Top Ten Least Mary Sue Warrior Cats
This is a list of the least Mary Sue warrior cats! YAY!Songbird is a brown tabby she-cat with white front paws and amber eyes. She is Morningstar's mate in Battles of the Clans. ( because ) She was killed by an unknown ShadowClan warrior and was expecting kits when she died. Songbird was also an ancient ThunderClan queen. Morningstar mentioned he didn't want anymore deaths or injuries and that they shouldn't have taken on a Clan after driving away a fox. He sees Songbird in a vision. She convinced him to let ThunderClan fight.
~Owlpaw
She's from Battles of the Clans and the most Mary Sue thing about her is her brown fur.
Her death was just horrible. She was expecting kits, too!
A lot of my friends claim the ShadowClan medicine cat, Littlecloud, is a Gary Stu. HOW is he a Gary Stu, poeple? Jeez.
Littlecloud is not a Gary Stu!
"Brambleclaw fought a strong urge to curl up at her paws and whimper like a kit."
I almost cried.
Some more of my friends think Goldenflower is Mary Sue. But she's not!
Gary stu? No! His face is a flaw!
He's my least favorite.
I hate him, but he’s as far from a Gary Stu that you can get. I mean, does he even have any good qualities?
Ivypool is a great character with a good balance of strengths, like her bravery, and flaws like being jealous. She is an average hunter and fighter, or was before going to the Dark Forest. While she is loyal to her Clan and is one of the main characters, she isn't part of the prophecy and doesn't get many chances in the spotlight. Ivypool isn't anywhere near Mary Sue territory. In fact, I just took a Mary Sue test and it says Ivypool is a safe character and not a Sue. (I took the same test for Dovewing, and she's a Sue. )
Ivypool is a great character with flaws, average abilities but still loyal and in my opinion, has a pure heart. Of course she always had her heart in the right place, but that led her to some trouble (dark forest) you might call her a Mary Sue, but seriously, look at her sister. Ivypool is a great warrior, but seriously, her sister,
Yep, she's got a lot of flaws (being jealous, falling for Hawkfrost I mean seriously) but still a good character
Dovewing has a few flaws, but there are many toms padding after her. Bumblestripe, Foxleap (only for a little while, but still), Mousewhisker, Tigerheart. Damn, Dovewing gets ALL the toms. She's also part of a prophecy. Flawless? almost. Described as beautiful? Hmmm lemme check, does it count in the allegiances or just in general. Has many toms padding after her? Yup. Is in a forbidden relationship? Yup. Has kits too. Whiny? Yep. In the spotlight? Yep. In prophecies? Yep.
Dovewing is Basically a mary sue
Dovewing has a lot of flaws, why don't people see that? honestly she's one of the best warrior cats in my opinion
I don't think she's a mary sue, I just think she's annoying and whines way too much.
If people think she's a Mary Sue, then they don't know the true meaning of one.
The most Gary Stu thing about Harespring is the fact that he becomes deputy in Bramblestar's Storm.
Most Gary Stu things- He's a deputy in Bramblestar's Storm, then leader later on.
Pardon? Who? Haha. Probably the most average filler cat in the books. Very not-mary-sue-ish
Just a bit. But honestly her annoying personality as an apprentice made up for it.
Just a little bit is she a Mary Sue but just a little.
She's kind of a Mary Sue to be honest.
I mean, COME ON! Everyone thinks he's a Gary Stu. I'd like 1 GOOD REASON how he is. Jeez.
If he were a Gary Stu, he'd have survived the mudslide, nope. He didn't.
Her birth broke the warrior code, and she killed Ashfur in fear of him revealing the truth over her family. She lived in the tunnels for a while, before rejoining ThunderClan. Hollyleaf was slain by Hawkfrost and spent her last moments with her mother Leafpool saying her last words ”I couldn’t bear to… to leave without knowing my mother.” ...read more.
Flawless? Nope. Described as beautiful? Nope. Has many toms padding after her? Nope. Is in a forbidden relationship? Nope. Whiny? Nope. In the spotlight? Nope. In prophecies? Nope.
HOLLYLEAF IS THE EXACT OPPOSITE OF A MARY-SUE PEOPLE! (I love you Hollyleaf! )
She's my favorite cat. A lot of people hate her, but when u read omen of the stars, she gets better.
I love and miss Hollyleaf. I hate Hawkfrost for killing her. Good grief, though, so uptight.
I love Hollyleaf! She truly cared about the prophecy, poor baby
LOL, Tigerstar is totally not a Gary Stu.
Look, Crow X Leaf is my favorite ship, but... I will admit it's a flaw Leafpool has. She betrayed her Clan, became mates with a cat from a different Clan, she broke the Warrior Code, she broke the Medicine Cat Code, and she had half-Clan kits. If anyone thinks she is a Mary-Sue, they have some serious problems. -FeirceheartOfThunderClan
She fell in love with someone, bad enough, it was a Windclan cat. She had his kits. She lied about it. How far from a Mary sue can you get?!?
She is the complete OPPOSITE of a Sue!
There really is no way to describe her as a Sue..and people stil lsay so because they hate her,
Okay, quick response to the person who said "No. She is the biggest Sue ever created. Name a personality flaw she has and I'll rethink. But she doesn't have any." Okay, maybe she doesn't have any personality flaws. She's happy, cheerful, and sweet all the time. But are you forgetting the fact that she literally can't even feel her hind legs? Here, I'll list the flaws she has. No, not because I hate her, she's my 2nd favourite cat in the series, but to show you that she does have flaws:
1. SHE CAN'T WALK!
2. She can never have a mate
3. She can't have kits
4. She can never be a warrior
5. She was really depressed for almost a whole book.
There, 5 flaws. Is that good enough for you? -FeirceheartOfThunderClan
Killed so much cats
Made kits fight
Betrayed his father
Drove out his mother
Blamed Yellowfang for KILLING kits
I love her, but she's far from a Mary-Sue. She broke the code to have kits with Raggedstar, and she killed her own son! I mean, her son WAS Brokenstar so in her defense he sort of deserved it, but still. -FeirceheartOfThunderClan
NOT A STU! Lots of people think he is. BUT HOW?
Guess who's an unrecognized unappreciated character?