Top Ten Mario Games vs Sonic Games

Which Mario game is better or sonic game. The choice is yours
The Top Ten
1 Sonic the Hedgehog 3 vs Super Mario Bros 3

Hard choice, both are good games, but I will go with Super Mario Bros. 3.

Sonic the Hedgehog 3 gets an 86/100 score.

Super Mario Bros. 3 (original NES game) gets an 86.5/100 score.
The SNES version of Super Mario Bros. 3 gets a 74/100 score.
The GBA version of Super Mario Bros. 3 gets a 54/100 score.

Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island gets a 99/100 score.
Super Mario Advance 3: Yoshi's Island gets a 66/100 score.

Tails' Adventure gets an 88/100 score.

Super Mario World (original SNES version) gets a 92/100 score.
Super Mario Advance 2: Super Mario World gets a 57/100 score.

Sonic CD gets a 9.1 score and its modern remakes get an 83/100 score.

Dr. Mario (NES version) gets an 84/100. The Game Boy version of Dr. Mario gets a 53/100 score.

Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine gets an 88/100.

Sonic the Fighters gets a 78/100 score.

The original Super Smash Bros. on the N64 gets a 97/100 score.

Sonic ...more

Why compare sonic 3 to super Mario bros. 3 it's not even debatable. Sonic 3 is much better. None of the 2d Mario games before super Mario world were even good. Super Mario bros 3 is not good but it is also not terrible. Sonic 3 vs world is much more debatable. I love both 3 and world but I would have to go with sonic the hedgehog 3 by a bit. It is my favorite game of all time anyways.

Both games got me really into each respective franchise, or at least had a huge impact. Personally, I prefer Sonic 3 (and Knuckles), but Super Mario Bros. 3 was superb too, for its time (considering Super Mario Bros. 3 came before the whole Sonic franchise)

I go with Sonic 3 because it's the game that got me into sonic. It was one of the best days ever. This game rocks. Their are only a few problems I have with this game

1. It's too easy and too short
2. Sonic looks silly compared to his Sonic 1 sprikes.

3. Two worst levels: Marble garden zone and carnival night zone.

2 Yoshi Island vs Tails Adventure

Why does it feel like all the comments on this site were made by 12 year olds. They always either go, Sonic sucks and Mario is boss; or Mario is balls and sonic would win any day. They don't even have reason. Although Yoshi Island is a significantly better game as it was made for a much more powerful console with much better graphics and gameplay.

This comparison is number 1?!?!?! Number 1 should be Sonic 3 and Knuckles vs Super Mario World! That is a much better comparison given that both titles are frequently considered the best out of their respective series!

I go with Yoshi Island. Tails Adventure is nothing but back tracking over and over again.

I love Yoshi's Island and would give this game a 9.8.

Tails' Adventure gets an 8.8 score.

3 Luigi's Mansion vs. Shadow the Hedgehog

Shadow is our lord and savior. Plus, it has guns! Luigi is just some scared person nobody in the games really knows about (that one game where Luigi was called mr green Mario brother guy) -the one and only, shadowswagged922

Look, I'd compare Wario World with Shadow instead, but I'm gonna have to go with Luigi Mansion

I say luigi's mansion because shadow the hedgehog was too dark and misanthrope

DEFIANTLY Luigi's Mansion Because It's More Appropriate For Children

4 Sonic Adventure vs Super Mario 64

I would go with Super Mario 64! Sonic Adventure is just so annoying & with a horrible storyline. , why play this game? The soundtrack should not exist & besides, the 2-D artwork of this game is scary! So Super Mario 64 is going to win no matter what because this game is so amazing! Man, this game is full of awesomeness! Why? The music, the extremely memorable graphics, this game is HD, and the gameplay rocks!

I love the sonic series but only for the classics and generations but to compare adventure to super Mario 64 is insane. The only fun part of adventure was sonics stages and with the rest of the game being crap compared to the masterpiece super Mario 64 that in my opinion is the greatest 3d platform ever is just crazy. Sonic is better in 2d than Mario and Mario is better in 3d than sonic

Super Mario 64 for the win!

Super Mario 64 (the original N64 version) gets a perfect 10/10!

Sonic Adventure (the original Japanese Dreamcast version) gets a 12/20.

Sonic Adventure (the non-Japanese Dreamcast version) gets a not-so-high 7/20.

I hate the red coin star in rainbow ride (Super Mario 64) while in sonic adventure I didn't have any problem with this game

5 Sonic CD vs Super Mario World

These games are equal in terms of gameplay. Both of these games are perfect and are the pinacal of 2D plat forming. In terms of power ups Mario world wins no doubt. Sonic CD bosses destroy any of Mario Worlds bosses. Last Mario and Sonic control perfectly and the level designs are legendary

URGH! I can't PICK! Given that CD is my favorite Sonic game, I cannot pick a fave. Both series and games are phenomenal. Well, Sonic is phenomenal sometimes. Mania was good, Forces was okay.

I would 100% vote for super Mario world because even though sonic CD might be fun, There are horrifying secrets in the game that might give you nightmares.

Pick Yoshi against Amy Rose. Amy Rose is cuter, but Yoshi can win better!

6 Sonic Colours vs. Mario Paint

This isn't a very good match. Mario Paint VS. Sonic Colors? Seriously? That doesn't make sense. Why not Super Mario Galaxy 2 VS. Sonic Colors? That would be better.

Whoever put this on thinks Sonic colors is a coloring game for 2 yr. Olds

Sonic Colors. Cause it ain't a five year old game,

Mario paint got 99 sonic colors got 78

7 New Super Mario Bros. vs. Sonic the Hedgehog 4: Episode I

Sonic. The Mario show was kinda strange...

Sonic the hedgehog 4 chapter 1 wins

Sonic 4 the win

8 Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine vs Dr. Mario

I think Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine, by just a little.

Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine gets a 17/20 score.

Dr. Mario gets a 14/20 score.

Dr Mario got 69 dr robotnik got 74

Dr. Mario because Dr. Robotnik game was based in Sonic cartoon and this cartoon sucks.

9 Sonic 06 vs Hotel Mario

Two worst video games of all times. Sonic 06 hands down. It has a amazing soundtrack and beautiful CGI cut scenes. Hotel Mario is... bleh. I never wanna play that game EVER again. Oh dear hotel Mario sucks

Hotel Mario is great despite its ridiculous gameplay, but Sonic '06 sucks all the way.

Sonic 06 all the time, at least it has better story, levels, and custsense.
I can't call hotel mario a game anymore

Hotel Mario is 6 times better than Sonic '06.

Hotel Mario gets a 7.2.

Sonic '06 gets a 1.2.

10 Sonic Shuffle vs. Mario Party 2

Mario party 2 got 76 sonic shuffle got 56

Sonic shuffle ( 4/10 ) Mario party 2 ( 8/10 )

Sonic Shuffle<Mario Party 2

Kinda unfair match

The Contenders
11 Paper Mario vs. Sonic & the Secret Rings
12 Sonic Schoolhouse vs Mario Type Teaching

Sonic Schoolhouse. I mean, these games are good.

I think Mario Type Teaching

13 Super Mario 3D Land vs. Sonic Generations 3ds

Sonic Generations.

14 Sonic Heroes vs Super Mario Sunshine

Sonic heroes is OK... I mean it has a great soundtrack, bad controls, cheesy lines, and good graphics. I don't know about Mario sunshine because I never played it. But someone told me it have terrible voice acting.

Super Mario Sunshine gets 4/10 stars.

Sonic Heroes gets 3/10 stars.

Super Mario Sunshine for the win, but I still believe that Sonic Heeroes has better themes.

Heroes was the first video game I ever played! So definitely Sonic Heroes

I never played Sunshine but Heroes was a boss game! Gameplay9.5/10
Voices 8/10 Music 10/10 amazing!

15 Sonic R vs Mario Kart

I hate Sonic r looks like stands for rated r

Sonic r sucks if you like it go to hell.

Sonic r got 70 Mario kart got 93

16 Super Mario Bros. vs. Sonic the Hedgehog

Sonic won cause better content graphics

Super Mario Bros revolutionisedo gaming and it's so adicting

17 Sonic Lost World vs Super Mario Galaxy

Man I hate them both. How could you like Peach getting kidnapped when after getting free from Bowser, she lets herself have a near-death experience?! And sonic Lost World? Wasn't Mario supposed to be in this game as well as Yoshi & Zelda characters?

Both games are good but Sonic lost world have better graphics, better music, and better voice acting than Mario Galaxy. Both games have bad controls though.

Sonic didn't copy Mario, all it had was the 360 degree level design, that was all, I liked both games so I'm gonna say a tie

Normally, Sonic is much better than Mario. However, I prefer Super Mario Galaxy over Sonic: Lost World.
Super Mario Galaxy gets a B+, and Sonic: Lost World gets a D.

18 Super Mario RPG: The Legend of the Seven Stars vs. Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood

Judging by my name you would guess I love Super Mario RPG over Sonic Chronicles.

In fact, I love them both.

Sonic Chronicles is underrated in my opinion but I've completed the game countless times. But for a Bioware game I think the graphics needed work. Also, I didn't like the music, which was remixes of tracks from the classic Sonic games. I also like how they extended the story about the echidnas! But I wish they had done a sequel or another Sonic RPG. Because that would be AWESOME!

Super Mario RPG had less playable characters and the story was too simple, but it had better graphics. For a SNES game. The music was amazing and I love the level design. There were also many secrets in this game! Like those secret boxes you could find!
It also had those fun mini games! It was also the first game in the series Bowser was an ally. Eggman was too, in Sonic Chronicles! That's so cool to play as villains. I wish there was a sequel. Or another standalone Mario ...more

19 Sonic the Fighter vs Super Smash Bros

Super Smash Bros. is perfect in any way & deserves a 9.2.

Sonic the Fighters is good & gets a 6.5.

So therefore, Super Smash Bros. wins. Why? Because it is classic & a crossover. Sonic the Fighers is to hard to play, but nonetheless, it's good.

Smash bros no doubter. Super Smash Bros has the BEST local multiplayer in gaming history.

Sonic is in super smash bros so it really doesn't make sense unless it's the 64 version

Super smash bros. Better game than sonic the fighter.

20 Super Mario Bros. vs. Sonic the Hedgehog 2
21 Super Mario Galaxy vs. Sonic '06
22 Sonic Advance 2 vs Super Mario Advance 2

Super Mario Advance 2 gets 5 stars out of 10. Sonic Advance 2 gets 2 stars out of 10.

Too bad Princess Peach is ruining Super Mario Advance 2 & the Modern Sonic designs on the characters for Sonic Advance 2 is ruining Sonic Advance 2.

Mario advance 2 is nothing but a silly port of super Mario world. Sonic advance 2 is fast and awesome.

23 Shadow the Hedgehog vs Wario World

Shadow the hedgehog! That game is awesome. Wario world... not so much

Shadow the Hedgehog gets a 2.8.

Wario World gets a 7.3.

Remember, Shadow is our lord and savior. Definitely Shadow. -shadowswagger922

I hate shadow the hegdehog

24 Mario Tennis Open vs. Sega Superstars Tennis

Sega superstars tennis I guess, I didn't play Mario open tennis, also sega tennis had characters from other series, not all from 1 like Mario

25 Sonic Colors vs. Super Mario Galaxy

These 2 games are there best! Sonic Colors is really fun and I could play it all day! Also, Super Mario Galaxy for a whole week! Sonic Colors< Super Mario Galaxy. Sonic Colors gets 8.9 stars and Super Mario Galaxy gets 9.2!

Super Mario Galaxy is way better. It has way better gameplay and a way better soundtrack than Sonic Colors. Sonic Colors sucks.

I would vote for Sonic colors because it is one of the best sonic games ever and is better than Super Mario Galaxy.

Sonic colors all the way. Better soundtrack and better gameplay and graphics then Mario galaxy

8Load More
PSearch List