a lot faster than metal."
3. "Ok name me one good metal song why because there are no good metal songs"
1. "Metal music is not a sub genre of rock."
2. "No skills at all!" - about Adam Lambert
3. "she's got an ugly voice" - about Adele
1. "Rock is a lot faster than metal."
2. "Garage-band material" - about Blind Guardian
3. "Metal music is not a sub genre of rock."



Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.