Top Ten Mario Games vs Sonic Games

Which Mario game is better or sonic game. The choice is yours

The Top Ten

1 Yoshi Island vs Tails Adventure

Why does it feel like all the comments on this site were made by 12 year olds. They always either go, Sonic sucks and Mario is boss; or Mario is balls and sonic would win any day. They don't even have reason. Although Yoshi Island is a significantly better game as it was made for a much more powerful console with much better graphics and gameplay.

I go with Yoshi Island. Tails Adventure is nothing but back tracking over and over again. - Chaotixhero

Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island gets a 9.5.

Tails Adventure gets a 7.3.

Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island review
Presentation: 10
Characters: 8
Gameplay: 10
Score: 9/10 (Phenomenal to Masterpiece)

Tails' Adventure review
Presentation: 6
Story: 9
Gameplay: 8
8/10 (Strong)

Tell me why you love both games, but prefer Yoshi's Island. I strongly prefer Super Mario World 2 because it has even more of an adventurous feel and is an overal bigger game. As much as I love Tails' Adventure for the fact that Tails, one of my favorite Sonic characters got his own game (please avoid Tails' Skypatrol) and it feels much more upbeat than kiddie.

V 6 Comments
2 Sonic the Hedgehog 3 vs Super Mario Bros 3

Super Mario 3, by a landslide. - nintendofan126

Both games got me really into each respective franchise, or at least had a huge impact. Personally, I prefer Sonic 3 (and Knuckles), but Super Mario Bros. 3 was superb too, for its time (considering Super Mario Bros. 3 came before the whole Sonic franchise)

Both games tie. They are classic and have perfect graphics, classic music, very high nostalgia level and nostalgic gameplay. Sonic 3 has a much better story, though, and it's much less annoying.

Sonic 3 & Knuckles is my favorite video game of all time!

V 9 Comments
3 Sonic Adventure vs Super Mario 64

Super Mario 64 for the win!

Super Mario 64 (the original N64 version) gets a perfect 10/10!

Sonic Adventure (the original Japanese Dreamcast version) gets a 12/20.

Sonic Adventure (the non-Japanese Dreamcast version) gets a not-so-high 7/20.

Super Mario 64 is 64 times better than Sonic Adventure!

I would give Super Mario 64 a 9.9.

I would give Sonic Adventure a 0.1.

I would go with Super Mario 64! Sonic Adventure is just so annoying & with a horrible storyline. , why play this game? The soundtrack should not exist & besides, the 2-D artwork of this game is scary! So Super Mario 64 is going to win no matter what because this game is so amazing! Man, this game is full of awesomeness! Why? The music, the extremely memorable graphics, this game is HD, and the gameplay rocks!

Sonic Adventure Gets A 8.1/10

Super Mario 64 Gets A 9.9/10 - VideoGamefan5

V 14 Comments
4 Sonic CD vs Super Mario World

I pick Super Mario world. The first game that had Yoshi! - nintendofan126

Pick Yoshi against Amy Rose. Amy Rose is cuter, but Yoshi can win better!

Sonic CD for the win. - Chaotixhero

URGH! I can't PICK! Given that CD is my favorite Sonic game, I cannot pick a fave. Both series and games are phenomenal. Well, Sonic is phenomenal sometimes. Mania was good, Forces was okay.

V 12 Comments
5 Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine vs Dr. Mario

I think Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine, by just a little.

Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine gets a 17/20 score.

Dr. Mario gets a 14/20 score.

Dr. Mario because Dr. Robotnik game was based in Sonic cartoon and this cartoon sucks.

V 3 Comments
6 Super Mario Bros. 3 vs. Sonic the Hedgehog 2

Super Mario Bros 3, WHY EVERY PERSON PICKS THE SONIC GAME! - GumballWatterson

Mario 3 ( 9.5/10 ) sonic 2 (9.5/10 ) so draw

7 Sonic Colours vs. Mario Paint

This isn't a very good match. Mario Paint VS. Sonic Colors? Seriously? That doesn't make sense. Why not Super Mario Galaxy 2 VS. Sonic Colors? That would be better.

Whoever put this on thinks Sonic colors is a coloring game for 2 yr. Olds

Sonic Colors. Cause it ain't a five year old game, - DCfnaf

Sonic Colors.

V 1 Comment
8 Super Mario Bros. vs. Sonic the Hedgehog

Sonic won cause better content graphics

9 Sonic Shuffle vs. Mario Party 2

Mario party 2 got 76 sonic shuffle got 56

V 4 Comments
10 Super Mario World vs. Sonic the Hedgehog 3

Sonic the Hedgehog 3. - DCfnaf

The Contenders

11 Luigi's Mansion vs. Shadow the Hedgehog

I say luigi's mansion because shadow the hedgehog was too dark and misanthrope

DEFIANTLY Luigi's Mansion Because It's More Appropriate For Children

Luigi's mansion got 79 shadow the hedgehog got 30

Look, I'd compare Wario World with Shadow instead, but I'm gonna have to go with Luigi Mansion - DCfnaf

V 3 Comments
12 Sonic Schoolhouse vs Mario Type Teaching

Sonic Schoolhouse. I mean, these games are good.

V 1 Comment
13 Super Mario Land vs. Sonic the Hedgehog (Game Gear)

SONIC for the win! Even though I like Mario games better

14 Sonic the Fighter vs Super Smash Bros

Super smash bros. Better game than sonic the fighter. - Chaotixhero

Smash bros no doubter. Super Smash Bros has the BEST local multiplayer in gaming history. - recaller

Super Smash Bros. is perfect in any way & deserves a 9.2.

Sonic the Fighters is good & gets a 6.5.

So therefore, Super Smash Bros. wins. Why? Because it is classic & a crossover. Sonic the Fighers is to hard to play, but nonetheless, it's good.

Super Smash Bros is a crossover and in Brawl and Wii U, sonic appears. - DCfnaf

V 3 Comments
15 Sonic Heroes vs Super Mario Sunshine

Sonic heroes is OK... I mean it has a great soundtrack, bad controls, cheesy lines, and good graphics. I don't know about Mario sunshine because I never played it. But someone told me it have terrible voice acting. - Chaotixhero

Super Mario Sunshine gets 4/10 stars.

Sonic Heroes gets 3/10 stars.

Super Mario Sunshine for the win, but I still believe that Sonic Heeroes has better themes.

Heroes was the first video game I ever played! So definitely Sonic Heroes

Sonic Heroes :D amazing game

V 5 Comments
16 Sonic R vs Mario Kart

Sonic r got 70 Mario kart got 93

Mario Kart, Sonic R sucks Mario Kart gets an 8

Sonic are gets a 2 - MrQuaz680

Mario kart

Sonic R is better than Poopy Head Kart 64!

17 Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins vs. Sonic CD
18 Sonic Lost World vs Super Mario Galaxy

Both games are good but Sonic lost world have better graphics, better music, and better voice acting than Mario Galaxy. Both games have bad controls though. - Chaotixhero

Man I hate them both. How could you like Peach getting kidnapped when after getting free from Bowser, she lets herself have a near-death experience?! And sonic Lost World? Wasn't Mario supposed to be in this game as well as Yoshi & Zelda characters?

It is not true because opinions are not facts. Peach getting kidnapped DOES NOT AFFECT THE GAME. - DCfnaf

Super Mario Galaxy, sonic copied Mario

Well personally, I think Sonic Colors is the better competitor to Super Mario Galaxy, or its sequel.

V 9 Comments
19 Super Mario RPG: The Legend of the Seven Stars vs. Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood

Judging by my name you would guess I love Super Mario RPG over Sonic Chronicles.

In fact, I love them both.

Sonic Chronicles is underrated in my opinion but I've completed the game countless times. But for a Bioware game I think the graphics needed work. Also, I didn't like the music, which was remixes of tracks from the classic Sonic games. I also like how they extended the story about the echidnas! But I wish they had done a sequel or another Sonic RPG. Because that would be AWESOME!

Super Mario RPG had less playable characters and the story was too simple, but it had better graphics. For a SNES game. The music was amazing and I love the level design. There were also many secrets in this game! Like those secret boxes you could find!
It also had those fun mini games! It was also the first game in the series Bowser was an ally. Eggman was too, in Sonic Chronicles! That's so cool to play as villains. I wish there was a sequel. Or another standalone Mario ...more

20 Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island vs. Knuckles' Chaotix


21 Mario Tennis Open vs. Sega Superstars Tennis

Sega superstars tennis I guess, I didn't play Mario open tennis, also sega tennis had characters from other series, not all from 1 like Mario

22 Shadow the Hedgehog vs Wario World

Shadow the hedgehog! That game is awesome. Wario world... not so much

Shadow the Hedgehog gets a 2.8.

Wario World gets a 7.3.

Remember, Shadow is our lord and savior. Definitely Shadow. -shadowswagger922

Wario World. - DCfnaf

V 3 Comments
23 Super Mario Sunshine vs. Sonic Adventure 2

Let's review Super Mario Sunshine.

Sound: 4/10.
Graphics: 4/10.
Music: 4/10.
Difficulty: 10+/10.
Creativity: 2/10.
Worlds/levels: 4/10.
Hub: 3/10.
Voice acting: 2/10 (Princess Peach has the worst voice out of all other Super Mario Sunshine characters).
Gameplay: 5/10.
Nostalgia level: 4/10.
Story: 2/10.
Humor level: 3/10.
Controls: 7/10.
Character sprites: 2/10.
Character designs: 1/10.
Bosses: 5/10.
Visuals: 4/10.
Characters: 4/10 (I strongly hate Princess Peach, though).
Character sprites: 4/10.
Fun factor: 6/10.

I would give this game 3/10 stars.

Let's review Sonic Adventure 2 (and Sonic Adventure 2: Battle)

Sound: 2/10.
Graphics: 5/10.
Music: 2/10.
Difficulty: 10/10.
Creativity: 5/10.
Worlds/levels: 4/10.
Hub: Seriously, why is there no hub?!
Voice acting: 1/10 (8/10 for the Japanese version)
Gameplay: 4/10.
Nostalgia level: 3/10.
Story: 3/10.
Humor level: ...more

24 Wario Land 4 vs. Sonic CD

Honestly I am almost unsure which game is weirder. - xandermartin98

Trust me Wario land 4 is more weirder

Sonic CD. At least there's no Wario.

Wario Land 4 because Wario. - DCfnaf

25 Sonic Advance 2 vs Super Mario Advance 2

Mario advance 2 is nothing but a silly port of super Mario world. Sonic advance 2 is fast and awesome. - Chaotixhero

Super Mario Advance 2 gets 5 stars out of 10. Sonic Advance 2 gets 2 stars out of 10.

Too bad Princess Peach is ruining Super Mario Advance 2 & the Modern Sonic designs on the characters for Sonic Advance 2 is ruining Sonic Advance 2.

26 Sonic the Hedgehog vs. Mario Bros.

The original Sonic the Hedgehog gets an 8.2 in every version.

Mario Bros. gets an 8.1 in every version.

So Sonic the Hedgehog will win.

Both games are AMAZING but Super Mario Bros no doubt wins this one because it saved the video game franchise.

Mario bros ( 9/10 ) sonic 1 (9/10 ) so baffle

Mario Bros is way better than Sonic the Hedeghog. Mario beats Sonic and that's a fact.

V 5 Comments
27 Mario Golf vs. Sonic Golf

There is no such thing as Sonic Golf. - FasterThanSonic

28 Sonic 06 vs Hotel Mario

Hotel Mario is great despite its ridiculous gameplay, but Sonic '06 sucks all the way.

Hotel Mario is 6 times better than Sonic '06.

Hotel Mario gets a 7.2.

Sonic '06 gets a 1.2.

I like Sonic '06 more because it's so much worse.

Sonic 06. I'll take Mephiles over crappy cutscenes. - DCfnaf

V 6 Comments
29 Super Mario Bros. 2 vs. Sonic Heroes
30 Sonic Colors vs. Super Mario Galaxy

Sonic colors all the way. Better soundtrack and better gameplay and graphics then Mario galaxy

Sonic Colors is better than Super Mario Galaxy.

Super Mario Galaxy gets a 2.5.

Sonic Colors gets a 3.5.

Princess Peach was some teenager in this game.

Mario galaxy by a landslide!

V 7 Comments
31 Mario Kart Wii vs Sonic & Sega All Star Racing

Alex Kidd? Vitural fighters? Wow this roaster is better then just Mario characters. I wonder if the make a third one, put in new characters like Pac-Man or Mega Man because if Wreck-it Ralph can race so can those two - Chaotixhero

Mario Kart Wii sucks & gets a 3.2 rating.

Sonic & Sega All-Stars Racing is great and gets a 7.9 in general.

So, Sonic & Sega All-Stars Racing for the win!

Much more variety in stuff plus crossovers make Sonic and Sega All Stars Racing truly Awesome.

Mario Kart Wii - PaperMarioFan

V 6 Comments
32 Sonic Generation vs Super Mario Galaxy 2

Although I never played Super Mario Galaxy 2 the only thing imma say is that Sonic Generations was a great game, the graphics 10/10, Level Design 10/10, voice acting 9/10, Soundtrack 100/10, all in all it was a great game

I love both games, but I'd have to go with sonic generations.

Generations by the way, and I'm also going with Sonic Generations.

Both are amazing, so it's hard to pick. - DCfnaf

V 1 Comment
33 New Super Mario Bros. vs. Sonic Rush Adventure

Sonic Rush Adventure for the win.

Don't know...I guess Sonic Rush Adventure - DCfnaf

New Super Mario brothers of course! - DarkDragon_492

V 2 Comments
34 Donkey Kong vs. Knuckles' Chaotix

Both are great but Knuckles Chaotic have a few problems - Chaotixhero

Donkey Kong gets a 6.4.

Knuckles' Chaotix gets a 9.5.

35 Super Mario 3D World vs. Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric

3D World sucks! I wish this game dies. And Princess Peach was useless. Rosalina is much better in this game.

Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric. People say it was horrible, but I really liked it. Especially that one joke in the beginning. ( eggman: you know what's better than an ambush? Tails: an ambush with ice cream? Eggman: that sound delicious, but no! A post ambush ambush! ) don't judge my sense of humor.

Both games are great in my opinion but Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyrics is a game that I will give a chance to. - Chaotixhero

Super Mario 3D World Gets An 8.9/10

Sonic Boom: Rise Of Lyric Gets An 1/1000000000 - VideoGamefan5

V 4 Comments
36 Sonic Adventure 2 vs. Super Mario 64

Sonic Adventure 2 has an amazing plot, plus it has the amazing Shadow the Hedgehog. Mario 64 is just meh go save the princess again. Sonic Adventure 2 is save the world from being destroyed and defeat some black and red hedgehog that looks like you!

Sonic Adventure 2 is awful & lame.

Super Mario 64 is where it's at!

Sonic Adventure 2 gets a 2.5.

Super Mario 64 is 4 times better, so thus it gets a perfect 10/10 score.

Super Mario 64 is 64 times better than Sonic Adventure 2.

Super Mario 64 gets a perfect 10/10 score on the original N64 version and Sonic Adventure 2 deserves a very bad 0.1 & a half/10 score on both the Dreamcast & GameCube versions.

Super Mario 64 - DCfnaf

V 7 Comments
37 Super Mario World vs. Sonic the Hedgehog

Sonic sucks. Super Mario World is way better.

Sonic is so awesome, he can even pounce Super Mario World at breakneck speeds!
Sonic the Hedgehog gets an A-.
Super Mario World gets a B+.

Super Mario World for me, but both Video Games are awesome for me!
Aren't these two Video Games the two Video Games that started the Mario VS Sonic rivalry in the firs tplace? Or am I msitaken? - HeavyDonkeyKong

Both tie for sure.

Let's review Super Mario World.

Story: 4/10. Uggh, Princess Peach getting kidnapped is ruining my whole life.
Graphics: 10/10.
Sound: 10/10.
Music: 8/10.
Difficulty: 10/10.
Creativity: 9/10.
Worlds/levels: 8/10.
Gameplay: 8/10.
Nostalgia level: 10/10.
Controls: 10/10.

Overall, Super Mario World gets a 9/10 score.

Let's review Sonic the Hedgehog.

Story: 9/10.
Graphics/visuals: 10+/10.
Sound: 10/10.
Music: 10/10.
Difficulty: 10/10.
Creativity: 9/10.
Gameplay: 8/10.
Nostalgia level: 10+/10.
Controls: 10/10.

Sonic the Hedgehog gets a 9/10.

Maybe the original Sonic the Hedgehog wins, by just a little bit.

38 Super Mario 64 DS vs. Sonic Adventure DX: Director's Cut

64 DS is my childhood. - DCfnaf

39 New Super Mario Bros. vs. Sonic the Hedgehog 4: Episode I

Sonic. The Mario show was kinda strange...

Sonic the hedgehog 4 chapter 1 wins

Sonic 4 the win

40 Sonic the Hedgehog 4 Episode 2 vs Super Mario Bros Wii
41 Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood vs. Super Paper Mario

Super Paper Mario for the win! Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood was one of Sonic the Hedgehog's worst!

Sonic chronicles: the Dark brotherhood was too easy. The paper Mario games are all better except for sticker star! Super Paper Mario wins! - HeavyDonkeyKong

Sonic Chronicles, I don't know but Paper Mario was bad so I'm going with the dark brotherhood

Super Paper Mario - DCfnaf

42 Super Mario Galaxy vs. Sonic Generations

Sonic Generations all the way

43 Super Mario Bros. vs. Sonic the Hedgehog 3

Super Mario Bros - GumballWatterson

Sonic 3 - DCfnaf

44 Sonic Genesis vs. Mario's Time Machine

Sonic Genesis. Mario's time machine was terrible. I can at least cut Genesis some slack.

V 1 Comment
45 Sonic Adventure vs. Mario Party

Sonic Adventure gets a 5.

Mario Party gets a 7.

V 1 Comment
46 Super Mario RPG: The Legend of the Seven Stars vs. Sonic Battle

Sonic Battle!

47 Sonic Chronicles vs. Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga
48 Sonic Jam vs. Super Mario Allstars

Super Mario all Stars has multiple games and a special one had super Mario world

Sonic Jam all the way. It is way more fun, and has better characters and graphics.

49 Super Mario Galaxy vs. Sonic '06

Galaxy DUH. - DCfnaf

50 Sonic Shuffle vs. Mario Party 3
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top Ten Most Overhated Super Mario and Sonic the Hedgehog Video Games Top 10 Sonic and Mario Games Top Ten Super Mario and Sonic the Hedgehog Video Game Levels With the Best Music Top Ten Hardest Events In Mario & Sonic at the London 2012 Olympic Games Top Ten Mario and Sonic Video Games With the Best Boxarts

List Stats

200 votes
134 listings
3 years, 128 days old

Top Remixes (4)

1. Super Mario Bros. vs. Sonic the Hedgehog
2. Super Mario Bros. 3 vs. Sonic the Hedgehog 2
3. Super Mario World vs. Sonic the Hedgehog 3
1. Sonic Colours vs. Mario Paint
2. Sonic Shuffle vs. Mario Party 2
3. Yoshi Island vs Tails Adventure
1. Sonic the Hedgehog 3 vs Super Mario Bros 3
2. Yoshi Island vs Tails Adventure
3. Sonic CD vs Super Mario World

View All 4


Creative Comparing #6: Super Mario Bros (NES) vs Sonic the Hedgehog (Sega Genesis)

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.