Top Ten Least Scary Creepypastas

The Top Ten
1 Jeff the Killer Jeff the Killer is a creepypasta usually accompanied by a picture of a white face looking in to the camera smiling in an unsettling manner. The creepypasta is also usually accompanied by the term "Go to sleep".

It may not be that scary and it does have its flaws, but I still think it deserves some credit. People who think there's nothing to like about it are just haters; it doesn't have to be super scary to be a good story. It's different and I love it.

No, he isn't the least scariest character. He's the COOLEST character! Like dude, why do people hate Jeff so much? He's cool! To be honest, If I was a boy and I was a creepypasta character, I would be Jeff.

First of all he's fake because someone can die without blinking and also he's 18 and still reminas unwanted by the police while killing people every single night.

2 Cupcakes

Its not scary, the gore in it is dragged out so much it just gets boring after a while.

3 Smile Dog "Smile Dog" is a story about a cursed image file. The image shows a large German Shepard or Husky dog that is smiling.

Is it weird that I think he's cute?

4 Mario.TXT File
5 Sonic.exe

"I was scared because Sonic jump scared me and blood happened."

There. Now you don't have to read sonic.exe.

PS: Thanks for ruining a file extension for everyone, you crappypasta!

This is the twilight of creepypastas. Cliche world.

Can be if done right.

6 Pokemon Black
7 Ash's Coma
8 SpongeBob Bootleg

It was just dumped with distorted audio.

9 Smile Cat

He very cool but allergic to cars

10 Persuaded
The Contenders
11 Slenderman The Slender Man is a fictional supernatural character that originated as an Internet meme created by Something Awful forums user Eric Knudsen

Are you kidding with me he is one of the most scariest sob ever I was very paranoid since last year of August.plus he's real I saw him twice >,> <,<

His name sounds like a fitness program.

I still find him scary for some reason.

12 Where Bad Kids Go
13 My Teddy Bear
14 The Rake
15 Grinny

Smile Dog is a dog and Grinny Cat is a cat. I feel like I know more than you guys who day they ate the same Creepypasta.

Let's rip off smile dog!

16 Herobrine

This is not even scary its just a glitched mob in minecraft they removed anyways he's manly is only used for an antagonist

Stop bullying the poor guy for having different eyes. He needs a friend.

Not scary at all and herobrine is just steve with a smile and white eyes

He just has those white eyes and don't you think he's a little lonely

17 Sally.exe

Sallys not creepy I woulndnt even consider her a creepypasta

18 Ben Drowned

He's my favorite
And he's not really creepy like the others
But his story can give me the chills
So yeah

He is the least scary one. Also he is my favorite one.

He's almost scary

Not scary at all

19 Nina The Killer

Nina the killer is not scary at all like 0% scary but she is still cool I guess

20 Jane the killer Jane the killer is the main character of the creepypasta story Jane the Killer: The real Story. She is know to be a rival to the creepypasta Jeff the Killer.

Ripoff of an already terrible creepypasta.

21 Thomas and the Children
22 Rap Rat
23 Happy Appy
24 Ticci Toby

To me, Toby's story is more sad or emotional than scary. While it is still scary to an extent, I feel as if that isn't the basis of the story. It all is supposed to be deep.

25 Eyeless Jack

Well now I've seen everything why do most creepy pastas I like start with J and so dose my last name.-.

8Load More
PSearch List