Least Scariest Creepypastas


The Top Ten

1 Jeff the Killer Jeff the Killer Jeff the Killer is a creepypasta usually accompanied by a picture of a white face looking in to the camera smiling in an unsettling manner. The creepypasta is also usually accompanied by the term "Go to sleep".

What the beep, he's not so scary but he can be if done right.

The story isn't scary but the picture (not the anime one ) is pretty creepy. - CharismaticKat

Not creepy, just really disturbing. (For me, anyway).

It can be creepy if done correct. - DarkBoi-X

V 4 Comments
2 sonic.exe sonic.exe

Can be if done right. - BorisRule

This is the twilight of creepypastas. Cliche world. - TeamRocket747

"I was scared because Sonic jump scared me and blood happened."

There. Now you don't have to read sonic.exe.

PS: Thanks for ruining a file extension for everyone, you crappypasta!

3 Slenderman Slenderman The Slender Man is a fictional supernatural character that originated as an Internet meme created by Something Awful forums user Eric Knudsen

Are you kidding with me he is one of the most scariest sob ever I was very paranoid since last year of August.plus he's real I saw him twice >,> <,< - Kevinsidis

4 Persuaded
5 Where Bad Kids Go
6 Grinny

Smile Dog is a dog and Grinny Cat is a cat. I feel like I know more than you guys who day they ate the same Creepypasta.

Let's rip off smile dog! - TeamRocket747

Yeah what’s with all the rip offs like”grinny” like COME ON WE ALL KNOW THAT GRINNY IS SMILE DOG

Stop the rip offs already😑"'

7 My Teddy Bear
8 Herobrine Herobrine

How may I ask is a Minecraft character with white eyes scary or creepy in any way? - CharismaticKat

He just has those white eyes and don't you think he's a little lonely

Meh not scary

Not scary at all and herobrine is just steve with a smile and white eyes

V 4 Comments
9 Nina The Killer

Nina the killer is not scary at all like 0% scary but she is still cool I guess

10 Sally.exe

Sallys not creepy I woulndnt even consider her a creepypasta

The Newcomers

? Lazari

Where is Lazari?

? Alice Human Sacrifice

Not sure if it’s real or not but it was on Creepypasta wiki so it counts. I also like it although not scary for me.

The Contenders

11 Jane the killer Jane the killer Jane the killer is the main character of the creepypasta story Jane the Killer: The real Story. She is know to be a rival to the creepypasta Jeff the Killer.

Ripoff - Pokemonfan10

12 Clockwork: Your Time is Up

What a cringefest


13 Happy Appy Happy Appy
14 The Russian Sleep Experiment

A true story?

15 BEN Drowned

Not scary at all

16 Sally Williams

Killer kids are always scary - blackflower

Cause why not? Her story can be one to scare us all. That's why.

17 1999 1999

Okay the picture is sort of creepy looking. - CharismaticKat

The Disneyland 1999 one is lame

This story is a mundane torture porn fest.

18 Squidward's Suicide

That would be more sad than scary.


19 Ticci Toby
20 Laughing Jack Laughing Jack
21 Eyeless Jack Eyeless Jack

Well now I've seen everything why do most creepy pastas I like start with J and so dose my last name.-.

It's not scary. - CharismaticKat

22 Dead Bart

The images about dead bart are just melting homer faces

23 Smile Dog Smile Dog

Agh! It's a husky. So scary. Run for your life! - CharismaticKat

No this is scary. - TeamRocket747

24 Lost Episode Compilation

"DON'T WATCH IT" too late

25 Mizithra


26 Poopsy: I'm Sorry
27 Ronald McDonald House
28 Red
29 Amazing World of Gumball: The Grieving
30 Homicidal Liu
31 Masky
32 Grinny Cat
33 Tired of Luck

Lol this is just about a boy who caused suicide because he had to much luck

34 Are You Sure?

About what?

35 Pinkamena

When has a My little pony character ever been scary a creepypasta about it,GIVE ME A BREAK!

BAdd New Item